Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Transcript of interview with Virginia Trioli: ABC News Breakfast: 31 July 2018: Trade agenda, Belt and Road Initiative, infrastructure partnership, Longman by-election, company tax cuts



Download PDFDownload PDF

ABC News Breakfast interview Trade agenda, Belt and Road Initiative, infrastructure partnership, Longman by-election, company tax cuts

Transcript, E&OE

31 July 2018

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Today Trade Minister Steve Ciobo will deliver a speech in Melbourne outlining what our

future looks like and, of course, our involvement in the so-called One Road, One Belt initiative out of China.

Mr. Ciobo joins us now in the studio. Minister, good morning, thanks for joining us.

STEVEN CIOBO: Good to be with you, Virginia.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: With all of those elements in play and such extraordinary uncertainty, what's the one

key way that Australia can punch through on a trade basis?

STEVEN CIOBO: Diversification. We need to make sure that we continue to engage not only with our

region, but more broadly across the world. That's why right now we've got underway negotiations with the

European Union, we've got negotiations underway with Latin American countries. We've already got, of

course, the foundation stones of our trade relationship, the big bilateral relationships that we have with

China, with Japan, with Korea, with the United States. All of that about maximizing opportunities for

Australian businesses to export to the world.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: That, of course, is how it plays out in an ideal world. But when you've got these fluxes in

place and when we basically, to be honest here, used to get knocked to the sidelines a bit because they’re

the bigger players. What actually is the power and influence that we have? Can you specifically define that

for us this morning? About how we get through.

STEVEN CIOBO: Australia's very committed, of course, to the multilateral trading system. So in other

words, the World Trade Organization. We don't wanna revert back to a world where might is right. We want

to be in a world where there are rules that everyone can abide by, and know that that's going to be the best

approach on trade.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: I get that, but my question goes to something else.

STEVEN CIOBO: Sure.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Which is, when you've got these big players, in this huge Punch and Judy match, and

we still want to be able to come in and trade at some level, what's the specific power and influence we

have? Can you describe it for us?

STEVEN CIOBO: I don't think it's about power and influence, Virginia. I think what it's about-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Because you’re going to need to have some of that-

STEVEN CIOBO: What I'm saying is, what it's actually about is our ability to mobilise and to be able to

secure trade deals, and that's what we've done. You know, what you're saying and highlighting with respect

to, you know, the United States and China, absolutely is the case, but if you look at-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: And also, also Britain and the European Union because they're so caught up in that,

themselves.

STEVEN CIOBO: Sure. But if you look at the results, the run record, so to speak, over the past several

years, it's been outstanding. And we've done trade deals now, the most significant one, making sure that

we've maintained and kept in place the TPP-11, the Trans-Pacific Partnership 11, which gives us access to

trillions and trillions of dollars of economic activity. But now we've been able to capitalise on Australia's

standing globally, to put in place negotiations with huge markets, including the European Union, 500 million

people; bilateral discussions with the UK, for when they formally exit. Indonesia, Hong Kong, Peru, Pacific

Alliance countries; Mexico, Columbia, Chile, Peru, so it's a long list. But I'll go back to the point, which is it’s

all about driving exports, because ultimately, if we can export more as a country, we earn more as a

country, and we create more employment here in Australia.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: And we know that a release has been a put out this morning, I think by the Foreign

Minister, on the trilateral arrangement now, which takes in the Memorandum of Understanding, that's been

signed between Australia and China, over their so-called One Belt, One Road infrastructure program. The

Government is refusing to release the agreement that it's signed with China, the details of it-

STEVEN CIOBO: That's not strictly true, actually.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Let me ask my question, and you can clarify it for me.

STEVEN CIOBO: Sure.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Okay. As we understand it, you've been FOI'd over that MOU, and the reason we were

given that the specific MOU won't be released is, and quote, “it could upset Beijing”. Explain to us this

morning if you're not doing that, or better, you can tell us what you actually are doing. How, if that's the

case, if that doesn't confirm everyone's suspicions about this arrangement being one of secrecy, a lack of

transparency, and China's worrying power in the region. So, first of all tell us what you are doing, if that's

wrong?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, it's wrong because, the simple fact is that it requires both parties to agree, and

China hasn't agreed to releasing it. So that’s the reason why. It's not that the Australian Government

doesn't want it released, it's that China has not agreed to release it.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Let me ask you then, at the time of signing, did your Government, our Government,

stipulate that the MOU should be made publicly available, and did China disagree?

STEVEN CIOBO: Look, I would need to find out about that, off the top of my head I can't answer that

question, Virginia, but-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Well, as I understand from a report this morning in the Fairfax press, that question has

been asked of the Government, but you guys haven't got back with an answer. So would you like to answer

now?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, I just said to you. I'm very happy to go back and find out what-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: So, in the intervening time, you've not tried to find out an answer to that?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, what, who the journalist spoke to at the Department of Foreign Affairs, I don't know

if we can find that out-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But wouldn't that be a key understanding? You would know that, wouldn't you?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, hang on Virginia. Hang on, hang on. Just let me answer some of your questions,

rather than pepper me with 20 questions and don’t give me a chance to answer.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Well, you gave me your answer, you just said you don’t know and you haven’t found

out.

STEVEN CIOBO: So, again, I'll answer the question, rather than. You ask them, and I'm happy to answer

them. So my point is simply this, that when I signed the MOU with China on the BRI, Belt and Road

Initiative, of course Australia remains absolutely committed to making sure we can be part of regional

movements to improve the lot of Asia. Now, China's got a vision about how to do that, that’s through BRI.

The MOU that I signed with China, and bear in mind it is a Memorandum of Understanding. It's not a

commitment to do something, it's a memorandum, a fundamental issue around principles. And that was for

cooperation between Australia and China in third countries, where we think that there's benefit for both of

us to be able to work together.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Sure.

STEVEN CIOBO: Now, I actually signed the document, of course, I've had the chance to read it and

peruse it, and there's nothing in there that causes me particular concern. But to go back to the mechanics

of what you were asking-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: So, I will jump in there, because I say what you're saying then, actually makes less and

less and less of a case for not making it absolutely public.

STEVEN CIOBO: And you know what, and take that up with the Chinese Government. But from Australia's

perspective, I'm very happy for that to be out there. But it requires the agreement of both parties, and so

China needs to agree to release it as well.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But you see the problem. So this is actually what is in the minds of so many Australians,

and indeed in the minds of our intelligence agencies, that there is so much secrecy from the Chinese end

that the Australian Government would even agree to go ahead, and say okay, no, let me finish-

STEVEN CIOBO: Sure.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: We would like to have this released, it's important to us, we agree with transparency, it

matters to the private sector here in Australia. Oh, you won't agree to release it, oh well, fine. That's

bothersome. Do you see that?

STEVEN CIOBO: Look, I mean the Australian Government, of course, operates on very different principles

to the Chinese Government-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: So how can we have faith in the process in that way if we can't even see the MOU?

STEVEN CIOBO: I'm not going to lecture the Chinese Government about how they should conduct their

internal affairs. That's up to China. I could bring an approach of transparency from the Australian

Government perspective and I'm very happy to do that. But ultimately, Virginia, if you’re saying, well ‘why

doesn't Australia tell China how to act’? Well look, ultimately that's up to the Chinese Government.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: In relation to deals with us, yes. In relation to do with Australia, yes.

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, in relation to the MOU, I think what matters most to Australian businesses is, and

what I genuinely think matters most to Australian businesses, is that they have the opportunity to

participate in infrastructure provisioning across the region. That's what I'm focused on. If we can get more

Australian businesses involved in that side of being involved in infrastructure for the region, that's going to

be good for Australian business and good for Australian workers.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: I can imagine many people are thinking, only if it is transparent and corruption free and I

guess, we’ll-

STEVEN CIOBO: But those principles, of course. Virginia, if you're suggesting that the Australian

Government would sign up to something that promotes corruption or promotes principles that run against

those principles the Australian Government operates, well, of course, that's not the case. That's completely

false. And I just made specific reference to that just before.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Let me ask you about the aftermath of the Super Saturday. You know better than others

that you have to have a, you know, big vote in South East Queensland in order to you know, take the

election and to win. Why are those voters in that part of the world so enamored of One Nation, and not

you?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, I don't think that's the case. We, of course-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: A good 17 per cent for One Nation.

STEVEN CIOBO: -and you know what, and we see a fair chunk of that was flying back to Labor. So it's not

about being more than the Coalition or more than Labor. But the fact is that we all need to demonstrate that

ultimately, government in Australia is either going to be a high taxing Labor Government, or a Coalition that

has a lower tax profile. That's the fundamental choice.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: That's not what I asked, that’s not what I asked you. Why are they not enamored of

you?

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, you could easily say why are they not enamored of the Labor Party as well?

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: I’ll ask that of them. Of you, I'll ask, why are they not enamored with you?

STEVEN CIOBO: Obviously, I disagree with the assertion in your question. I mean, I do think that the

Coalition-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But you didn’t pick up a seat so they mustn’t be.

STEVEN CIOBO: Well, it was a by-election. A Government hasn't won a by-election for 98 years.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But you were there campaigning, hoping that you wouldn’t; didn’t you-

STEVEN CIOBO: Let’s not pretend. Of course. We're always going to campaign, hoping to pick up a seat-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: But you can't have it both ways, you can't say oh you know, history will never let us win.

STEVEN CIOBO: Virginia that's ridiculous. The fact is, the Government is always-

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: I guess you should never campaign in by-elections then?

STEVEN CIOBO: -gonna put its best foot forward. Always. But to suggest that because we didn't pick up a

seat, as indeed no government has for 98 years, that that in some way, you know, is an upset of the apple

cart, I mean that's preposterous.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Steve Ciobo, would you like to see this final bit of the company tax cuts policy ditched?

STEVEN CIOBO: No, I absolutely think the Coalition will always be lower taxing than Labor. We have got

to make sure that we are competitive globally, because if we are not competitive globally, that money will

go to other counties around the world, and Australia will suffer the consequences.

VIRGINIA TRIOLI: Steve Ciobo, good to talk to you, thank you.

STEVEN CIOBO: Good to speak with you