Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download PDFDownload PDF 

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment

   21   QUESTIONS

Questions without notice being asked—



 

Member directed to leave

At 2.04 pm the Member for Sydney ( Ms Plibersek ) was directed, under standing order 94, to leave the Chamber for one hour for continuing to interject after a warning had been given by the Chair and she accordingly left the Chamber.

Questions without notice continuing—

Member directed to leave

At 2.05 pm the Member for Paterson ( Ms Swanson ) was directed, under standing order 94, to leave the Chamber for one hour for continuing to interject after a general warning had been given by the Chair and she accordingly left the Chamber.

Questions without notice continuing—

Member directed to leave

At 2.12 pm the Member for Cowan ( Dr Aly ) was directed, under standing order 94, to leave the Chamber for one hour continuing to interject after a general warning had been given by the Chair and she accordingly left the Chamber.

Questions without notice continuing—

Member directed to leave

At 2.18 pm the Member for Ballarat ( Ms C. F. King ) was directed, under standing order 94, to leave the Chamber for one hour continuing to interject after a general warning had been given by the Chair and she accordingly left the Chamber.

Questions without notice continuing—

Member directed to leave

At 2.36 pm the Member for Bruce ( Mr Hill ) was directed, under standing order 94, to leave the Chamber for one hour continuing to interject after a general warning had been given by the Chair and he accordingly left the Chamber.

Questions without notice continuing—

 

 

Suspension of standing orders moved

Mr Albanese (Leader of the Opposition) moved—That so much of the standing orders be suspended as would prevent the Leader of the Opposition from moving the following motion immediately—That the House:

(1)        notes that this week:

(a)        detectives from the NSW Police Force’s State Crime Command Financial Crimes Squad launched Strike Force Garrad to investigate whether the Minister for Emissions Reduction committed a crime;

(b)        the Prime Minister refused to stand down the Minister while the subject of a criminal investigation notwithstanding the Ministerial Standards;

(c)        the Prime Minister called the NSW Police Commissioner and discussed the nature, substance and instigation of the criminal investigation;

(d)        former Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull, former NSW ICAC Commissioner David Ipp QC, and former NSW ICAC Counsel Assisting Geoffrey Watson SC have criticised the Prime Minister’s call;

(e)        the Prime Minister misled the House while defending the deliberate misleading of the House by the Minister and refused to apologise and correct the record; and

(f)         the Prime Minister failed to answer questions about his conduct, or the conduct of the Minister, and prevented Parliament debating this scandal 20 times; and

(2)        therefore, calls on the Prime Minister to:

(a)        acknowledge the Minister for Emissions Reduction deliberately misled the House;

(b)        acknowledge the Prime Minister’s decision to call the NSW Police Commissioner was inappropriate;

(c)        correct the record in person and apologise for misleading the House on Wednesday;

(d)        correct the record in person and apologise for misleading the House today by claiming the Opposition voted against the second reading of the Defence Service Homes Amendment Bill 2019 when it supported it;

(e)        undertake to fully cooperate with the NSW Police Force criminal investigation; and

(f)         stand down the Minister for Emissions Reduction.

Closure of Member

Mr Porter (Leader of the House) moved—That the Member be no longer heard.

Question—put.

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—

AYES, 73

Mr Alexander

Ms Flint

Mr Littleproud

Mr Sharma

Dr Allen

Mr Frydenberg

Ms Liu

Mr Simmonds

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Mr Gee

Mr McCormack

Mr Stevens

Mr K. J. Andrews

Dr Gillespie

Mrs McIntosh

Mr Sukkar

Mrs Archer

Mr Goodenough

Dr McVeigh

Mr Taylor

Ms Bell

Ms Hammond

Mrs Marino

Mr Tehan

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hastie

Dr Martin

Mr Thompson

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hawke

Mr Morrison

Mr Tudge

Mr D. J. Chester

Mr Hogan

Mr Morton

Mr van Manen

Mr Christensen

Mr Howarth

Mr Ted O’Brien

Mr Wallace

Mr Conaghan

Mr Hunt

Mr L. S. O’Brien

Dr Webster

Mr Connelly

Mr Irons

Mr Pasin

Mrs Wicks

Mr Coulton

Mr Joyce

Mr Pearce

Mr R. J. Wilson

Mr Drum*

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Pitt

Mr T. R. Wilson

Mr Dutton

Mr Laming

Mr Porter

Mr Wood

Mr Entsch

Ms Landry

Ms Price

Mr Wyatt

Mr Evans

Mr Leeser

Mr Ramsey*

Mr Young

Mr Falinski

Ms Ley

Mr Robert

Mr Zimmerman

Mr Fletcher

 

NOES, 64

Mr Albanese

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Ms Sharkie

Mr Bandt

Dr Freelander

Mr B. K. Mitchell

Mr Shorten

Ms Bird

Mr Georganas

Mr R. G. Mitchell

Mr D. P. B. Smith

Mr Bowen

Mr Giles

Dr Mulino

Mr Snowdon

Mr Burns

Mr Gorman

Ms Murphy

Ms Stanley*

Mr M. C. Butler

Mr Gosling

Mr Neumann

Ms Steggall

Ms T. M. Butler

Dr Haines

Mr O’Connor

Ms Swanson

Mr Byrne

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neil

Ms Templeman

Dr Chalmers

Mr Husic

Ms Owens

Mr Thistlethwaite

Mr Clare

Mr Jones

Ms Payne

Ms Thwaites

Ms Coker

Ms Kearney

Mr Perrett

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms Collins

Mr Keogh

Mrs Phillips

Mr Watts

Mr Conroy

Mr Khalil

Ms Plibersek

Ms Wells

Mr Dick

Ms M. M. H. King

Ms Rishworth

Mr Wilkie

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rowland

Mr J. H. Wilson

Mrs Elliot

Ms McBride

Ms Ryan*

Mr Zappia

* Tellers

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

Mr M. C. Butler (seconder) addressing the House—

Closure of Member

Mr Porter moved—That the Member be no longer heard.

Question—put.

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—

AYES, 73

Mr Alexander

Ms Flint

Mr Littleproud

Mr Sharma

Dr Allen

Mr Frydenberg

Ms Liu

Mr Simmonds

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Mr Gee

Mr McCormack

Mr Stevens

Mr K. J. Andrews

Dr Gillespie

Mrs McIntosh

Mr Sukkar

Mrs Archer

Mr Goodenough

Dr McVeigh

Mr Taylor

Ms Bell

Ms Hammond

Mrs Marino

Mr Tehan

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hastie

Dr Martin

Mr Thompson

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hawke

Mr Morrison

Mr Tudge

Mr D. J. Chester

Mr Hogan

Mr Morton

Mr van Manen

Mr Christensen

Mr Howarth

Mr Ted O’Brien

Mr Wallace

Mr Conaghan

Mr Hunt

Mr L. S. O’Brien

Dr Webster

Mr Connelly

Mr Irons

Mr Pasin

Mrs Wicks

Mr Coulton

Mr Joyce

Mr Pearce

Mr R. J. Wilson

Mr Drum*

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Pitt

Mr T. R. Wilson

Mr Dutton

Mr Laming

Mr Porter

Mr Wood

Mr Entsch

Ms Landry

Ms Price

Mr Wyatt

Mr Evans

Mr Leeser

Mr Ramsey*

Mr Young

Mr Falinski

Ms Ley

Mr Robert

Mr Zimmerman

Mr Fletcher

 

NOES, 64

Mr Albanese

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Ms Sharkie

Mr Bandt

Dr Freelander

Mr B. K. Mitchell

Mr Shorten

Ms Bird

Mr Georganas

Mr R. G. Mitchell

Mr D. P. B. Smith

Mr Bowen

Mr Giles

Dr Mulino

Mr Snowdon

Mr Burns

Mr Gorman

Ms Murphy

Ms Stanley*

Mr M. C. Butler

Mr Gosling

Mr Neumann

Ms Steggall

Ms T. M. Butler

Dr Haines

Mr O’Connor

Ms Swanson

Mr Byrne

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neil

Ms Templeman

Dr Chalmers

Mr Husic

Ms Owens

Mr Thistlethwaite

Mr Clare

Mr Jones

Ms Payne

Ms Thwaites

Ms Coker

Ms Kearney

Mr Perrett

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms Collins

Mr Keogh

Mrs Phillips

Mr Watts

Mr Conroy

Mr Khalil

Ms Plibersek

Ms Wells

Mr Dick

Ms M. M. H. King

Ms Rishworth

Mr Wilkie

Mr Dreyfus

Dr Leigh

Ms Rowland

Mr J. H. Wilson

Mrs Elliot

Ms McBride

Ms Ryan*

Mr Zappia

* Tellers

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

Debate ensuing—

Mr Marles addressing the House—

Closure

Mr Porter moved—That the question be now put.

Question—That the question be now put—put.

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—



 

AYES, 73

Mr Alexander

Ms Flint

Mr Littleproud

Mr Sharma

Dr Allen

Mr Frydenberg

Ms Liu

Mr Simmonds

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Mr Gee

Mr McCormack

Mr Stevens

Mr K. J. Andrews

Dr Gillespie

Mrs McIntosh

Mr Sukkar

Mrs Archer

Mr Goodenough

Dr McVeigh

Mr Taylor

Ms Bell

Ms Hammond

Mrs Marino

Mr Tehan

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hastie

Dr Martin

Mr Thompson

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hawke

Mr Morrison

Mr Tudge

Mr D. J. Chester

Mr Hogan

Mr Morton

Mr van Manen

Mr Christensen

Mr Howarth

Mr Ted O’Brien

Mr Wallace

Mr Conaghan

Mr Hunt

Mr L. S. O’Brien

Dr Webster

Mr Connelly

Mr Irons

Mr Pasin

Mrs Wicks

Mr Coulton

Mr Joyce

Mr Pearce

Mr R. J. Wilson

Mr Drum*

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Pitt

Mr T. R. Wilson

Mr Dutton

Mr Laming

Mr Porter

Mr Wood

Mr Entsch

Ms Landry

Ms Price

Mr Wyatt

Mr Evans

Mr Leeser

Mr Ramsey*

Mr Young

Mr Falinski

Ms Ley

Mr Robert

Mr Zimmerman

Mr Fletcher

 

NOES, 64

Mr Albanese

Mrs Elliot

Mr Marles

Ms Sharkie

Dr Aly

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr B. K. Mitchell

Mr Shorten

Mr Bandt

Dr Freelander

Mr R. G. Mitchell

Mr D. P. B. Smith

Ms Bird

Mr Georganas

Dr Mulino

Mr Snowdon

Mr Bowen

Mr Giles

Ms Murphy

Ms Stanley*

Mr Burns

Mr Gorman

Mr Neumann

Ms Steggall

Mr M. C. Butler

Mr Gosling

Mr O’Connor

Ms Swanson

Ms T. M. Butler

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neil

Ms Templeman

Mr Byrne

Mr Husic

Ms Owens

Mr Thistlethwaite

Dr Chalmers

Mr Jones

Ms Payne

Ms Thwaites

Mr Clare

Ms Kearney

Mr Perrett

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms Coker

Mr Keogh

Mrs Phillips

Mr Watts

Ms Collins

Mr Khalil

Ms Plibersek

Ms Wells

Mr Conroy

Ms M. M. H. King

Ms Rishworth

Mr Wilkie

Mr Dick

Dr Leigh

Ms Rowland

Mr J. H. Wilson

Mr Dreyfus

Ms McBride

Ms Ryan*

Mr Zappia

* Tellers

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

And the question—That the motion for the suspension of standing orders be agreed to—being accordingly put—

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr A. D. H. Smith, in the Chair)—



 

AYES, 65

Mr Albanese

Mr Fitzgibbon

Mr Marles

Ms Sharkie

Dr Aly

Dr Freelander

Mr B. K. Mitchell

Mr Shorten

Mr Bandt

Mr Georganas

Mr R. G. Mitchell

Mr D. P. B. Smith

Ms Bird

Mr Giles

Dr Mulino

Mr Snowdon

Mr Bowen

Mr Gorman

Ms Murphy

Ms Stanley*

Mr Burns

Mr Gosling

Mr Neumann

Ms Steggall

Mr M. C. Butler

Dr Haines

Mr O’Connor

Ms Swanson

Ms T. M. Butler

Mr Hayes

Ms O’Neil

Ms Templeman

Mr Byrne

Mr Husic

Ms Owens

Mr Thistlethwaite

Dr Chalmers

Mr Jones

Ms Payne

Ms Thwaites

Mr Clare

Ms Kearney

Mr Perrett

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms Coker

Mr Keogh

Mrs Phillips

Mr Watts

Ms Collins

Mr Khalil

Ms Plibersek

Ms Wells

Mr Conroy

Ms M. M. H. King

Ms Rishworth

Mr Wilkie

Mr Dick

Dr Leigh

Ms Rowland

Mr J. H. Wilson

Mr Dreyfus

Ms McBride

Ms Ryan*

Mr Zappia

Mrs Elliot

 

NOES, 73

Mr Alexander

Ms Flint

Mr Littleproud

Mr Sharma

Dr Allen

Mr Frydenberg

Ms Liu

Mr Simmonds

Mrs K. L. Andrews

Mr Gee

Mr McCormack

Mr Stevens

Mr K. J. Andrews

Dr Gillespie

Mrs McIntosh

Mr Sukkar

Mrs Archer

Mr Goodenough

Dr McVeigh

Mr Taylor

Ms Bell

Ms Hammond

Mrs Marino

Mr Tehan

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hastie

Dr Martin

Mr Thompson

Mr Buchholz

Mr Hawke

Mr Morrison

Mr Tudge

Mr D. J. Chester

Mr Hogan

Mr Morton

Mr van Manen

Mr Christensen

Mr Howarth

Mr Ted O’Brien

Mr Wallace

Mr Conaghan

Mr Hunt

Mr L. S. O’Brien

Dr Webster

Mr Connelly

Mr Irons

Mr Pasin

Mrs Wicks

Mr Coulton

Mr Joyce

Mr Pearce

Mr R. J. Wilson

Mr Drum*

Mr C. Kelly

Mr Pitt

Mr T. R. Wilson

Mr Dutton

Mr Laming

Mr Porter

Mr Wood

Mr Entsch

Ms Landry

Ms Price

Mr Wyatt

Mr Evans

Mr Leeser

Mr Ramsey*

Mr Young

Mr Falinski

Ms Ley

Mr Robert

Mr Zimmerman

Mr Fletcher

 

* Tellers

And so it was negatived.

 

 

Questions without notice continued.