Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Full Day's HansardDownload Full Day's Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Thursday, 12 May 1921


Senator PEARCE (Western Australia) (Minister for Defence) . -I am afraid thatif the amendment were agreed to it would be impossible to administer the proposed section. For instance, a man might purchase a pipe or tobacco from a canteen, and if the amendment were agreed to he would not be able to sell the articles again.


Senator Elliott - A canteen is like an ordinary organization.


Senator PEARCE - Still, certain funds are supplied to originate a canteen.


Senator Foster - Would the section not cover such things as trench comforts funds and battalion funds'?


Senator PEARCE - The Red Cross is a permanent organization: Trench comforts funds were organized during the war. An attempt is being made to continue them for the Citizen Forces, but I am very doubtful whether that can be done. I am afraid that it would be found so difficult to administer the amendment that it would become a dead letter. I doubt whether it would accomplish anything, and it might make it an offence to do certain things which should hot be regarded as offences. If a man gets an article from a canteen, what objection can there be to his selling it afterwards?


Senator Elliott - That article would not be supplied by any person.


Senator PEARCE - It would be supplied in the first instance to the canteen. The honorable senator will remember that canteens were started in Australia in the first place by a grant from the Treasury. I shall not oppose the amendment, but. will have it examined to see whether it is necessary that it should be reconsidered, in which case the clause can be recommitted.







Suggest corrections