Save Search

Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Thursday, 1 November 2012
Page: 12934

The House divided. [12:09]

(The Speaker—Ms Anna Burke)

DIVISION:NOES 64 AYES 64 PAIRS 10
AYESNOESPAIRS
Albanese, ANBandt, AP
Bird, SLBowen, CE
Bradbury, DJBrodtmann, G
Burke, ASButler, MC
Byrne, AMChampion, ND
Cheeseman, DLCollins, JM
Combet, GICrean, SF
Danby, MD'Ath, YM
Dreyfus, MAElliot, MJ
Ellis, KMEmerson, CA
Ferguson, MJFitzgibbon, JA
Garrett, PRGeorganas, S
Gibbons, SWGray, G
Griffin, APHall, JG (teller)
Hayes, CPHusic, EN (teller)
Jenkins, HAJones, SP
Katter, RCKing, CF
Livermore, KFLyons, GR
Macklin, JLMcClelland, RB
Melham, DMitchell, RG
Murphy, JPNeumann, SK
O'Connor, BPJO'Neill, DM
Owens, JParke, M
Perrett, GDPlibersek, TJ
Ripoll, BFRishworth, AL
Rowland, MARoxon, NL
Rudd, KMSaffin, JA
Shorten, WRSmyth, L
Swan, WMSymon, MS
Thomson, CRThomson, KJ
Vamvakinou, MWilkie, AD
Windsor, AHCZappia, A
Alexander, JGAndrews, KJ
Andrews, KLBaldwin, RC
Billson, BFBishop, BK
Bishop, JIBriggs, JE
Broadbent, REBuchholz, S
Chester, DChristensen, GR
Ciobo, SMCobb, JK
Coulton, M (teller)Dutton, PC
Entsch, WGFletcher, PW
Frydenberg, JAGambaro, T
Gash, JGriggs, NL
Hartsuyker, LHawke, AG
Hockey, JBHunt, GA
Irons, SJJensen, DG
Jones, ETKelly, C
Laming, ALey, SP
Macfarlane, IEMarino, NB
Markus, LEMatheson, RG
McCormack, MFMirabella, S
Morrison, SJNeville, PC
Oakeshott, RJMO'Dowd, KD
O'Dwyer, KMPrentice, J
Pyne, CMRamsey, RE
Randall, DJRobb, AJ
Roy, WBRuddock, PM
Scott, BCSecker, PD (teller)
Simpkins, LXLSlipper, PN
Smith, ADHSouthcott, AJ
Stone, SNTehan, DT
Truss, WETudge, AE
Turnbull, MBVan Manen, AJ
Vasta, RXWyatt, KG
Clare, JDForrest, JA
Ferguson, LDTHaase, BW
Gillard, JEAbbott, AJ
Grierson, SJSomlyay, AM
Kelly, MJSchultz, AJ
Leigh, AKKeenan, M
Marles, RDCrook, AJ
Sidebottom, PSMoylan, JE
Smith, SFRobert, SR
Snowdon, WEWasher, M

The numbers for the ayes and noes being equal, Madam Speaker gave her casting vote with the ayes.

Question agreed to.