Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Transcript of doorstop Interview: Ministerial Entrance, Parliament House, Canberra: Wednesday, 15 August 2007: leadership.



Download PDFDownload PDF

Doorstop Interview, Ministerial Entrance, Parliament House, Canberra

Wednesday, 15 August 2007 8.40am

SUBJECTS: Leadership

TREASURER:

Well good morning. Let me say at the outset, I have never urged supporters of mine to carp against the Prime Minister. Nor have I ever urged supporters of mine to do anything which would undermine the Liberal Party. And anybody who wants to have a look at the record knows that and any suggestions that I have told any of my supporters to that effect is completely false.

Michael Brissenden said that I had dinner with him on the 5th of March, 2005. I have extremely accurate records. On the 5th of March 2005, I was in Melbourne at my brother’s birthday party. So that dinner didn’t occur.

I had a dinner with Michael Brissenden on the 2nd of June, 2005. And in the course of that dinner a lot of things were said, a lot of very interesting things were said. But I want to make it clear that I never carped at the Prime Minister nor did I ever go to the backbench. What in fact happened, subsequent to 2005, is that the Prime Minister and I had a discussion and he asked me in 2006, whether I would serve as Treasurer to the term of the election and support the re-election of the Liberal Government in 2007.

I put out a statement that I would do that. I am absolutely focussed on winning the next federal election and I think you would see from the way in which I have brought down two Budgets in 2006 and 2007, that I have been true to my word. I am focussed on winning the next election as Treasurer and supporting the bid of the Prime Minister.

JOURNALIST:

Did you ever say that Mr Howard couldn’t win the next election?

TREASURER:

No, Mr Howard could have beaten Kim Beazley. I think anybody could have beaten Kim Beazley. In the end it was Kevin Rudd that beat Kim Beazley. So I don’t think there is any doubt that Mr Howard could beat Kim Beazley.

JOURNALIST:

So you are denying all that account that the three journalists agreed on?

TREASURER:

Page 1 of 5 The Commonwealth Treasurer - Transcript - Leadership - Doorstop Interview, Minist...

15/08/2007 http://www.treasurer.gov.au/tsr/content/transcripts/2007/118.asp?pf=1

No, what I saying to you, is I never told my supporters to carp at the Prime Minister. I never told, I never went to the backbench, I never carped at the Prime Minister and as you know I never withdrew from the Treasurership. Now, there was no dinner on the date that Michael Brissenden said there was but there was a dinner with Michael Brissenden and I have very accurate records of those dates.

JOURNALIST:

And the other two journalists?

TREASURER:

And the other two journalists. In the course of this discussion - by the way which is an off-the-record discussion - I think that point ought to be made, because I think that is an important point of journalistic ethics - there was a long discussion about politics. I never had any doubt in that discussion that John Howard could beat Kim Beazley who was the Labor leader. I don’t think there was any doubt about that. As I said, in the end the person who beat Kim Beazley was Kevin Rudd for the Labor leadership. But the leadership was being talked about at around these times. You will recall there was a statement made in Athens and there were long discussions about what might happen in Australian politics. I subsequently had a discussion with the Prime Minister. This is all known, this is all on the record. And we discussed the way in which we would go to the election. That was a discussion in 2006. I put out a statement in 2006. I said, at his request, that I would do everything I could to ensure the re-election of the Liberal Government and that is what I have done.

JOURNALIST:

Treasurer, what caused your re-think in the 24 hours after the dinner?

TREASURER:

There wasn’t any re-think. There wasn’t any re-think. Now, Paul, you and I know we have discussions about politics all the time. You have got to remember two years after the event, journalists have decided to rev this issue up long after this was settled 12 months ago. Now, they would do that for their own reasons, obviously. But they are entitled to rev this up for their own reasons. But this matter was settled in 2006 when I put out a statement.

JOURNALIST:

The three journalists all have notes. Are you saying that they have concocted their accounts of the evening?

TREASURER:

No, I am saying they have the wrong night.

JOURNALIST:

Yes but that doesn’t change what was said.

TREASURER:

Well, wouldn’t their notes show the night? That’s the first point. The second point I would say is, journalists who come to dinners with notebooks are not very usual in my experience. But they have taken out of it what they think happened two years ago.

JOURNALIST:

So they didn’t have notebooks with them at the time?

Page 2 of 5 The Commonwealth Treasurer - Transcript - Leadership - Doorstop Interview, Minist...

15/08/2007 http://www.treasurer.gov.au/tsr/content/transcripts/2007/118.asp?pf=1

TREASURER:

I didn’t see them writing any notes. And by the way, if I was giving an interview to journalists, I would have done it on camera, on tape, as I always do, as I am doing now. And by the way, if this had been an on-the-record conversation, I assume it would have been published. But here we are in 2007, this dinner according to my records took place in June of 2005 - it certainly didn’t take place on the 5th of Match - they have their recollections. I am not going to get into arguments with journalists but I am going to point out to you; here at the undeniable facts: Did I become a backbencher? No. Did I carp? No. What did I do? I put out a statement pledging to continue as Treasurer and support the Prime Minister which I have.

JOURNALIST:

Tony Abbott said this morning that you are impatient about becoming Prime Minister.

TREASURER:

Well I think I am pretty patient. I don’t think any person has served in the position as Treasurer longer than me.

JOURNALIST:

Treasurer, did your Press Secretary change the rules of the dinner as it were? There was one understanding at the dinner but within 24 hours…?

TREASURER:

I don’t think so, Paul.

JOURNALIST:

Are you sure that is right?

TREASURER:

I don’t think so. Pretty sure.

JOURNALIST:

So their recollection of the conversation, their recollection of the on-the-record (inaudible).

TREASURER:

I am pretty sure. Because if I was doing an on-the-record interview, not only would you expect a journalist to bring a tape, we would bring one ourselves, wouldn’t we?

JOURNALIST:

I think (inaudible) is not attributable.

TREASURER:

Well I don’t know all of these rules. According to me…

JOURNALIST:

Page 3 of 5 The Commonwealth Treasurer - Transcript - Leadership - Doorstop Interview, Minist...

15/08/2007 http://www.treasurer.gov.au/tsr/content/transcripts/2007/118.asp?pf=1

Mr Costello, of course you do.

TREASURER:

No, I am sorry, I don’t know all of these rules. According to me, if you have something to say to be reported you stand in front of a media camera and you put a tape on it and you say it. That is what I do.

JOURNALIST:

(inaudible) incorrect?

TREASURER:

Pardon?

JOURNALIST:

Their recollection of the conversation and things that…?

TREASURER:

I am saying, look, I am not going to get into an argument with them, they have their recollections, I certainly have mine, but here is the proof. Did anything of what they said would happen, happen? No.

JOURNALIST:

But did you threaten at that dinner…?

TREASURER:

No, hang on. Did anything of what they said would happen, happen? Bear in mind this is two years ago. Nothing happened. Have a look at the record and these matters were resolved and brought to finality last year. So, you know, it is all an interesting academic debate, isn’t it, of what happened in 2005? You don’t need to go back to 2005 because we have had two years to assess what happened and it is all there. It is there for the world to see.

JOURNALIST:

Yes or no though, Treasurer, did you say at that dinner in 2005, that you had set April 2006 as the deadline, the mid-term for challenging Mr Howard?

TREASURER:

No, the journalists have very different recollections to what I have and did I set April? No. Did I set April? No. Did anything happen in April? No.

JOURNALIST:

But did you say…?

TREASURER:

Did I go to the backbench? No. All of these things…

Page 4 of 5 The Commonwealth Treasurer - Transcript - Leadership - Doorstop Interview, Minist...

15/08/2007 http://www.treasurer.gov.au/tsr/content/transcripts/2007/118.asp?pf=1

JOURNALIST:

Does that mean…?

TREASURER:

Hang on, all of these things which you know, in their recollection were going to happen, didn’t happen. And so, you know, it is an interesting discussion isn’t it, about what was said two years ago, that the outcome of it is nothing happened?

JOURNALIST:

Did you say you would challenge for the leadership?

TREASURER:

No.

JOURNALIST:

(inaudible) yesterday on television when you said you absolutely denied saying…?

TREASURER:

I absolutely deny ever saying to any of my supporters, absolutely…

JOURNALIST:

Do you absolutely deny saying (inaudible)?

TREASURER:

…that they should, they carp, I absolutely deny saying that I would go to the backbench. I didn’t do it and therein lies the tale. Thank you. Thank you.

© Commonwealth of Australia 2000

Page 5 of 5 The Commonwealth Treasurer - Transcript - Leadership - Doorstop Interview, Minist...

15/08/2007 http://www.treasurer.gov.au/tsr/content/transcripts/2007/118.asp?pf=1