Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document

    15   Parliamentary Service Amendment (Parliamentary Budget Officer) Bill 2011

The order of the day having been read for the further consideration in detail of the bill—

Mr Hockey moved Opposition amendment (2).

Debate continued.

Mr Pyne addressing the House—

 

 

 

Adjournment negatived

It being 9.30 p.m.—The question was proposed—That the House do now adjourn.

Mr Albanese (Leader of the House) requiring the question to be put immediately without debate—

Question—put.

*164

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 68

Mr Adams

Mr Danby

Mr S. P. Jones

Ms Parke

Mr Albanese

Mrs D’Ath

Dr M. J. Kelly

Mr Perrett

Mr Bandt

Mr Dreyfus

Ms King

Ms Plibersek

Ms Bird

Mrs Elliot

Dr Leigh

Mr Ripoll

Mr Bowen

Ms Ellis

Ms Livermore

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bradbury

Dr Emerson

Mr Lyons

Ms Rowland

Ms Brodtmann

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mr McClelland

Ms Saffin

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms Macklin

Mr Shorten

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Marles

Mr Sidebottom

Mr Butler

Mr Georganas

Mr Melham

Mr S. F. Smith

Mr Byrne

Mr Gibbons

Mr Mitchell

Ms Smyth

Mr Champion

Mr Gray

Mr Murphy

Mr Snowdon

Mr Cheeseman

Ms Grierson

Mr Neumann

Mr Swan

Mr Clare

Mr Griffin

Mr Oakeshott

Mr C. R. Thomson

Ms Collins

Ms Hall*

Mr O’Connor

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Combet

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neill

Mr Wilkie

Mr Crean

Mr Husic*

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

 

 

 

Debate continued.

Question—That the amendment be agreed to—put.

*165

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Dr M. J. Kelly

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Ms King

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Dr Leigh

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Ms Livermore

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr Lyons

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mr McClelland

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms Macklin

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Marles

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Melham

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Mitchell

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Murphy

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Neumann

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr Oakeshott

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Mr O’Connor

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neill

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Owens

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Ms Parke

 

Mr Danby

Mr Katter

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Mr Hockey, by leave, moved Opposition amendments (3) to (5) together.

Question—That the amendments be agreed to—put.

*166

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 68

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Coulton*

Mr Katter

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Crook

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Entsch

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Fletcher

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

NOES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Parke

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Mr Perrett

 

Mr Danby

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Mr Hockey, by leave, moved Opposition amendments (6) and (7) together.

Debate continued.

Question—That the amendments be agreed to—put.

*167

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 70

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Ms Parke

 

Mr Danby

Mr Katter

Mr Perrett

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Mr Hockey, by leave, moved Opposition amendments (8), (10) and (11) together.

Question—That the amendments be agreed to—put.

*168

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Parke

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Mr Perrett

 

Mr Danby

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Mr Hockey moved Opposition amendment (9).

Question—That the amendment be agreed to—put.

*169

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Parke

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Mr Perrett

 

Mr Danby

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Mr Hockey moved Opposition amendment (12).

Question—That the amendment be agreed to—put.

*170

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

NOES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Parke

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Mr Perrett

 

Mr Danby

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was negatived.

Question—That the bill be agreed to—put.

*171

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 69

Mr Adams

Mrs D’Ath

Ms King

Mr Ripoll

Mr Albanese

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rishworth

Mr Bandt

Mrs Elliot

Ms Livermore

Ms Rowland

Ms Bird

Ms Ellis

Mr Lyons

Ms Saffin

Mr Bowen

Dr Emerson

Mr McClelland

Mr Shorten

Mr Bradbury

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Ms Macklin

Mr Sidebottom

Ms Brodtmann

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Mr S. F. Smith

Ms A. E. Burke

Mr Garrett

Mr Melham

Ms Smyth

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Georganas

Mr Mitchell

Mr Snowdon

Mr Butler

Mr Gibbons

Mr Murphy

Mr Swan

Mr Byrne

Mr Gray

Mr Neumann

Mr C. R. Thomson

Mr Champion

Ms Grierson

Mr Oakeshott

Ms Vamvakinou

Mr Cheeseman

Mr Griffin

Mr O’Connor

Mr Wilkie

Mr Clare

Ms Hall*

Ms O’Neill

Mr Windsor

Ms Collins

Mr Hayes

Ms Owens

Mr Zappia

Mr Combet

Mr Husic*

Ms Parke

 

Mr Crean

Mr S. P. Jones

Mr Perrett

 

Mr Danby

Dr M. J. Kelly

Ms Plibersek

 

NOES, 67

Mr Alexander

Mr Forrest

Mr McCormack

Mr Ruddock

Mr K. J. Andrews

Mr Frydenberg

Mr Macfarlane

Mr Scott

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Ms Gambaro

Ms Marino

Mr Secker*

Mr Baldwin

Mrs Gash

Mrs Markus

Mr Simpkins

Mr Billson

Mrs Griggs

Mr Matheson

Mr Slipper

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mrs Mirabella

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Ms J. I. Bishop

Mr Hartsuyker

Mr Morrison

Dr Southcott

Mr Briggs

Mr A. G. Hawke

Mr Neville

Dr Stone

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hockey

Mr O’Dowd

Mr Tehan

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hunt

Ms O’Dwyer

Mr Truss

Mr Chester

Mr Irons

Mrs Prentice

Mr Tudge

Mr Christensen

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cobb

Mr E. T. Jones

Mr Ramsey

Mr van Manen

Mr Coulton*

Mr Keenan

Mr Randall

Mr Vasta

Mr Crook

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Robb

Dr Washer

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Robert

Mr Wyatt

Mr Fletcher

Ms Ley

Mr Wyatt Roy

 

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Gillard                      Mr Abbott

Mr K. J. Thomson          Mr Ciobo

Ms Roxon                      Mr Dutton

Mr Rudd                         Mr Schultz

Mr M. J. Ferguson         Mrs Moylan

Mr Symon                      Mr Somlyay

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

The House continuing to sit until after midnight—

Wednesday, 21 September 2011

Consideration in detail concluded.

On the motion of Mr Bradbury (Parliamentary Secretary to the Treasurer), by leave, the bill was read a third time.