


Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
-
PETITIONS
- Chiropractic Services
- Excise on Grape Spirit
- Kangaroos
- Proposed Airport at Scheyville, New South Wales
- Discrimination against Women
- Foreign Bases
- Construction of Railway Overpass, Port Augusta, South Australia
- Taxation: Truck Owner-Drivers
- Pensions
- Telecom Australia
- General Motors-Holden's Ltd
- Mackay Directory Assistance Centre
- Postal Services
- Procedural Text
-
LEBANON
- Notice of Motion
- SERVICEMEN
- SOUTH WEST TASMANIA
- SUGAR INDUSTRY
- CITIZEN MILITARY FORCES
- AMERICA'S CUP
- FORTIFIED WINES: EXCISE TAX
- LEBANON
-
SALARIES AND WAGES PAUSE ACT REPEAL BILL 1983
- Second Reading
-
OVERSEAS STUDENTS CHARGE AMENDMENT BILL 1983
- Second Reading
- HEALTH LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1983
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
PETROL PRICES
(Mr GOODLUCK, Mr HAWKE) -
ASSETS TEST
(Mr CUNNINGHAM, Mr KEATING) -
LIBYAN DELEGATION
(Mr WEST) -
LOCAL GOVERNMENT: REVENUE SHARING ARRANGEMENTS
(Mr SIMMONS, Mr UREN) -
ELECTORAL REFORM
(Mr HUNT, Mr BEAZLEY) -
HMAS 'SUCCESS'
(Mr MOUNTFORD, Mr DAWKINS) -
DEFENCE FORCE RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS SCHEME
(Mr WHITE, Mr SCHOLES) -
PRICES AND INCOMES ACCORD
(Mrs DARLING, Mr HAWKE) -
TRADE AND PROTECTION POLICY
(Mr PEACOCK, Mr LIONEL BOWEN) -
HIGH TECHNOLOGY INDUSTRIES
(Mr BLANCHARD, Mr BARRY JONES) -
GRAPE SPIRIT EXCISE
(Mr HICKS, Mr KEATING) -
DESTRUCTION OF KOREAN AIRLINER
(Mr JACOBI, Mr HAYDEN)
-
PETROL PRICES
- PERSONAL EXPLANATION
- AUSTRALIAN SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY COUNCIL
- PETROLEUM PRODUCTS PRICING AUTHORITY
- NATIONAL RAILWAY NETWORK (FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE) ACT
- PROPOSALS FOR WORKS (BUS STOPS) WITHIN THE PARLIAMENTARY ZONE
- NEW BUSINESS AFTER 11 P.M.: ADJOURNMENT OF THE HOUSE
- IMMIGRATION AND ETHNIC AFFAIRS
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE SENATE
- HEALTH LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1983
- PERSONAL EXPLANATION
-
HEALTH LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1983
- Second Reading
-
In Committee
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr FREE
- Mr SPENDER
- Mr NEWMAN
- Ms MAYER
- Mr CONNOLLY
- Mrs DARLING
- Mr SPENDER
- Dr THEOPHANOUS
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr CARLTON
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr MacKELLAR
- Mr CONNOLLY
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr MacKELLAR
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr NEWMAN
- Mr CONNOLLY
- Mr MacKELLAR
- Mr NEWMAN
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr NEWMAN
- Mr MacKELLAR
- Mr SPENDER
- Mr GROOM
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr FISHER
- Mr CUNNINGHAM
- Mr RUDDOCK
- Dr EVERINGHAM
- Mr NEWMAN
- Mr SHIPTON
- Mr FISHER
- Mr CUNNINGHAM
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr GROOM
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr RUDDOCK
- Mr SHIPTON
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr SPENDER
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr SPENDER
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr HODGMAN
- Mr MacKELLAR
- Mr HODGMAN
- Dr THEOPHANOUS
- Mr SPENDER
- Dr EVERINGHAM
- Mr HODGMAN
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr NEWMAN
- Dr BLEWETT
- Mr MACPHEE
- Mr SHIPTON
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr CONNOLLY
- Mr HODGMAN
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr CARLTON
- Mr CARLTON
- Dr BLEWETT
- Third Reading
- MEDICARE LEVY BILL 1983
- INCOME TAX LAWS AMENDMENT (MEDICARE LEVY) BILL 1983
- STATES (TAX SHARING AND HEALTH GRANTS) AMENDMENT BILL (No. 2) 1983
- NOTICES
- PAPERS
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
-
Sales Tax Assessments
(Dr Klugman, Mr Keating) -
Badgery's Creek-Luddenham Area: World Heritage List
(Dr Klugman, Mr Cohen) -
Indonesia: Gift of Patrol Boat
(Dr Everingham, Mr Scholes) -
Tax Deductions: Maintenance Payments
(Mr Blanchard, Mr Keating) -
Fire Fighting Equipment: Tax Deductibility
(Mr Andrew, Mr Keating) -
Australian National Line: Shipment of Coal to Tasmania
(Mr Burr, Mr Peter Morris)
-
Sales Tax Assessments
Page: 843
Dr THEOPHANOUS(1.23 a.m.)
—We cannot allow the outrageous comments of the honourable member for Denison (Mr Hodgman) to go unchallenged. He appears to perceive socialisation under every bed. The situation seems to be that the honourable member has used the word 'socialisation' in discussion of virtually every measure that has come before the House of Representatives in the last two weeks. His whole conception of what constitutes socialisation is so incorrect as to be laughable.
Mr Robert Brown
—It is paranoia.
Dr THEOPHANOUS
—As the honourable member for Hunter says, it is paranoia on the part of the honourable member for Denison.
Opposition members interjecting-
Dr THEOPHANOUS
—The Minister for Health (Dr Blewett) says that the honourable member cannot claim for Portnoy's complaint.
The DEPUTY CHAIRMAN
(Mr Rocher)
—Order! The honourable member for Burke does not need any help.
Dr THEOPHANOUS
—It is a little difficult to be serious when one is replying to the honourable member for Denison. The fact of the matter is that this is not a measure for the socialisation of medicine. If the honourable member knew anything about the systems which have socialised medicine and has compared what is happening here with what has happened in systems where medicine has been socialised even he, with his thick mind, would be able to perceive the difference.
The fact of the matter is that this legislation is designed to overcome the extraordinary problems and the complexities brought about by the multiplicity of mad systems created by the five different schemes of medical insurance of the conservatives. What we are doing in this legislation is putting some kind of rationale into the system. Some principle of efficiency and rationale has to be put into place. The conservatives seem to think that the principle of rationality or efficiency should not ever apply to anything. We will not be deflected from the task of establishing a national insurance system, because national systems are in the national interest. Honourable members opposite have never heard of the national interest. They think that anything that will maximise profit for a few small groups in the community is a sufficient reason to argue for it. They simply are not interested in looking at the national interest in relation to this matter.
Let me make it quite clear that we will proceed with this legislation. We believe its context is extremely fair. It takes into account the considerations of the medical profession. Under this legislation people have freedom to choose doctors, and doctors have freedom to charge whatever fees they want. All of these freedoms are part of this system. For the honourable member for Denison to claim that this is socialised medicine is simply absolute nonsense and total rubbish, and ought to be rejected.