Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Disclaimer: The Parliamentary Library does not warrant the accuracy of closed captions. These are derived automatically from the broadcaster's signal.
7.30 -

View in ParlViewView other Segments

(generated from captions) It is likely to warm up again by Thursday. Before we go, a brief recap of our top stories tonight. Us President Donald Trump has cast fresh doubt on the refugee deal with Australia. Calling it "dumb" and vowing to examine it but Malcolm Turnbull insists Mr trump has promised to honour the agreement . Prime Minister has defended his decision to donate $1.75 million to the Liberal Party ahead of last year' election. Labour has accused Mr Turnbull of trying to buy votes. And that's the latest from the Canberra newsroom. For more ACT news you can follow us online or on Facebook and ABC Canberra. Stay with us now for 730 with Stan Grant.

This program is live captioned by Ericsson Access Services. Welcome to the program. The dark side of a glamour sport. How tennis management failed a vulnerable young player.We have really struggled hard with not being able to protect our daughter.She was asked very personal, very intrusive and also pretty irrelevant questions.She was destroyed in her life by the actions of those involved at that institutional investigation.And I believe that in 1978 God changed his mind about black people.Black people.And the irreverent hit musical from the creators of South Park.There's something about Mormon culture, the big smiles they have. It seems like they're always about to break out in song.Those stories shortly. First, the Australian-American alliance is built on shared values, history, trust and respect. All of that it seems is being tested right now by the undorth dox and unpredictable Donald Trump -- unorthodox and unpredictable Donald Trump. At the centre of it is for America to take more than 1,000 asylum seekers held by Australia in offshore detention. Donald Trump is calling the deal dumb. President Trump blasting PM Malcolm Turnbull in a tense phone conversation. As Andrew Probyn reports, it has left the Government dumbfounded and Turnbull on the defensive. Deal or no deal? Just before midnight in Washington DC, Donald Trump's thumbs struck again. Do you believe it, the President said on Twitter?

This dumb deal is now dominating Australian politics. Dogging Malcolm Turnbull at every turn.That is his tweet. I'm telling you:

Today was meant to be all about energy policy and the PM's new-found emphasis on cheap power. But just before a planned news conference came the first bombshell from Washington. And it's all about that weekend phone call.Very busy night. Angry phone call between President Trump and one of our four closest allies, PM Malcolm Turnbull of Australia.Donald Trump reportedly berated Malcolm Turnbull for the refugee agreement he struck with Barack Obama, calling it the worst deal ever. And he accused Australia of seeking to export the next Boston bombers. Dramatic detail the PM defiantly refused to confirm.I'm not going to comment on a conversation between myself and the President of the US. Other than what we have said publicly and you can surely understand the reasons for that.He's cozier with an adversary like Putin than a close ally like Australia. What's happening?The report in the Washington Post is consistent with what I've been told by Government insiders about the tense 25 minute phone call. Donald Trump made it clear to the PM he hated the deal and he was only considering it in deference to the US-Australia alliance. Political deals, like sausages, are best not seen in the making but Malcolm Turnbull sought to turn his handling of the difficult episode into a virtue.Australians know me very well. I always stand up for Australia in every form.Clearly President Trump and his people are saying one thing happened in this conversation which is completely at odds with what PM Turnbull's told the Australian people. They both can't be right.This afternoon's presidential tweet shows Trump's temperament is a clear and present danger to normal political and diplomatic transactions. In the last few hours we've seen conflicting statements from the White House, US State Department and the American embassy in Canberra. The refugee deal has swung from on to maybe, back to on, and then Trump's declaration of it being dumb. Malcolm Turnbull has sought to protect the deal by not criticising the President but Trump's first weeks in office have shown that it's no longer business as usual. If this isn't enough to preoccupy the PM, he's now being irritated by renewed focus on his wealth. Last night he finally revealed just how much he gave to the Liberal Party at the last election.I contributed $1.75 million. That was the contribution I made. It's been talked about and speculated about. There it is.Jim Chalmers accused Malcolm Turnbull of using his bulging wallet to buy the lection, sparking furious offence. That's a grubby political smear from a grubby political hack, of a party of hacks led by Bill Shorten.He said he's acted within his legal obligations but I don't think he's acted within his ethical obligations. When you're going to make a monster donation you have to touch to think it's not relevant.He goes out there every day and attacks me for having done well, paid tax, made a quid, bought a nice house. He hates that. And he calls me Mr Harbourside MansionIt was Tony Abbott's chief of staff who gave Malcolm Turnbull the nickname Mr Harbourside Mansion and it clearly still rankles.I can't be bought by anyone. I'm not a wholly owned subsidiary of the CFMEU like Bill Shorten, I'm my own man. And Bill Shorten hates that.As to the future of the refugee deal, the PM is still holding the line.

The President's Twitter accounts has gone silent which might mean he's asleep. But in this brave new world of Trump, no-one can be sure what will happen when the alarm goes off in the morning. So, should Malcolm Turnbull take a tougher public stance against Donald Trump? Certainly former Labor foreign minister Bob Carr seems to think so. Carr has penned an editorial calling Trump a loudmouth nationalist. He says our leaders have acted like doting couriers in the past to the US and Trump's behaviour is a wake-up call to those who insist we-a special relationship with America. Bock Carr heads the Australia China Relations Institute at the University of Technology. He joined me earlier from Singapore. Bob Carr, good to have you with us. You've written an editorial where you are questioning the future and scope of the US-Australia alliance. Is that not an overreaction to the Trump presidency?It would be if that's what I was saying but in the piece I've written, I say this is a healt thing for Australia. The response of -- healthy thing for Australia, the response of Donald Trump to the phone call made by our PM. I think it's a reminder to Australians that America is different, America has changed. America is declaring it's America first from now on. That's a quote from the inauguration speech by the President. And I just think it's healthy if we absorb that fact. Everyone supports thuliance in Australia, there's a concensus on that. It's one of the pillars of Australian foreign policy but it's not the andwle the end all of Australia's international character. That's the point I'm making.I hear you on the nature of Donald Trump and what he's had to say about America's role in the world but how is that helped the relationship with the US and dealing with Donald Trump when you were using phrases such as a loudmouth nationalist, that's what you were calling him, you're saying it should wake us up to the quaint belief that the US-Australia relationship is somehow something special? How does that help in what is a volatile time?Stan, take that point on the notion that somehow we've got the most special relationship wumeric in the world. I could easily give you a list of 20 countries that hold that belief. America is the proud possessor of an alliance system, it's one of the things that distinguishes the US and advantages it over any other contenders for global leadership. And it's useful if Australians understand that Poland, for example, would regard itself as having every bit a special a relationship with the US as Australia. That Barack Obama on his farewell tour to Europe was talking about Germany as America's most important partner in the world. In Britain, the T Trans Atlantic Alliance is regarded as the apostles creed. We have to be practical about the alliance. It is not the only path of our international personality. And if this rude dismissal of the representations by an Australian PM altogether legitimate representations by President Trump serves to remind Australians of that great truth, then it's a good and healthy thing.You talk about being realistic and sensitable. Is that not what Malcolm Turnbull is doing here? He's negotiated with Donald Trump? He says he has secured the deal to take some out of silm seekers with the US? -- asylum seekers with the US - is that not better than calling him a loudmouth nationalist or other insults others have thrown at Donald Trump?If you're saying no Australian can criticise Donald Trump, that's a remarkable position to adopt. I think Donald Trump ought to be taken at his own measure. He is saying he's a nationalist. He's saying, he said it in his inaugural address that he's put America first. He called NATO a redundant alliance. Now, we don't want to live, we don't want to live under the illusion that things are the same as they once were. Where an American President can tweet his contempt for an Australian PM Australia what the Australian PM might have expected to have been treated as a confidential exchange between friends. This has been, it has been a rude treatment of an Australian leader unprecedented in the contact between Australian leadership and American leadership. It was followed up by a highly offensive tweet that was entirely unnecessary. And it contained, it contained the measure that this American President doesn't regard ANZUS as a useful starting point for the Australian-American relationship. You don't treat a loyal treaty partner like this. That's why I said and I said and I I hope it appears tomorrow that this is a healt thing and we ought to reflect -- healthy thing and we ought to reflect on it.The US is still a key part of the world global order. It's been a bedrock, as you know, a bedrock of security and stability in the region and the relationship has been the bedrock won for Australia as well as Malcolm Turnbull seeks to navigate that at these times - snrt it better to be prudent rather than to be -- rather it better to be prudent rather than to do this?If Australians are banned on commenting on the most negative exchange between an Australian PM and an American President, going back - and I don't know what's become as any notion of us as an independent nation and one that chooses to be an alliance partner of the US. That's how status here. If criticism of the US is forbidden, if it's beyond the possibility that we could respond to a nationalistic dismissal of an Australian PM by the new American PM, I don't know what's become of us.Good to talk to you, Sir. Thank you again for joining us.My pleasure, thank you.The image of tennis in Australia is dominated by glamour events such as the recent Australian Open or the Davis Cup tie starting tomorrow. Last year's child abuse royal commission explored the failings of tennis management in addressing allegations of sexual abuse against a coach. For the first time tonight the people involved in that case are speaking about their sense of betrayal in how they were and continue to be treated.

She was an optimistic person. She became a target.In 1995, when a girl made the New South Wales Junior Tennis squad at just 15, her dreams were coming true. Her mother would later claim in the royal commission those dreams were shattered by her contact with this man, and the way that contact was handled. Ending with the girl falling apart, suffering depression, anorexia, drug use, attempting suicide, fracturing her family.We have really struggled hard with not being able to protect our daughter.His name is Noel Callaghan. He was thusistent state squad coach.Noel was well respected in the industry and had a very good name as a coach. And results with players.Noel Callaghan's CV boasts coaching history with some top players. He has always fiercely denied any wrongdoing.It's pretty much been my life. It's my passion. It's something I just love doing and love helping players.Noel Callaghan started to coach the girl, whom we're only allowed to call BXJ, mostly at Sydney's prestigious White City Club. BXJ later told andles tennis investigators that their coach frequently peppered their conversations with demeaning and sexual comments. At the time Amanda Chaplin was an assistant state women's coach. She says she witnessed Mr Callaghan making inappropriate remarks like the time she spoke to him about including BXJ in a post junior squad.I remember calling and saying would it be possible for her to come down to the squad and attend the squad? And he said, "Not that effing tart. She will be out the back screwing all the blokes and then saying 'Who is next?'"What did you say?I said, "I can't believe you just said that and Don't Get Excited say that to me? She's good enough -- and don't just say that to me. She's good enough to be in the squad and is she able to come?" That wasn't the first time I heard that with him.BXJ later told investigators his behaviour escalated. Once with Mr Callaghan putting a hand on her leg in a taxi ride. Then she said later on at a tennis camp something happened that shocked her. BXJ's mother later gave evidence that Noel Callaghan came into her daughter's room one night. He straddled her legs and tried to kiss her several times. She kept trying to push him off saying, "No. "Soon after, BXJ withdrew from Noel Callaghan's coaching sessions. Her mother told her new coach, BXD, another former student of Noel Callaghan, who had her own allegations.I felt very sick about it and I said it's happened to me too.BXD claims 10 years earlier, whether she was a promising player, she had been -- when she was a promising player, she had been raped by Noel Callaghan.He insisted he came in. Before I knew it he was pretty much on top of me.Mr Callaghan would be charged with the sexual assault of BXD. He vehemently denied any wrongdoing and was found not guilty. Back when BXD first heard about her new young student's claims, she says she took immediate steps to protect her, by telling Amanda Chaplin who raised it with Tennis New South Wales. It took 18 months for investigations to get under way and when they did they sparked the start of BXJ's decline. She was destroyed in her life by the actions of those involved at that institutional investigation.The lawyer for Tennis New South Wales interviewed the girl twice. The second time proved disastrous. Her parents sat outside the room, barred from accompanying her. BXJ was quizzed by Tennis New South Wales's lawyer, along with the then CEO Craig Watson and John qhitker.She was extremely distressed.BXJ was questioned about the detail of each allegation and other things like how many boyfriends she had and how long her shorts were?What kind of humanity was that to use against a teenage girl?The Royal Commission called the questioning insensitive and offensive. It said it was inappropriate that Tennis New South Wales officials were there.She was asked very personal, very intrusive and also pretty irrelevant questions about matters that would have been intimidating for anyone to answer, let alone a young woman who was already distressed by what had occurred.It totally stripped away her feelings of self-worth at the time.In your mind, there's no doubt about that link? It was that interview and her breakdown? Directly that day it was overwhelming. Overwhelmed her. And she never played tennis again. And hasn't been the same person potentially that she could have been. It's just to see the loss of what her life should have been.But behind the scenes, the Tennis New South Wales lawyer decided she was impressed by BXJ's evidence. She wrote a report for the board.

The lawyer presented the board with a waive for Noel Callaghan to stand him down. But Tennis New South Wales never revealed the report's existence to BXJ.Had it existed back when our daughter's case was being put together it would have perhaps given her more courage to face her fears then, perhaps maybe go forward. Or at least if she hadn't even gone forward to have that closure in herself that she actually was believed.Instead, Tennis New South Wales's board decided to get a second opinion. The author of that report concluded she was not so persuaded BXJ should be believed over Noel Callaghan and strongly advised against dismissing the coach. So Tennis New South Wales wrote to BXJ saying no action would be taken but inviting her to take her claims to the police or the Equal Opportunity Board.It was devastating. Absolutely devastating. 17 years later the royal commission sat not to consider the allegations against Noel Callaghan, but to put tennis bureaucracy on trial. It found Tennis New South Wales complete disregarded BXJ's welfare and abrogated its duty towards her. It was your organisation that had the responsibility to care for her, wasn't it?It was.Tennis New South Wales told it's learnt from the royal commission and is committed to creating a safer environment for players. In 2001 BXJ went to police and made a statement against the coach but Tennis New South Wales, citing privilege, didn't hand over the report that bolstered her claims. Charges were laid but dropped three years later the royal commission was told because she was too ill to pursue the case.To actually not pass over the information and to say that some of that information was privilege and to hold the most valuable information in that privileged document, that's not helping the child at all.Meanwhile, Amanda Chaplin was having problems of her own. She told the royal commission some supporters of Noel Callaghan started harassing her in person and via an anonymous letter campaign. She says because of her whistleblower role. She resigned.It was clear that they weren't going to change their mind on the employment of Noel. And probably healthwise it was healthy for me not to stay there.As well as BXJ and BXD, a third player made allegations against Noel Callaghan. In all he faced three sets of charges. Two were dropped. He was found not guilty in his only trial involving BXD. He's continued to coach players in Australia and overseas. He's told 7.30 the royal commission's open use of his name has been grossly unfair since he was not being judged, the system was.The President of Tennis Australia, Mr Steve Healy.A second revelation emerged from the royal commission, the person who represented Noel Callaghan when BXJ's claims were first investigated by Tennis New South Wales was Steve Healy, now the head of Tennis Australia. At the time he was a partner in a Sydney law firm and the head of a suburban tennis association. He was also a member of the Tennis Australia Player Development Board and Advisory Committee. Mr Healy declined an interview but Tennis Australia says:

Nevertheless, some have questioned the appropriateness of Mr Healy acting for Noel Callaghan, given his standing in the game at the time.It lacks judgement if an organisation creates the impression that somehow they are lining up to support the alleged offender, particularly so in circumstances where they're not providing appropriate support or counselling to the young person who is making the complaint.Mr Healy went on to become chairman of Tennis New South Wales and then Tennis Australia. He defends his record.I am proud:

It is not without some sense of shame and a great deal of sadness that we heard the evidence given to the royal commission.BXJ and Amanda have now received letters of apology from Tennis New South Wales, as well as one from Tennis Australia, apologising for everything that happened. Signed on Tennis Australia's behalf by Steve Healy. What's your reaction to that apology coming from Steve Healy?I personally struggle with that a lot. So many people involved in both organisations knew all about it.The women in this story had told 7.30 they're disappointed with Tennis Australia's response to the royal commission's damning findings. They wanted the apology to be high-profile, public and they want a public campaign, calling for anyone in tennis claiming to be victims of sexual assault to come forward. Tennis Australia says it's revamped its child and whistleblower protection policies and offered support to the people in this story, including access to their welfare staff. But the women we have interviewed are frustrated that measures they've suggested, like a hotline for victims, are still in the planning stage, months after the royal commission aired the issue.I guess they are acting out as instructed. That is, as I see it. They're ticking the boxes.I'd love to see them take more initiative to instigating things, to not having to prompt or to feel like I'm educating them.Meanwhile, BXJ's mother faces a more immediate battle to restore self-belief to her struggling daughter.That very simple phrase of being believed could have saved many years of heartache. Just to know that she's worthwhile.Irever rnt TV show South Park has never been -- Irreverent TV show South Park has never been afraid to have a go at religion. But Matt Stone and Trey Parker have said they're not anti-religion at all and have developed an affection mor Mormonism. They've written a staged musical called The Book Of Mormon which has already won nine Tony Awards. Monique Schafter caught up with them.Hello, my name is Elder Young. Did you know Jesus lived here in the USA?You can read all about it now in this nifty book. It's free. You don't have to pay.Hello. The show follows two young Mormon missionaries. What happens once they get to Uganda?When they get there it's basically these two white kids from Utah who have grown up in this insular community with the church and they're really happy and they really like where they've grown up and they believe the church's message and they want to spread the word and go to this place and they're dropped in the middle of one of those subsuheron African places where they can't get any -- subSaharan African places where they can't get any break.We have an intruder. He walked right into camp. I believe that Satan has a hold of you!Why did you decide to focus on Mormons?We grew up learning about Mormons because it was part of the little local culture and so we, we just knew a lot about Mormons and it was also, it's just a really interesting way to look at religion in general. It's such a young religion and its profit lived over 100 years ago.There's something about Mormon culture and the big smiles they have. It seems like they're always about to break out into song.I believe in 1978 God changed his mind about black people. You can be a Mormon. A Mormon who just believes.What the (BLEEP) is this?There are over six million Mormons in the US. In Australia we have around 150,000. Given there are less Mormons in Australia, do you think Aussies would still understand the show?We could all relate to that idea of growing up and you get out of high school and you go to the big city or to college or whatever your version is and you don't know anything is the reality. That's a great place to find the character and you put them into a pressure cooker where they don't know what to do. And comedy ensues and song and dancing.Yes.What do the Mormons generally think of your musical?We know Mormons who have seen the show and they like it. They're paying attention.There's a select few who view it as their Fiddler on the Roo. The Mormon Church in Melbourne has taken out an ad campaign to counteract some of the messages in the musical and ads at train stations and stuff like that. Do you think that's savvy PR?In New York, they took out ads and they were paying us and put ads in saying and they were just like, "You've seen the show. Now read the book." That is genius. Again, they're so smart. And I'm sure it is a tactic but it is also just who they are. It's genius.They're going to outnice you all the time.You've made a career out of dark sat i whether it's South Park, Team America or the -- dark satire, whether it's South Park, Team America - what's it like with current affairs?Satire has kind of become reality now. So it is really hard to make fun of and we had the last season of South Park ended a month and a half ago. We were really trying to make fun of what was going on but we couldn't keep up. It was like what was actually happening was way funnier than anything we could come up with. So we're kind of, we decided to back off and let them do their comedy and we'll do ours. Welcome to the Pentagon, Sir. I've been ordered to show you around. This way, please.So I can do whatever the (BLEEP) I want now? Yes, Sir. Here are all our military secrets and all classified information.Good.This is the drone program. You can kill anyone on earth remotely. Here's the keys.How important is the fight against censorship in these current times? It's been weird for us because we've rarely dealt with censorship. As much as we like to say we're sort of, and people say we're part of the champions of fighting against censorship. All that's ever happened for us is we make jokes and people throw awards and money at us.We're not victims of anything.Yeah. At least in America, I know. Whatever. I really think it's pretty robust. People say what they want. It's a pretty good place in that regard.Do you plan to take the show to other parts of Australia?Absolute leaf. Absolutely we'd love for it to stay here as long as it can. That's the dream.Hello!A very musical end to the program. I hope you can join us again tomorrow night the same time. I'll see you then. Goodnight.