

- Title
NATIVE TITLE BILL 1993
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
20-12-1993
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
37
- Electorate
WA
- Interjector
- Page
5321
- Party
LP
- Presenter
- Status
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Senator ELLISON
- Stage
- Type
- Context
Bill
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1993-12-20/0263

Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- HANSARD
-
NATIVE TITLE BILL 1993
- Procedural Text
- Procedural Motion
- Motion
-
In Committee
- Senator HILL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator KEMP
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator MacGIBBON
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TEAGUE
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Procedural Text
-
In Committee
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
-
ORDER OF BUSINESS
- Days and Hours of Sitting
-
NATIVE TITLE BILL 1993
-
In Committee
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BISHOP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator KEMP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator KEMP
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator BOSWELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator PARER
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator PARER
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator VANSTONE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator MINCHIN
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator TAMBLING
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator MINCHIN
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator MINCHIN
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator MINCHIN
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator COLLINS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator COLLINS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator COLLINS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator COLLINS
- Senator MINCHIN
- Senator COLLINS
- Senator HILL
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator HILL
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator ALSTON
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator SPINDLER
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
- Senator GARETH EVANS
- Senator CRANE
-
In Committee
Page: 5321
Senator ELLISON (9.20 p.m.)
—That is the situation when the Commonwealth minister determines that alternative state measures can apply. But the state has to comply with the Commonwealth regime for that to happen. So the state is not free; it is still hidebound in the conduct of its own legislation. It cannot act concurrently unless the Commonwealth minister says, `Well, it has to be done that way or it cannot be done at all'. That is the problem.
The state might want to do things differently. The Commonwealth government has said that it wants a unified native title system, but there are different requirements in each state. For instance, the mining law of Victoria is quite different to the mining law of Western Australia. Is the Commonwealth going to say that there is a unified, universal scheme across the country that a state has to fit into in order to be able to do this, or will the government do it on a state by state basis?