Save Search

Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Ch10 Legislation / ORDINARY BILL PROCEDURE / Second reading / Determination of question for second reading



Download WordDownload Word

House of Representatives                                Ch 10                                                 p 362

 

Legislation / ORDINARY BILL PROCEDURE / Second reading

 

Determination of question for second reading

When debate on the motion for the second reading has concluded, and any amendment has been disposed of, the House determines the question on the second reading ‘That this bill be now read a second time’. On this question being agreed to, the Clerk reads the long title of the bill.

Only one government bill has been negatived at the second reading stage in the House of Representatives, 1 but there have been a number of cases in respect of private Members’ bills. 2 The accepted practice of the House has been that in cases where the second reading has been negatived, the motion for the second reading has not been moved again.

The modern practice of the House of Commons is that defeat on second reading is fatal to a bill. 3 In the Senate rejection of the motion that a bill be read a second time does not prevent the Senate from being asked subsequently to grant the bill a second reading. 4



VP 1922/207.



E.g. VP 1937-40/496; VP 1976-77/130, 442-3, 487.



May, 23rd edn, p. 583.



Odgers , 11th edn, p. 236.