

- Title
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Prime Minister: Piggery
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
02-02-1994
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
37
- Electorate
NSW
- Interjector
- Page
207
- Party
LP
- Presenter
- Status
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Senator MICHAEL BAUME
- Stage
- Type
- Context
Miscellaneous
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1994-02-02/0057

Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- PRESENTATION TO GOVERNOR-GENERAL
- PETITIONS
-
NOTICES OF MOTION
- Days and Hours of Meeting
- Department of Immigration and Ethnic Affairs
- Environment
- Housing
- Member for Maribyrnong
- Autism
- Taxation
- Mineral Exploration
- Housing
- Citizenship
- Burma
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
-
COMMITTEES
- Industry, Science, Technology, Transport, Communications and Infrastructure Committee
-
DOCUMENTS
- Tabling
- COMMITTEES
- BUSHFIRES
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
-
CORPORATE LAW REFORM BILL 1993
- First Reading
- Second Reading
-
COMMITTEES
- Procedure Committee
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Member for Maribyrnong
(Senator ALSTON, Senator McMULLAN) -
Economy: Budget Forecasts
(Senator McKIERNAN, Senator COOK) -
Member for Maribyrnong
(Senator ALSTON, Senator McMULLAN) -
Afghanistan
(Senator LOOSLEY, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Environment
(Senator KERNOT, Senator COOK) -
Bushfires
(Senator WEST, Senator FAULKNER) -
Member for Maribyrnong
(Senator HILL, Senator McMULLAN) -
Immigration and Multiculturalism
(Senator REYNOLDS, Senator BOLKUS) -
Prime Minister: Piggery
(Senator MICHAEL BAUME, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Malaysia
(Senator BOURNE, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Community Grants
(Senator TIERNEY, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Space Project
(Senator MURPHY, Senator SCHACHT) -
Trade and Administrative Services Portfolios
(Senator BROWNHILL, Senator McMULLAN) -
Cigarette Smoking
(Senator COLSTON, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Woodchipping
(Senator CHAMARETTE, Senator COLLINS)
-
Member for Maribyrnong
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
- Immigration: Permanent Residency
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- Member for Maribyrnong
- Bushfires
- Prime Minister: Piggery
- Community Grants
-
COMMITTEES
- Community Affairs Committee
- Environment, Recreation and the Arts Committee
-
DOCUMENTS
- Anglo-Australian Telescope Board
- Business of the Senate
- President's Report on Annual Reports
- Questions on Notice: Summary
- Asia-Pacific Parliamentary Forum
-
COMMITTEES
-
Estimates Committee A
- Additional Information
-
Estimates Committee C
- Additional Information
-
Estimates Committee F
- Additional Information
-
Scrutiny of Bills Committee
- Report
-
Estimates Committee A
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- COMMITTEES
- NATIONAL HEALTH AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 3) 1993 NURSING HOME CHARGE (IMPOSITION) BILL 1993 HEALTH LEGISLATION (PROFESSIONAL SERVICES REVIEW) AMENDMENT BILL 1993
- CHEMICAL WEAPONS (PROHIBITION) BILL 1993
-
ADJOURNMENT
- Minehunters
- DOCUMENTS
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
-
Parliament: Electorate Staff
(Senator Brownhill, Senator McMullan) -
Forests
(Senator Coulter, Senator Richardson) -
ATSIC: Strelley Group
(Senator Panizza, Senator Collins) -
Housing, Local Government and Community Services: Chairs
(Senator Calvert, Senator Richardson) -
Finance: Conferences
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Finance: Conference Facilities
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Environment, Sport and Territories: Market Research
(Senator Calvert, Senator Richardson) -
Arts and Administrative Services: Panel System and Link Desk
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Arts and Administrative Services: Function at Batemans Bay
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Industrial Relations: Campaign Research
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Koalas
(Senator Lees, Senator Richardson) -
Forests
(Senator Coulter, Senator Richardson) -
Narran Lakes Wetlands Region
(Senator Bourne, Senator Richardson) -
Forests
(Senator Coulter, Senator Richardson) -
Defence Exports to Papua New Guinea
(Senator Bourne, Senator Gareth Evans) -
East Timor
(Senator Chamarette, Senator Gareth Evans) -
Centenary House
(Senator Campbell, Senator McMullan) -
Forests
(Senator Coulter, Senator Richardson) -
Social Security: Purchase of Rulers
(Senator Calvert, Senator Crowley) -
Window Coverings
(Senator Calvert, Senator McMullan) -
Casselden Place, Melbourne
(Senator Short, Senator McMullan) -
Direct Marketing
(Senator Alston, Senator Gareth Evans) -
Business Dealings of Departments and Agencies
(Senator Alston, Senator Gareth Evans) -
HMAS Huon
(Senator Calvert, Senator Robert Ray) -
Dementia
(Senator Patterson, Senator Richardson)
-
Parliament: Electorate Staff
Page: 207
Senator MICHAEL BAUME (3.10 p.m.)
—by leave—I move:
That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for Foreign Affairs (Senator Gareth Evans) to a question without notice asked by Senator Michael Baume this day, relating to the Prime Minister's ivestment in a piggery.
The supplementary part of my question asked Senator Gareth Evans to give an unequivocal assurance that the Prime Minister (Mr Keating), either as Treasurer or Prime Minister, had not been involved in any negotiations or dealings whatsoever—including with Danish government members or officials—in relation to the piggery project. That is a very simple question: has he or has he not as Treasurer or Prime Minister been involved other than at arm's length or as a passive investor?
The reason for the question is that Mr Constantinidis was the first person to publicly state that the Prime Minister was heavily involved in the operations of the company, at least to the extent of its negotiations with the Danes. We know that negotiations with the Danes went on for a very long time—in fact, longer than that for which the Prime Minister was on the back bench. That is on the record. So when Senator Evans tells the chamber that everyone knew that the Prime Minister was negotiating, he was in fact misleading this parliament because that is simply not true. At no stage was this parliament told, nor did it appear in print, that the Prime Minister was heavily involved during his period on the back bench in negotiations with the Danes.
It is intriguing that neither the Prime Minister nor his ministers—nor his minions as they scurry up and down the press gallery, spreading poison and terrorising the gallery into not running any material about this issue—at any stage suggested that the Prime Minister's involvement with the business was other than at arm's length. Certainly, that was the impression that Senator Evans falsely presented today. Senator Evans responded that it was an arm's length exercise and always had been. He did not qualify that by adding that that was in terms of the accounts. In fact—to quote one of many examples—when asked about his pigs on radio 6WF in Perth on 30 June 1992, the Prime Minister said:
Mine is really just a passive investment.
It is either a passive investment or it is not. If at any stage he has been heavily involved in negotiations on behalf of this company, we are entitled to know that he did not really mean that it was only a passive investment but that it has been a very active investment.
They are all now starting to admit the absolute correctness of the bulk of the points I have been making—firstly, of course, about the accounts, a matter I have been pursuing for 99 per cent of my time since raising this matter in this place. They are admitting that there was an error, and they have been forced to admit that the Prime Minister has not at all times had an arm's length relationship with this company and at all times been a passive investor.
We have asked a simple question. That question is: in view of the fact that the Prime Minister is now known to have been involved in detailed, heavy negotiation with the Danes, will we get an unequivocal assurance that when he was Treasurer—in other words, when he first acquired his interest in this venture—or when he was Prime Minister, he was not involved in any such negotiations.
The question hangs in the air: why should the Prime Minister enter into an investment in a company which was losing multimillions of dollars—that is, according to the correct accounts—unless he knew there was a prospect of some venture like the Danish one coming good? It was the only reason the company was worth that sort of investment. We want an assurance that he had not been involved in any undertakings. I wonder why Senator Evans refuses to give any.