Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Monday, 16 November 2009
Page: 11704
[5:43 PM]

The House divided.    

(The Deputy Speaker—Mr S Sidebottom)

DIVISION:NOES 76 (27 majority) AYES 49 PAIRS 3
AYESNOESPAIRS
Abbott, A.J.Baldwin, R.C.
Billson, B.F.Bishop, B.K.
Briggs, J.E.Broadbent, R.
Chester, D.Ciobo, S.M.
Coulton, M.Dutton, P.C.
Farmer, P.F.Forrest, J.A.
Gash, J.Georgiou, P.
Haase, B.W.Hartsuyker, L.
Hawke, A.Hawker, D.P.M.
Hull, K.E. *Hunt, G.A.
Irons, S.J.Jensen, D.
Keenan, M.Laming, A.
Ley, S.P.Lindsay, P.J.
Marino, N.B. *Markus, L.E.
May, M.A.Mirabella, S.
Moylan, J.E.Oakeshott, R.J.M.
Pyne, C.Ramsey, R.
Randall, D.J.Robb, A.
Robert, S.R.Ruddock, P.M.
Schultz, A.Scott, B.C.
Secker, P.D.Simpkins, L.
Southcott, A.J.Stone, S.N.
Truss, W.E.Vale, D.S.
Washer, M.J.Windsor, A.H.C.
Wood, J.
Adams, D.G.H.Albanese, A.N.
Bidgood, J.Bird, S.
Bowen, C.Bradbury, D.J.
Burke, A.E.Butler, M.C.
Byrne, A.M.Campbell, J.
Champion, N.Cheeseman, D.L.
Clare, J.D.Collins, J.M.
Combet, G.Crean, S.F.
D’Ath, Y.M.Danby, M.
Debus, B.Dreyfus, M.A.
Elliot, J.Ellis, K.
Emerson, C.A.Ferguson, L.D.T.
Ferguson, M.J.Fitzgibbon, J.A.
Garrett, P.Georganas, S.
George, J.Gibbons, S.W.
Gray, G.Grierson, S.J.
Griffin, A.P.Hale, D.F.
Hall, J.G. *Hayes, C.P. *
Irwin, J.Jackson, S.M.
Kelly, M.J.Kerr, D.J.C.
King, C.F.Livermore, K.F.
Macklin, J.L.Marles, R.D.
McClelland, R.B.McKew, M.
McMullan, R.F.Melham, D.
Murphy, J.Neal, B.J.
Neumann, S.K.O’Connor, B.P.
Owens, J.Parke, M.
Perrett, G.D.Plibersek, T.
Price, L.R.S.Raguse, B.B.
Rea, K.M.Ripoll, B.F.
Rishworth, A.L.Roxon, N.L.
Saffin, J.A.Shorten, W.R.
Smith, S.F.Snowdon, W.E.
Sullivan, J.Swan, W.M.
Symon, M.Tanner, L.
Thomson, C.Thomson, K.J.
Trevor, C.Turnour, J.P.
Vamvakinou, M.Zappia, A.
Neville, P.C.Ellis, A.L.
Somlyay, A.M.Burke, A.S.
Bailey, F.E.Bevis, A.R.

* denotes teller

Question negatived.