

- Title
AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY (SELF-GOVERNMENT) AMENDMENT (DISALLOWANCE AND AMENDMENT POWER OF THE COMMONWEALTH) BILL 2009
Second Reading
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
26-11-2009
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
42
- Electorate
Tasmania
- Interjector
- Page
8969
- Party
AG
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Brown, Sen Bob
- Stage
Second Reading
- Type
- Context
Bills
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2009-11-26/0096
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- PETITIONS
- BUSINESS
- NOTICES
- BUSINESS
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- BUSINESS
- TRADE PRACTICES AMENDMENT (MATERIAL LESSENING OF COMPETITION—RICHMOND AMENDMENT) BILL 2009
- NATIONAL PREVENTATIVE HEALTH TASKFORCE
- COMMITTEES
- NATIONAL YEAR OF ACTION ON MARRIAGE EQUALITY
- CIVIL PARTNERSHIPS
- LEGISLATIVE POWER OF THE TERRITORIES
-
CIVIL PARTNERSHIPS
LEGISLATIVE POWER OF THE TERRITORIES - COMMONWEALTH SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH ORGANISATION
- NORTHERN TERRITORY EMERGENCY RESPONSE REDESIGN CONSULTATION
- SNOWY WATER LICENCE
- VOLUNTEERS AND VOLUNTEER SUPPORTING ORGANISATIONS
- COMMITTEES
- AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY (SELF-GOVERNMENT) AMENDMENT (DISALLOWANCE AND AMENDMENT POWER OF THE COMMONWEALTH) BILL 2009
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- BUDGET
-
ACIS ADMINISTRATION AMENDMENT (APPLICATION) BILL 2009
COAL MINING INDUSTRY (LONG SERVICE LEAVE FUNDING) AMENDMENT BILL 2009
FOREIGN ACQUISITIONS AND TAKEOVERS AMENDMENT BILL 2009 -
AUSTRALIAN CENTRE FOR RENEWABLE ENERGY BILL 2009
AVIATION TRANSPORT SECURITY AMENDMENT (2009 MEASURES NO. 2) BILL 2009
NATIVE TITLE AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 2) 2009
SAFETY, REHABILITATION AND COMPENSATION AMENDMENT BILL 2009 - HEALTH INSURANCE AMENDMENT (COMPLIANCE) BILL 2009
- COMMITTEES
- ACIS ADMINISTRATION AMENDMENT (APPLICATION) BILL 2009
- BUSINESS
-
RESALE ROYALTY RIGHT FOR VISUAL ARTISTS BILL 2009
TAX LAWS AMENDMENT (RESALE ROYALTY RIGHT FOR VISUAL ARTISTS) BILL 2009 - TAX LAWS AMENDMENT (2009 MEASURES NO. 5) BILL 2009
- COAL MINING INDUSTRY (LONG SERVICE LEAVE FUNDING) AMENDMENT BILL 2009
- FAMILY ASSISTANCE LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (PARTICIPATION REQUIREMENT) BILL 2009
- CUSTOMS TARIFF AMENDMENT (INCORPORATION OF PROPOSALS) BILL 2009
-
PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES BILL 2009
PERSONAL PROPERTY SECURITIES (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2009 - HIGHER EDUCATION SUPPORT AMENDMENT (VET FEE-HELP AND TERTIARY ADMISSION CENTRES) BILL 2009
- MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
National School Chaplaincy Program
(Mason, Sen Brett, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Climate Change
(Collins, Sen Jacinta, Sherry, Sen Nick) -
Asylum Seekers
(Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta, Evans, Sen Chris) -
Greater Sunrise Project
(Brown, Sen Bob, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Testing and Certification Australia
(Heffernan, Sen Bill, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Building the Education Revolution Program
(Pratt, Sen Louise, Arbib, Sen Mark) -
Environment
(Troeth, Sen Judith, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Pharmaceutical Industry
(Xenophon, Sen Nick, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Uranium
(Trood, Sen Russell, Faulkner, Sen John) -
Building the Education Revolution Program
(Bilyk, Sen Catryna, Carr, Sen Kim)
-
National School Chaplaincy Program
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: ADDITIONAL ANSWERS
- OVERSEAS TAX HAVENS
- SENATORS’ STAFF: TRAVEL ENTITLEMENTS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- NOTICES
- MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS
- COMMONWEALTH SCIENTIFIC AND INDUSTRIAL RESEARCH ORGANISATION
- MINISTERIAL STATEMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- AUDITOR-GENERAL’S REPORTS
- BUDGET
-
GEOSCIENCE AUSTRALIA
HEALTH LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (MIDWIVES AND NURSE PRACTITIONERS) LEGISLATION - DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
-
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
AUSTRALIAN CLIMATE CHANGE REGULATORY AUTHORITY BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CHARGES—CUSTOMS) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CHARGES—EXCISE) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CHARGES—GENERAL) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CPRS FUEL CREDITS) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME (CPRS FUEL CREDITS) (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
EXCISE TARIFF AMENDMENT (CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CUSTOMS TARIFF AMENDMENT (CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]
CARBON POLLUTION REDUCTION SCHEME AMENDMENT (HOUSEHOLD ASSISTANCE) BILL 2009 [NO. 2]-
In Committee
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Boswell, Sen Ron
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Boswell, Sen Ron
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- McGauran, Sen Julian
- Division
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- McEwen, Sen Anne
- Wong, Sen Penny
- McGauran, Sen Julian
- Back, Sen Chris
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Nash, Sen Fiona
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Nash, Sen Fiona
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Williams, Sen John
- McGauran, Sen Julian
- Faulkner, Sen John
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Boswell, Sen Ron
- McGauran, Sen Julian
- Division
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Back, Sen Chris
- Procedural Text
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Ryan, Sen Scott
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Mason, Sen Brett
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Sherry, Sen Nick
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Sherry, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Sherry, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Sherry, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Sherry, Sen Nick
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Milne, Sen Christine
- Joyce, Sen Barnaby
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Williams, Sen John
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- McGauran, Sen Julian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Boswell, Sen Ron
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Abetz, Sen Eric
-
In Committee
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs
(Barnett, Sen Guy, Evans, Sen Chris) -
Housing, and Status of Women
(Barnett, Sen Guy, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Finance and Deregulation
(Ronaldson, Sen Michael, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Special Minister of State
(Ronaldson, Sen Michael, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Broadband, Communications and the Digital Economy: Legal Advice
(Barnett, Sen Guy, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Health and Ageing: Hospitals
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Swine Influenza
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe)
-
Families, Housing, Community Services and Indigenous Affairs
Page: 8969
Senator BOB BROWN (Leader of the Australian Greens) (10:55 AM)
—I move:
That this bill be now read a second time.
I seek leave to table an explanatory memorandum relating to the bill.
Leave granted.
Senator BOB BROWN
—I table the explanatory memorandum and I seek leave to have the second reading speech incorporated in Hansard.
Leave granted.
The speech read as follows—
At the election in 2008, 220019 voters in the Australian Capital Territory elected a legislature. Its laws should not be overridden by the federal government, in particular, the executive of the federal government.
The Commonwealth parliament’s power to make laws for the territory comes from Sections 52 and 122 of the Constitution. Notably, the Constitution gives this power to the parliament. In 1988, the parliament delegated the power to the elected Legislative Assembly of the ACT through the Australian Capital Territory (Self-Government) Act 1988. However, the Self-Government Act provided for the Commonwealth parliament or the executive to disallow or amend any act of the ACT’s Legislative Assembly.
This bill removes that power from the executive. It leaves no doubt that any disallowance or amendment of an ACT law should be by legislation of the parliament as a whole. The executive can and does meet in secret, without the direction or agreement of the parliament. The provision for the executive override of the ACT’s laws leaves parliament, and its consultative committee system, diminished and reactive. This is not in the spirit of the Constitution.
This bill removes this anomaly and restores the Parliament’s exclusive power to wield or constrain constitutional authority over the territorial assembly.
I commend the bill to the Senate.
Senator BOB BROWN
—I seek leave to continue my remarks later.
Leave granted; debate adjourned.