Save Search

Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Ch10 Legislation / ORDINARY BILL PROCEDURE / Second reading / Second reading amendment / ADDITION OF WORDS



Download WordDownload Word

House of Representatives                                Ch 10                                                 p 358

 

Legislation / ORDINARY BILL PROCEDURE / Second reading / Second reading amendment

 

Addition of words

A reasoned amendment may not propose the addition of words to the question ‘That this bill be now read a second time’. 1 The addition of words must, by implication, attach conditions to the second reading. 2 The Senate has not adopted this rule, on the basis that as a House of review, it should be allowed every opportunity to project viewpoints. 3



S.O. 145(a)(iii); VP 1940/87. Until a change in the standing orders in 1965 this prohibition was not explicit and attempts to move amendments seeking to add words to the motion for the second reading were ruled out of order on the basis of House of Commons practice.



May, 23rd edn, p. 584. Other kinds of amendment with conditional wording have been accepted by the House (‘. . . will not decline to give the bill a second reading if . . .’, VP 1993-95/1777-8). However, the immediate question—That the words stand—does not suggest conditional acceptance.



J 1977/399; Odgers , 5th edn, p. 309.