

- Title
BILLS
Restoring Territory Rights Bill 2022
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
01-12-2022
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
47
- Electorate
Victoria
- Interjector
- Page
2783
- Party
AG
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Rice, Sen Janet
- Stage
Restoring Territory Rights Bill 2022
- Type
- Context
BILLS
- System Id
chamber/hansards/26124/0420


Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
-
BILLS
- Commonwealth Electoral Amendment (Banning Dirty Donations) Bill 2022
-
Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Bill 2022
-
In Committee
- McGrath, Sen James (The TEMPORARY CHAIR)
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Watt, Sen Murray
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson, Sen Pauline
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Henderson, Sen Sarah
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Henderson, Sen Sarah
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Henderson, Sen Sarah
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Henderson, Sen Sarah
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Ayres, Sen Tim
-
In Committee
- MINISTRY
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- DOCUMENTS
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
-
BILLS
- Treasury Laws Amendment (2022 Measures No. 4) Bill 2022, Treasury Laws Amendment (2022 Measures No. 5) Bill 2022
- Defence Home Ownership Assistance Scheme Amendment Bill 2022, Social Services and Other Legislation Amendment (Incentivising Pensioners to Downsize) Bill 2022, Atomic Energy Amendment (Mine Rehabilitation and Closure) Bill 2022, Education Legislation Amendment (2022 Measures No. 1) Bill 2022, Emergency Response Fund Amendment (Disaster Ready Fund) Bill 2022, Family Assistance Legislation Amendment (Cheaper Child Care) Bill 2022
-
Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Bill 2022
-
In Committee
- Chandler, Sen Claire (The TEMPORARY CHAIR)
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Chisholm, Sen Anthony
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- Pocock, Sen David
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Division
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Division
- Pocock, Sen Barbara
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- Roberts, Sen Malcolm
- Canavan, Sen Matthew
- Antic, Sen Alex
- Rennick, Sen Gerard
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
-
In Committee
-
Restoring Territory Rights Bill 2022
-
In Committee
- Nampijinpa Price, Sen Jacinta
- Gallagher, Sen Katy
- Scarr, Sen Paul
- O'Sullivan, Sen Matt
- Liddle, Sen Kerrynne
- Pocock, Sen David
- Steele-John, Sen Jordon
- Tyrrell, Sen Tammy
- Roberts, Sen Malcolm
- Birmingham, Sen Simon
- Shoebridge, Sen David
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- O'Neill, Sen Deborah
- Pocock, Sen David
- O'Neill, Sen Deborah
- McCarthy, Sen Malarndirri
- McKenzie, Sen Bridget
- Pocock, Sen David
- Rice, Sen Janet
- Allman-Payne, Sen Penny
- O'Neill, Sen Deborah
- Nampijinpa Price, Sen Jacinta
- Division
- Adoption of Report
- Third Reading
-
In Committee
-
Fair Work Legislation Amendment (Secure Jobs, Better Pay) Bill 2022
-
In Committee
- O'Sullivan, Sen Matt (The TEMPORARY CHAIR)
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- McKenzie, Sen Bridget
- Birmingham, Sen Simon
- McKim, Sen Nick
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Birmingham, Sen Simon
- O'Sullivan, Sen Matt
- McKenzie, Sen Bridget
- Hanson-Young, Sen Sarah
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Gallagher, Sen Katy
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- Cash, Sen Michaelia
- Gallagher, Sen Katy
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- McLachlan, Sen Andrew (The CHAIR)
- Division
- Adoption of Report
- Third Reading
-
In Committee
- Ozone Protection and Synthetic Greenhouse Gas Management Reform (Closing the Hole in the Ozone Layer) Bill 2022, Ozone Protection and Synthetic Greenhouse Gas (Import Levy) Amendment Bill 2022, Ozone Protection and Synthetic Greenhouse Gas (Manufacture Levy) Amendment Bill 2022
- COMMITTEES
- BILLS
- BUSINESS
Page: 2783
Senator RICE (Victoria) (19:16): I wish to speak against this amendment. The core of this debate that we are having is about restoring territory rights so the territories' can make decisions for themselves. This amendment by Senator Nampijinpa Price would interfere with that. It would mean that a lot of those rights actually wouldn't be restored. Fundamentally, our debate needs to be about the rights of the territories to decide for themselves.
I'm a Victorian and I now live in a state where we have voluntary assisted dying. I haven't spoken in this debate before, and I will put on the record that I am a supporter of voluntary assisted dying. I think the way that it has been managed in Victoria has been exemplary.
But in one way we're talking about voluntary assisted dying, and that's not what we should be talking about here. We should be talking about the rights of the territories to be making decisions for themselves. The fact that the territories have different rights to the states is an anachronism. It's a random facet of our colonial past such that, as a Victorian, I have the opportunity to be part of that decision-making process to elect my members of parliament who made that decision, but people who live in the territories don't. And it's just not appropriate.
This bill that we are debating tonight is going to go some way to restoring that, to say that on this very sensitive issue—on the issue as to whether people have the right to choose to end their lives in a way that they desire, that is peaceful, and how they want to end their lives. They should have the right to do that in the ACT and the Northern Territory just as I now do have as a Victorian.
I don't want to speak for much longer—I do want to get home tonight—but I really felt that it was worthwhile just putting that on the record. I also want to acknowledge the people who are in the gallery: the Chief Minister of the ACT Andrew Barr, Marshall Perron, Andrew Denton and the people that have been following this debate for a long time. The fact that we've got such a full gallery shows what a significant issue this is and shows that we need to be respecting the rights of territorians to be making these decisions for themselves.