Title | HVP No 31 - 28 November 2019 House of Representatives 19 AGRICULTURAL AND VETERINARY CHEMICALS LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (AUSTRALIAN PESTICIDES AND VETERINARY MEDICINES AUTHORITY BOARD AND OTHER IMPROVEMENTS) BILL 2019 |
Database | House Votes and Proceedings |
Date | 28-11-2019 |
Source | House of Reps |
Number | 31 |
Page | 515 |
Status | Final |
Federation Chamber / Main Committee | no |
System Id | chamber/votes/d9e499fd-85b5-458b-923b-dcad4a60dc1d/0020 |
The order of the day having been read for the resumption of the debate on the question—That the bill be now read a second time—
Debate resumed by Mr Fitzgibbon who moved, as an amendment—That all words after “That” be omitted with a view to substituting the following words:
“whilst not declining to give the bill a second reading, the House criticises the Government for repeatedly failing to legislate on agricultural matters in a timely manner”.
Debate ensuing—
Mr Joyce addressing the House—
Closure of Member
Mr Thistlethwaite moved—That the Member be no longer heard.
Question—put.
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—
AYES, 58
Dr Aly |
Dr Freelander |
Ms McBride |
Ms Ryan* |
Ms Bird |
Mr Georganas |
Mr Marles |
Mr Shorten |
Mr Bowen |
Mr Giles |
Mr B. K. Mitchell |
Mr D. P. B. Smith |
Mr Burns |
Mr Gorman |
Mr R. G. Mitchell |
Mr Snowdon |
Mr M. C. Butler |
Mr Gosling |
Dr Mulino |
Ms Stanley* |
Ms T. M. Butler |
Mr Hayes |
Mr Neumann |
Ms Swanson |
Mr Byrne |
Mr Hill |
Ms O’Neil |
Ms Templeman |
Dr Chalmers |
Mr Husic |
Ms Owens |
Mr Thistlethwaite |
Mr Clare |
Mr Jones |
Ms Payne |
Ms Thwaites |
Ms Coker |
Ms Kearney |
Mr Perrett |
Ms Vamvakinou |
Ms Collins |
Mr Keogh |
Mrs Phillips |
Mr Watts |
Mr Conroy |
Mr Khalil |
Ms Plibersek |
Ms Wells |
Mr Dick |
Ms C. F. King |
Ms Rishworth |
Mr J. H. Wilson |
Mr Dreyfus |
Ms M. M. H. King |
Ms Rowland |
Mr Zappia |
Mrs Elliot |
Dr Leigh |
|
NOES, 76
Mr Alexander |
Ms Flint |
Mr Littleproud |
Mr Sharma |
Dr Allen |
Mr Frydenberg |
Ms Liu |
Mr Simmonds |
Mrs K. L. Andrews |
Mr Gee |
Mr McCormack |
Ms Steggall |
Mr K. J. Andrews |
Dr Gillespie |
Mrs McIntosh |
Mr Stevens |
Mrs Archer |
Mr Goodenough |
Dr McVeigh |
Mr Sukkar |
Ms Bell |
Dr Haines |
Mrs Marino |
Mr Taylor |
Mr Broadbent |
Ms Hammond |
Dr Martin |
Mr Tehan |
Mr Buchholz |
Mr Hastie |
Mr Morrison |
Mr Thompson |
Mr D. J. Chester |
Mr Hawke |
Mr Morton |
Mr Tudge |
Mr Christensen |
Mr Hogan |
Mr Ted O’Brien |
Mr van Manen |
Mr Conaghan |
Mr Howarth |
Mr L. S. O’Brien |
Mr Wallace |
Mr Connelly |
Mr Hunt |
Mr Pasin |
Dr Webster |
Mr Coulton |
Mr Irons |
Mr Pearce |
Mrs Wicks |
Mr Drum* |
Mr Joyce |
Mr Pitt |
Mr R. J. Wilson |
Mr Dutton |
Mr C. Kelly |
Mr Porter |
Mr T. R. Wilson |
Mr Entsch |
Mr Laming |
Ms Price |
Mr Wood |
Mr Evans |
Ms Landry |
Mr Ramsey* |
Mr Wyatt |
Mr Falinski |
Mr Leeser |
Mr Robert |
Mr Young |
Mr Fletcher |
Ms Ley |
Ms Sharkie |
Mr Zimmerman |
* Tellers
And so it was negatived.
It being after 1.30 pm, the debate was interrupted in accordance with standing order 43 and the resumption of the debate made an order of the day for a later hour this day.