Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Monday, 3 June 2013
Page: 4796

The House divided. [15:37]

(The Speaker—Ms Anna Burke)

DIVISION:AYES 69 (1 majority) NOES 68 PAIRS 6
AYESNOESPAIRS
Abbott, AJAlexander, JG
Andrews, KLBaldwin, RC
Billson, BFBishop, BK
Bishop, JIBriggs, JE
Broadbent, REBuchholz, S
Chester, DChristensen, GR
Ciobo, SMCoulton, M (teller)
Dutton, PCEntsch, WG (teller)
Fletcher, PWForrest, JA
Frydenberg, JAGambaro, T
Griggs, NLHaase, BW
Hartsuyker, LHawke, AG
Hockey, JBHunt, GA
Irons, SJJensen, DG
Jones, ETKatter, RC
Keenan, MKelly, C
Laming, ALey, SP
Macfarlane, IEMarino, NB
Markus, LEMatheson, RG
McCormack, MFMirabella, S
Morrison, SJMoylan, JE
Neville, PCO'Dowd, KD
O'Dwyer, KMPrentice, J
Pyne, CMRamsey, RE
Randall, DJRobb, AJ
Robert, SRRoy, WB
Schultz, AJScott, BC
Simpkins, LXLSlipper, PN
Smith, ADHSomlyay, AM
Southcott, AJStone, SN
Tehan, DTTruss, WE
Tudge, AETurnbull, MB
Van Manen, AJVasta, RX
Washer, MJWilkie, AD
Wyatt, KG
Adams, DGHBandt, AP
Bird, SLBowen, CE
Bradbury, DJBrodtmann, G
Burke, ASButler, MC
Byrne, AMChampion, ND
Cheeseman, DLClare, JD
Collins, JMCombet, GI
Crean, SFDanby, M
D'Ath, YMDreyfus, MA
Elliot, MJEllis, KM
Emerson, CAFerguson, LDT
Ferguson, MJFitzgibbon, JA
Garrett, PRGeorganas, S
Gibbons, SWGillard, JE
Gray, GGrierson, SJ
Griffin, APHall, JG
Hayes, CPJenkins, HA
Jones, SPKing, CF
Leigh, AKLivermore, KF
Lyons, GRMacklin, JL
Marles, RDMcClelland, RB
Mitchell, RG (teller)Murphy, JP
Neumann, SKOakeshott, RJM
O'Connor, BPJO'Neill, DM
Owens, JParke, M
Perrett, GD (teller)Plibersek, TJ
Rishworth, ALRowland, MA
Roxon, NLRudd, KM
Saffin, JAShorten, WR
Sidebottom, PSSmyth, L
Snowdon, WESwan, WM
Symon, MSThomson, CR
Thomson, KJVamvakinou, M
Windsor, AHCZappia, A
Andrews, KJAlbanese, AN
Cobb, JKKelly, MJ
Crook, AJMelham, D
Gash, JRipoll, BF
Ruddock, PMSmith, SF
Secker, PDHusic, E

The question being not carried by an absolute majority of members as required by standing order 47.

Question negatived.