Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Transcript of interview with Ashleigh Gillon: Sky News Lunchtime Agenda, ALP National Conference: 3 December 2011: Same-sex marriage, uranium sales to India, asylum-seekers, ALP reform



Download PDFDownload PDF

The Hon Dr Craig Emerson MP Australian Minister for Trade and Competitiveness Sky News Lunchtime Agenda, ALP National Conference Subjects: Same-sex marriage, uranium sales to India, asylum-seekers, ALP reform.

Transcript, E&OE

3 December 2011

ASHLEIGH GILLON: Joining me here at the Conference now is Federal Trade Minister Craig Emerson. You can see

from these shots outside that there are thousands of people turning out to this rally. We can see a lot of same-sex

couples there. If it does come to this point in the Parliament where we see a Private Member's Bill, would you support

their right to get married?

CRAIG EMERSON: I'll actually support the retention of the Marriage Act as a union between a man and a woman.

There are deeply-held views, and they are being expressed here today by those who want to see a change. There are

deeply-held views by those who do not want to see change who aren't here today, but nevertheless hold those views

just as legitimately as those who are here have their view. And I think we need to respect that. The diversity of views

within the Labor Party reflects the diversity of views within the broader community. And we saw that occur on the floor

of the Conference today. Certainly, the Prime Minister had indicated that we should have robust but respectful debate. I

think it passed both those tests.

GILLON: If we did see it get to that point - if there were a vote on the Parliament floor - would you suggest that the

Marriage Act wouldn't be changed, because there would be enough people like you who would go against the Labor

Party's platform, to not support any changes to the Marriage Act?

EMERSON: Well, I think that's right. We'd see what the Coalition does. It is interesting that they pride themselves on

allowing people to vote according to their conscience - to cross the floor. They say that the Labor Party is too strait-jacketed; that people tell people how to vote. But on this one, Mr Abbott is saying that he would tell his Members how

to vote. If they comply with Mr Abbott's demands, then that would mean all of the Coalition would vote to retain the

Marriage Act. And a significant proportion of the Labor Caucus would also do that, so therefore the status quo would be

retained.

GILLON: We did see senior figures from the Right warning that the decision to support gay marriage, in terms of the

Labor Party platform, that that decision would be politically damaging; that you would feel the electoral pain at the next

election. Do you think that's the case?

EMERSON: Well, it may be; it may not be. Let's see how it plays out. What I do is respect the right of Party members

to have debates at conferences like this. I respect the majority view of a conference. And the majority view is to change

the platform, but at the same time to enable a conscience vote to occur. I respect the alternative view. And I think that

is one of the strengths of the Labor Party: that we do represent a broad church. And there is a diversity of views, which

reflects the diversity of views in the community. And it's important that people have the right to express their views here

today. But there are also people from other perspectives and other communities who have different views, and we

should respect those as well.

GILLON: Just to let our viewers know that we are going to be taking you live to that rally shortly. We are expecting

Labor MP Stephen Jones to be addressing the gathered crowd, which is numbering I would say at least over 10,000. It

is very difficult to tell from this vantage point, but as I say the numbers of people walking from Hyde Park just

continuing to stream in, and walking around Darling Harbour here, as you can see from those live pictures.

Craig Emerson, just moving on to a couple of the big issues at this Conference: we are going to see a debate over

uranium sales to India. We have the Queensland representatives here, WA ... they're actually against uranium mining,

full stop, the Labor Party in those states. As Trade Minister, how damaging do you think that view is in terms of not

wanting uranium mining at all? Is there sovereign risk there?

EMERSON: No, not at all. I mean it is a question of the position of Australia on these matters; the position of the

Government of the day, rather than the fact that people in a political party have a view. The Government of the day is a

Labor Government, and it is likely that the Labor Government will allow uranium sales to India under, obviously, strict

safeguards to ensure that it is used for peaceful purposes - which is, by the way, good for lifting 10s of millions, if not

Page 1 of 2 Sky News Lunchtime Agenda, ALP National Conference, tra...

28/03/2012 http://www.trademinister.gov.au/transcripts/2011/ce_tr_1112...

100s of millions, of Indians from poverty. Because so many poor Indians have access to electricity for less than half the

day. So it is good for poverty alleviation; it's good for job-creation here in Australia; and for all of those people who are

very concerned about climate change, this is a technology that emits no carbon into the atmosphere.

GILLON: Another issue: just after the lunch break we are going to see the focus return to the immigration debate. Chris

Bowen is going to be pushing for the refugee intake to be supported. He's also going to call on the Conference to

support the Malaysia solution. What do you expect the outcome to be of those debates?

EMERSON: Brendan [O'Connor] is one of the relevant Minsters here, along with Chris Bowen, who is the Immigration

Minister. If we do spend a little time at this Conference talking about Left and Right, I think that's legitimate because it is

relevant to these considerations. Ordinarily, in an interview like this I wouldn't be talking about Left, Right and Left Right

Out, the Extreme Centre Faction and all that sort of stuff. But Brendan's from the Left, and that's significant because he

will actually be supporting offshore processing on compassionate grounds; that is, to minimise the risk of people dying

at sea. That is a compassionate action. And that's what he'll be supporting, along with Chris Bowen, representing the

Right. And so I would think that that view - enabling offshore processing - would prevail. And, again, I'm a very strong

supporter of increasing the intake for refugees - because we are a big country; we can handle refugees. It's just an

argument about an orderly refugee program, and ensuring that we're not encouraging people to take those risky

journeys and lose their lives at sea.

GILLON: Another debate we're going to see is about Labor Party reform, and in particular the election of delegates to

this Conference. Are you expecting that we will see the rank and file have more of a say?

EMERSON: There are specific proposals that have been developed by Sam Dastyari from New South Wales, and they

will be put to the Conference. Again, there is a diversity of views here. And that's why I think it is good that we have

these sorts of conferences, that are not anaesthetised. I've been following or involved in Labor Party Conferences

since when I was a staffer for Peter Walsh way back in 1984. And I cannot recall one robust conference that caused

the Labor Party any damage. I think what people see there is passion, and an interest in ideas for the country's future.

That's a good thing; you don't really see a lot of that in the Liberal Party. They all say 'we're all for the one thing'. We do

have a diversity of views, and we settle those in the contest of ideas at the National Conference.

GILLON: Craig Emerson, thank you for your time.

Media enquiries

Minister Emerson's Office: (02) 6277 7420 ■

DFAT Media Liaison: (02) 6261 1555 ■

Page 2 of 2 Sky News Lunchtime Agenda, ALP National Conference, tra...

28/03/2012 http://www.trademinister.gov.au/transcripts/2011/ce_tr_1112...