Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Thursday, 19 September 2019
Page: 3601


Mr DUTTON (DicksonMinister for Home Affairs) (09:50): I move:

That this bill be now read a second time.

Governments must ensure that Australia's counterterrorism laws remain strong, targeted, and effective. There is no room for complacency in this endeavour, and our national security and counterterrorism laws are under constant review to ensure that Australia's law enforcement and intelligence agencies have the powers they need to prevent terrorist attacks and to deal with those individuals who would commit them.

Recently, the government introduced the Counter-Terrorism (Temporary Exclusion Orders) Act 2019, adding to the suite of measures to manage Australians who present a threat to the community, and today, the government introduces the Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Cessation) Bill 2019 to amend the terrorism-related citizenship loss provisions in the Australian Citizenship Act 2007.

The terrorism-related citizenship cessation provisions were first introduced in 2015 in response to the threat of foreign terrorist fighters returning to Australia from Syria and Iraq.

Since 2012, around 230 Australians have travelled to Syria or Iraq to fight with or support Islamic State, and around 250 Australian passports have been cancelled or refused in relation to the Syria-Iraq conflict, and others, as we know, who have fought for, or otherwise supported Islamic extremist groups, remain in Syria and Iraq and may seek to return to Australia at some time in the future.

The terrorism-related citizenship cessation provisions have been effective since their introduction. They have been able to result in the removal from the Australian community of dual citizens who fought in Syria and Iraq and who would have sought to return home with new skills, combat experience, and lethal intent. These provisions have protected the Australian community.

The Australian Citizenship Amendment (Citizenship Cessation) Bill 2019 continues the coalition government's effort to address the threat of terrorism and to deliver on our commitment to keep the Australian community safe. It's central reform and it provides for ministerial decision-making with respect to the cessation of Australian citizenship, replacing the current automatic operation of law provisions. Under this model, the Minister for Home Affairs can cease a person's Australian citizenship if satisfied that their conduct demonstrates a repudiation of their allegiance to Australia and that it is not in the public interest for the person to remain an Australian citizen.

The overarching purpose of this bill remains the same as when the provisions were first introduced in 2015. The parliament recognised then, as it does now, that Australian citizenship is a common bond, involving reciprocal rights and obligations. Citizens may, through certain conduct incompatible with the shared values of the Australian community, sever that bond and repudiate their allegiance to Australia. A citizen's duty of allegiance to Australia was not created by the Australian Citizenship Act 2007, but it is recognised by it and this bill reinforces that obligation.

The current citizenship loss provisions were recently reviewed by the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor (INSLM), who has made a number of recommendations as to how the provisions can be improved. The bill presented here today implements the majority of these recommendations.

In his report, the INSLM states 'the notion of allegiance by citizens to Australia is thought by some to be outdated; however, there can be no doubt of its current legal relevance in international law, the law of Australia, and the law of other countries'. In recognising the importance of laws to cease a person's citizenship, the INSLM recommends that sections 33AA and 35 be replaced with a ministerial decision-making model. This is the central amendment incorporated in this bill.

The bill retains three mechanisms for an individual to be considered for cessation of citizenship if they repudiate their allegiance to Australia:

First, a person can cease to be a citizen if they engage in specified terrorist conduct.

Second, a person can cease to be a citizen if they fight for, or are in the service of, a specified terrorist organisation overseas, and the bill retains provisions that a person is not in the service of a declared terrorist organisation if acting unintentionally, under duress, or providing humanitarian assistance.

Finally, a person can cease to be a citizen if they have been convicted of a specified terrorism offence by an Australian court.

In accordance with Australia's international law obligations, the bill retains provisions that no persons will have their citizenship ceased unless the minister is satisfied they are a citizen or national of another country. As an additional safeguard, the bill includes a provision whereby if a court finds the person was not a national or citizen of another at the time of the determination, their citizenship is taken never to have ceased.

In considering whether to cease a person's citizenship, the minister must have regard to certain public interest criteria. This, amongst other things, includes the degree of threat the person poses to the Australian community, Australia's international relations and the person's connection with the other country of citizenship. This enables the minister to consider a person within their specific context. The inclusion of the public interest criteria aligns with one of the INSLM's recommendations.

Once the minister has decided to cease a person's citizenship, the minister must inform the person in writing as soon as practicable. However, the minister retains the right to withhold notice if satisfied that giving notice could prejudice the security, defence or international relations of Australia, or Australian law enforcement operations.

Similar to the existing provisions, a decision to withhold notice can remain in place for five years. However, the new provisions require the minister to review this determination every 90 days. Additionally, at the conclusion of the five years, the person is provided notice unless the minister extends the determination once for a year. Withholding notice does not prevent a person from seeking judicial review if they become aware of the cessation of their citizenship through other means.

Once a person is provided notice, the new provisions give them 90 days to apply to the minister in writing for a revocation of the determination to cease their citizenship. Natural justice is afforded to the person so they can make representations on their case. This provision also aligns with a recommendation made by the INSLM.

In addition to applying to the minister, the bill contains several other avenues for a person's citizenship to be reinstated. Firstly, the minister may reinstate an individual's citizenship if it is in the public interest to do so. Secondly, in certain circumstances, a person's citizenship is taken never to have ceased and it is automatically reinstated. Finally, a person can access judicial review in relation to the minister's decision to cease their citizenship or reject their application for reinstatement.

The bill retains existing accountability and transparency measures. The minister must report to the parliament and the Parliamentary Joint Committee on Intelligence and Security (PJCIS) on the use of the provisions. In upholding transparency, the bill also amends the Intelligence Services Act 2001 to provide the PJCIS until 30 June 2021 to review the new provisions.

The bill includes transitional provisions to manage those persons whose citizenship may have ceased under the existing provisions, but whose circumstances are yet to come to the attention of the minister.

There are two additional measures that expand the operation of this new model.

Firstly, the bill amends the conduct provision so that behaviour dating from 29 May 2003 onwards can be taken into consideration when the minister determines whether to cease a person's citizenship. This enables the government to take into consideration and address a person's historic conduct that is incompatible with the shared values of the Australian community.

Secondly, the bill amends the conviction provision to allow the minister to cease a person's citizenship if they are convicted from 29 May 2003 onwards of certain terrorism offences for a period or periods totalling three years. The current requirement is a sentence of six years for a conviction from 2015 to now, or 10 years from conviction from 2005 to 2015. This amendment reflects the seriousness of a criminal conviction for a terrorism offence.

The date of 29 May 2003 is pertinent, as it is the date on which relevant offences were fully enacted under the Criminal Code Amendment (Terrorism) Act 2003.

These amendments build on, adapt and modernise the citizenship cessation provisions. They strengthen the operation of the measures in response to the increasingly complex challenges facing the national security, defence and international relations of Australia.

They further establish citizenship cessation as one of a suite of measures—which includes control orders, prosecution, temporary exclusion orders, the Commonwealth high-risk terrorist offenders scheme and deradicalisation programs—that can be applied appropriately and proportionately on a case-by-case basis.

Australia is a united and cohesive country. It is something we pride ourselves on. In recognising and protecting this unity and cohesion, it is essential that we continue to monitor, update and amend the way in which we deal with those who would threaten it. Behaviour that harms, or seeks to harm, our community—whether that be in Australia or offshore—is in clear opposition to the common bond and shared values that underpin membership the Australian community.

This bill is designed to protect the integrity of Australian citizenship and to ensure we have the necessary powers to keep Australians safe. It reflects the government's strong approach to combating terrorism, and protecting the sovereignty and safety of this country and its citizens.

I commend the bill to the House.

Debate adjourned.