Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Tuesday, 22 February 2011
Page: 918
[4:09 PM]

The House divided.    

(The Speaker—Mr Harry Jenkins)

DIVISION:NOES 71 AYES 71 PAIRS 3
AYESNOESPAIRS
Abbott, A.J.Alexander, J.
Andrews, K.Andrews, K.J.
Baldwin, R.C.Billson, B.F.
Bishop, B.K.Bishop, J.I.
Broadbent, R.Buchholz, S.
Chester, D.Christensen, G.
Ciobo, S.M.Cobb, J.K.
Coulton, M. *Crook, T.
Dutton, P.C.Entsch, W.
Fletcher, P.Forrest, J.A.
Frydenberg, J.Gambaro, T.
Gash, J.Griggs, N.
Haase, B.W.Hartsuyker, L.
Hawke, A.Hockey, J.B.
Hunt, G.A.Irons, S.J.
Jensen, D.Jones, E.
Katter, R.C.Kelly, C.
Laming, A.Ley, S.P.
Macfarlane, I.E.Marino, N.B.
Markus, L.E.Matheson, R.
McCormack, M.Mirabella, S.
Morrison, S.J.Moylan, J.E.
Neville, P.C.O’Dowd, K.
O’Dwyer, KPrentice, J.
Pyne, C.Ramsey, R.
Randall, D.J.Robb, A.
Robert, S.R.Roy, Wyatt
Ruddock, P.M.Scott, B.C.
Secker, P.D. *Simpkins, L.
Slipper, P.N.Smith, A.D.H.
Somlyay, A.M.Stone, S.N.
Tehan, D.Truss, W.E.
Tudge, A.Turnbull, M.
Van Manen, B.Vasta, R.
Washer, M.J.Windsor, A.H.C.
Wyatt, K.
Adams, D.G.H.Albanese, A.N.
Bandt, A.Bird, S.
Bowen, C.Bradbury, D.J.
Brodtmann, G.Burke, A.E.
Burke, A.S.Butler, M.C.
Byrne, A.M.Champion, N.
Cheeseman, D.L.Clare, J.D.
Collins, J.M.Combet, G.
Crean, S.F.D’Ath, Y.M.
Danby, M.Dreyfus, M.A.
Elliot, J.Emerson, C.A.
Ferguson, L.D.T.Ferguson, M.J.
Fitzgibbon, J.A.Garrett, P.
Georganas, S.Gibbons, S.W.
Gillard, J.E.Gray, G.
Grierson, S.J.Griffin, A.P.
Hall, J.G. *Hayes, C.P. *
Husic, E.Jones, S.
Kelly, M.J.King, C.F.
Leigh, A.Livermore, K.F.
Lyons, G.Macklin, J.L.
Marles, R.D.McClelland, R.B.
Melham, D.Mitchell, R.
Murphy, J.Neumann, S.K.
O’Connor, B.P.O’Neill, D.
Oakeshott, R.J.M.Owens, J.
Parke, M.Perrett, G.D.
Plibersek, T.Ripoll, B.F.
Rishworth, A.L.Rowland, M.
Roxon, N.L.Saffin, J.A.
Shorten, W.R.Smith, S.F.
Smyth, L.Snowdon, W.E.
Swan, W.M.Symon, M.
Thomson, C.Thomson, K.J.
Vamvakinou, M.Wilkie, A.
Zappia, A.
Keenan, M.Ellis, K.
Schultz, A.Rudd, K.M.
Briggs, J.E.Sidebottom, S.

* denotes teller

The requirements of standing order 47(c)(ii) for an absolute majority having not been satisfied, the motion was not carried.