Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download PDFDownload PDF 

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment

    11   SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED

Ms Gillard moved—That so much of the standing and sessional orders be suspended as would prevent the Member for Lalor from moving that this House condemns the Minister for Health and Ageing for undermining Australia’s Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme by implementing a new system of Special Patient Contributions which will:

(1)    put additional costs of hundreds of dollars per prescription on to patients with lung cancer, epilepsy and depression; and

(2)    create a new system of charging patients extra which will eventually be applied to a vast array of PBS medications.

Closure of Member

Mr Brough (Minister for Revenue and Assistant Treasurer) moved—That the Member be no longer heard.

Question—put.

*80

The House divided (the Deputy Speaker, Mr Wilkie, in the Chair)—

AYES, 80

Mr Abbott

Mrs Draper

Mr Keenan

Mr Schultz

Mr Anderson

Mr Dutton

Mrs D. M. Kelly

Mr Scott

Mr Andrews

Mrs Elson

Jackie Kelly

Mr Secker

Fran Bailey

Mr Entsch

Mr Laming

Mr Slipper

Mr Baird

Mr Farmer

Mrs Ley

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Mr Baker

Mr Fawcett

Mr Lloyd

Mr Somlyay

Mr Baldwin

Mr M. D. Ferguson

Mr McArthur *

Dr Southcott

Mr Barresi

Mr Forrest *

Mr McGauran

Dr Stone

Mr Bartlett

Ms Gambaro

Mrs Markus

Mr C. P. Thompson

Mr Billson

Mrs Gash

Mrs May

Mr Ticehurst

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Georgiou

Mrs Moylan

Mr Tollner

Ms J. Bishop

Mr Haase

Mr Nairn

Mr Truss

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hardgrave

Dr Nelson

Mr Tuckey

Mr Brough

Mr Henry

Mr Neville

Mr Turnbull

Mr Cadman

Mr Hockey

Ms Panopoulos

Mr M. A. J. Vaile

Mr Causley

Mrs Hull

Mr Pearce

Mrs D. S. Vale

Mr Ciobo

Mr Hunt

Mr Prosser

Mr Vasta

Mr Cobb

Dr Jensen

Mr Pyne

Dr Washer

Mr Costello

Mr Johnson

Mr Robb

Mr Windsor

Mr Downer

Mr Katter

Mr Ruddock

Mr Wood

NOES, 54

Mr Adams

Mr Emerson

Ms Hoare

Mr Price

Mr Albanese

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mrs Irwin

Mr Quick

Mr Beazley

Mr M. J. Ferguson

Mr Jenkins

Mr Ripoll

Mr Bevis

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms C. King

Mr Rudd

Ms Bird

Mr Garrett

Dr Lawrence

Mr Sawford

Mr Bowen

Mr Georganas

Ms Livermore

Mr Sercombe

Ms A. E. Burke

Ms George

Mr McClelland

Mr S. F. Smith

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Gibbons

Ms Macklin

Mr Snowdon

Ms Corcoran

Ms Gillard

Mr McMullan

Mr Swan

Mr Danby *

Ms Grierson

Mr Melham

Mr Tanner

Mr Edwards

Mr Griffin

Mr B. P. O’Connor

Mr K. J. Thomson

Mrs Elliot

Ms Hall *

Mr G. M. O’Connor

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms A. L. Ellis

Mr Hatton

Ms Owens

 

Ms K. M. Ellis

Mr Hayes

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

Mr Georganas (seconder) addressing the House—

Closure of Member

Mr Brough moved—That the Member be no longer heard.

Question—put.

*81

The House divided (the Deputy Speaker, Mr Wilkie, in the Chair)—

AYES, 78

Mr Abbott

Mrs Draper

Mrs D. M. Kelly

Mr Scott

Mr Anderson

Mr Dutton

Jackie Kelly

Mr Secker

Mr Andrews

Mrs Elson

Mr Laming

Mr Slipper

Fran Bailey

Mr Entsch

Mrs Ley

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Mr Baird

Mr Farmer

Mr Lloyd

Mr Somlyay

Mr Baker

Mr Fawcett

Mr McArthur *

Dr Southcott

Mr Baldwin

Mr M. D. Ferguson

Mr McGauran

Dr Stone

Mr Barresi

Mr Forrest *

Mrs Markus

Mr C. P. Thompson

Mr Bartlett

Ms Gambaro

Mrs May

Mr Ticehurst

Mr Billson

Mrs Gash

Mrs Moylan

Mr Tollner

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Georgiou

Mr Nairn

Mr Truss

Ms J. Bishop

Mr Haase

Dr Nelson

Mr Tuckey

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hardgrave

Mr Neville

Mr Turnbull

Mr Brough

Mr Henry

Ms Panopoulos

Mr M. A. J. Vaile

Mr Cadman

Mr Hockey

Mr Pearce

Mrs D. S. Vale

Mr Causley

Mrs Hull

Mr Prosser

Mr Vasta

Mr Ciobo

Mr Hunt

Mr Pyne

Dr Washer

Mr Cobb

Dr Jensen

Mr Robb

Mr Wood

Mr Costello

Mr Johnson

Mr Ruddock

 

Mr Downer

Mr Keenan

Mr Schultz

 

NOES, 54

Mr Adams

Mr Emerson

Ms Hoare

Mr Price

Mr Albanese

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mrs Irwin

Mr Quick

Mr Beazley

Mr M. J. Ferguson

Mr Jenkins

Mr Ripoll

Mr Bevis

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms C. King

Mr Rudd

Ms Bird

Mr Garrett

Dr Lawrence

Mr Sawford

Mr Bowen

Mr Georganas

Ms Livermore

Mr Sercombe

Ms A. E. Burke

Ms George

Mr McClelland

Mr S. F. Smith

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Gibbons

Ms Macklin

Mr Snowdon

Ms Corcoran

Ms Gillard

Mr McMullan

Mr Swan

Mr Danby *

Ms Grierson

Mr Melham

Mr Tanner

Mr Edwards

Mr Griffin

Mr B. P. O’Connor

Mr K. J. Thomson

Mrs Elliot

Ms Hall *

Mr G. M. O’Connor

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms A. L. Ellis

Mr Hatton

Ms Owens

 

Ms K. M. Ellis

Mr Hayes

Ms Plibersek

 

* Tellers

And so it was resolved in the affirmative.

Question—That the motion for the suspension of standing and sessional orders be agreed to—put.

*82

The House divided (the Deputy Speaker, Mr Wilkie, in the Chair)—

AYES, 54

Mr Adams

Mr Emerson

Ms Hoare

Mr Price

Mr Albanese

Mr L. D. T. Ferguson

Mrs Irwin

Mr Quick

Mr Beazley

Mr M. J. Ferguson

Mr Jenkins

Mr Ripoll

Mr Bevis

Mr Fitzgibbon

Ms C. King

Mr Rudd

Ms Bird

Mr Garrett

Dr Lawrence

Mr Sawford

Mr Bowen

Mr Georganas

Ms Livermore

Mr Sercombe

Ms A. E. Burke

Ms George

Mr McClelland

Mr S. F. Smith

Mr A. S. Burke

Mr Gibbons

Ms Macklin

Mr Snowdon

Ms Corcoran

Ms Gillard

Mr McMullan

Mr Swan

Mr Danby *

Ms Grierson

Mr Melham

Mr Tanner

Mr Edwards

Mr Griffin

Mr B. P. O’Connor

Mr K. J. Thomson

Mrs Elliot

Ms Hall *

Mr G. M. O’Connor

Ms Vamvakinou

Ms A. L. Ellis

Mr Hatton

Ms Owens

 

Ms K. M. Ellis

Mr Hayes

Ms Plibersek

 

NOES, 78

Mr Abbott

Mrs Draper

Mrs D. M. Kelly

Mr Scott

Mr Anderson

Mr Dutton

Jackie Kelly

Mr Secker

Mr Andrews

Mrs Elson

Mr Laming

Mr Slipper

Fran Bailey

Mr Entsch

Mrs Ley

Mr A. D. H. Smith

Mr Baird

Mr Farmer

Mr Lloyd

Mr Somlyay

Mr Baker

Mr Fawcett

Mr McArthur *

Dr Southcott

Mr Baldwin

Mr M. D. Ferguson

Mr McGauran

Dr Stone

Mr Barresi

Mr Forrest *

Mrs Markus

Mr C. P. Thompson

Mr Bartlett

Ms Gambaro

Mrs May

Mr Ticehurst

Mr Billson

Mrs Gash

Mrs Moylan

Mr Tollner

Mrs B. K. Bishop

Mr Georgiou

Mr Nairn

Mr Truss

Ms J. Bishop

Mr Haase

Dr Nelson

Mr Tuckey

Mr Broadbent

Mr Hardgrave

Mr Neville

Mr Turnbull

Mr Brough

Mr Henry

Ms Panopoulos

Mr M. A. J. Vaile

Mr Cadman

Mr Hockey

Mr Pearce

Mrs D. S. Vale

Mr Causley

Mrs Hull

Mr Prosser

Mr Vasta

Mr Ciobo

Mr Hunt

Mr Pyne

Dr Washer

Mr Cobb

Dr Jensen

Mr Robb

Mr Wood

Mr Costello

Mr Johnson

Mr Ruddock

 

Mr Downer

Mr Keenan

Mr Schultz

 

* Tellers

And so it was negatived.