

- Title
HVP No 47 - 15 June 2011
2 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED
- Database
House Votes and Proceedings
- Date
15-06-2011
- Source
House of Reps
- Number
47
- Page
633
- Status
Final
- Federation Chamber / Main Committee
no
- System Id
chamber/votes/2011-06-15/0003

Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
House Votes and Proceedings
-
House
- 1 MEETING OF THE HOUSE
- 2 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED
- 3 COMPETITION AND CONSUMER LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 2011
- 4 ECONOMICS—STANDING COMMITTEE—REPORT—STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS
- 5 FAMILY ASSISTANCE LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (CHILD CARE FINANCIAL VIABILITY) BILL 2011
- 6 GOVERNANCE OF AUSTRALIAN GOVERNMENT SUPERANNUATION SCHEMES BILL 2011
- 7 COMSUPER BILL 2011
- 8 SUPERANNUATION LEGISLATION (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS AND TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS) BILL 2011
- 9 CARBON CREDITS (CARBON FARMING INITIATIVE) BILL 2011
- 10 MEMBERS’ STATEMENTS
- 11 QUESTIONS
- 12 AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE—REPORT
- 13 SELECTION COMMITTEE—REPORT
- 14 DOCUMENTS
- 15 DOCUMENTS—MOTION TO TAKE NOTE OF DOCUMENTS
- 16 DISCUSSION OF MATTER OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE—CARBON TAX
- 17 MESSAGES FROM THE SENATE
- 18 MESSAGE FROM THE SENATE—HIGHER EDUCATION SUPPORT AMENDMENT (NO. 1) BILL 2011
- 19 CARBON CREDITS (CARBON FARMING INITIATIVE) BILL 2011
- 20 ADJOURNMENT
- DOCUMENTS
- ATTENDANCE
- Main Committee
-
House
2 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED
Mr Dutton moved—That so much of the standing and sessional orders be suspended as would prevent the Member for Dickson from moving the following motion forthwith: That this House calls on the Minister for Health and Ageing to attend the Chamber and explain why publicly the Minister has made comments condemning contact with and donations from tobacco companies and yet privately has written to tobacco company executives seeking their financial support.
Closure of Member
Mr Albanese (Leader of the House) moved—That the Member be no longer heard.
Question—put.
*105
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 70
Mr Adams |
Mr Dreyfus |
Ms King |
Ms Rishworth |
Mr Albanese |
Mrs Elliot |
Dr Leigh |
Ms Roxon |
Ms Bird |
Ms Ellis |
Ms Livermore |
Mr Rudd |
Mr Bowen |
Dr Emerson |
Mr Lyons |
Ms Saffin |
Mr Bradbury |
Mr L. D. T. Ferguson |
Mr McClelland |
Mr Shorten |
Ms Brodtmann |
Mr M. J. Ferguson |
Ms Macklin |
Mr Sidebottom |
Ms A. E. Burke |
Mr Fitzgibbon |
Mr Marles |
Mr S. F. Smith |
Mr A. S. Burke |
Mr Garrett |
Mr Melham |
Ms Smyth |
Mr Butler |
Mr Georganas |
Mr Mitchell |
Mr Snowdon |
Mr Byrne |
Mr Gibbons |
Mr Murphy |
Mr Swan |
Mr Champion |
Ms Gillard |
Mr Neumann |
Mr Symon |
Mr Cheeseman |
Mr Gray |
Mr O’Connor |
Mr C. R. Thomson |
Mr Clare |
Ms Grierson |
Ms O’Neill |
Mr K. J. Thomson |
Ms Collins |
Mr Griffin |
Ms Owens |
Ms Vamvakinou |
Mr Combet |
Ms Hall* |
Ms Parke |
Mr Wilkie |
Mr Crean |
Mr Hayes* |
Mr Perrett |
Mr Zappia |
Mr Danby |
Mr Husic |
Ms Plibersek |
|
Mrs D’Ath |
Mr S. P. Jones |
Mr Ripoll |
|
NOES, 74
Mr Abbott |
Mr Entsch |
Mr Macfarlane |
Mr Scott |
Mr Alexander |
Mr Fletcher |
Ms Marino |
Mr Secker* |
Mr K. J. Andrews |
Mr Forrest |
Mrs Markus |
Mr Simpkins |
Mrs K. L. Andrews |
Mr Frydenberg |
Mr Matheson |
Mr Slipper |
Mr Baldwin |
Ms Gambaro |
Mrs Mirabella |
Mr A. D. H. Smith |
Mr Bandt |
Mrs Gash |
Mr Morrison |
Mr Somlyay |
Mr Billson |
Mrs Griggs |
Mrs Moylan |
Dr Southcott |
Mrs B. K. Bishop |
Mr Haase |
Mr Oakeshott |
Dr Stone |
Ms J. I. Bishop |
Mr Hartsuyker |
Mr O’Dowd |
Mr Tehan |
Mr Briggs |
Mr A. G. Hawke |
Ms O’Dwyer |
Mr Truss |
Mr Broadbent |
Mr Hunt |
Mrs Prentice |
Mr Tudge |
Mr Buchholz |
Mr Irons |
Mr Pyne |
Mr Turnbull |
Mr Chester |
Dr Jensen |
Mr Ramsey |
Mr van Manen |
Mr Christensen |
Mr E. T. Jones |
Mr Randall |
Mr Vasta |
Mr Ciobo |
Mr Keenan |
Mr Robb |
Dr Washer |
Mr Cobb |
Mr C. Kelly |
Mr Robert |
Mr Windsor |
Mr Coulton* |
Mr Laming |
Wyatt Roy |
Mr Wyatt |
Mr Crook |
Ms Ley |
Mr Ruddock |
|
Mr Dutton |
Mr McCormack |
Mr Schultz |
|
* Tellers
Pairs
Ms Rowland Mr Neville
Dr M. J. Kelly Mr Hockey
And so it was negatived.
Mr Pyne moved—That Mr Dutton be granted an extension of time.
Question—put.
*106
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 72
Mr Abbott |
Mr Entsch |
Mr McCormack |
Mr Schultz |
Mr Alexander |
Mr Fletcher |
Mr Macfarlane |
Mr Scott |
Mr K. J. Andrews |
Mr Forrest |
Ms Marino |
Mr Secker* |
Mrs K. L. Andrews |
Mr Frydenberg |
Mrs Markus |
Mr Simpkins |
Mr Baldwin |
Ms Gambaro |
Mr Matheson |
Mr Slipper |
Mr Billson |
Mrs Gash |
Mrs Mirabella |
Mr A. D. H. Smith |
Mrs B. K. Bishop |
Mrs Griggs |
Mr Morrison |
Mr Somlyay |
Ms J. I. Bishop |
Mr Haase |
Mrs Moylan |
Dr Southcott |
Mr Briggs |
Mr Hartsuyker |
Mr O’Dowd |
Dr Stone |
Mr Broadbent |
Mr A. G. Hawke |
Ms O’Dwyer |
Mr Tehan |
Mr Buchholz |
Mr Hunt |
Mrs Prentice |
Mr Truss |
Mr Chester |
Mr Irons |
Mr Pyne |
Mr Tudge |
Mr Christensen |
Dr Jensen |
Mr Ramsey |
Mr Turnbull |
Mr Ciobo |
Mr E. T. Jones |
Mr Randall |
Mr van Manen |
Mr Cobb |
Mr Keenan |
Mr Robb |
Mr Vasta |
Mr Coulton* |
Mr C. Kelly |
Mr Robert |
Dr Washer |
Mr Crook |
Mr Laming |
Wyatt Roy |
Mr Windsor |
Mr Dutton |
Ms Ley |
Mr Ruddock |
Mr Wyatt |
NOES, 72
Mr Adams |
Mrs D’Ath |
Mr S. P. Jones |
Ms Plibersek |
Mr Albanese |
Mr Dreyfus |
Ms King |
Mr Ripoll |
Mr Bandt |
Mrs Elliot |
Dr Leigh |
Ms Rishworth |
Ms Bird |
Ms Ellis |
Ms Livermore |
Ms Roxon |
Mr Bowen |
Dr Emerson |
Mr Lyons |
Mr Rudd |
Mr Bradbury |
Mr L. D. T. Ferguson |
Mr McClelland |
Ms Saffin |
Ms Brodtmann |
Mr M. J. Ferguson |
Ms Macklin |
Mr Shorten |
Ms A. E. Burke |
Mr Fitzgibbon |
Mr Marles |
Mr Sidebottom |
Mr A. S. Burke |
Mr Garrett |
Mr Melham |
Mr S. F. Smith |
Mr Butler |
Mr Georganas |
Mr Mitchell |
Ms Smyth |
Mr Byrne |
Mr Gibbons |
Mr Murphy |
Mr Snowdon |
Mr Champion |
Ms Gillard |
Mr Neumann |
Mr Swan |
Mr Cheeseman |
Mr Gray |
Mr Oakeshott |
Mr Symon |
Mr Clare |
Ms Grierson |
Mr O’Connor |
Mr C. R. Thomson |
Ms Collins |
Mr Griffin |
Ms O’Neill |
Mr K. J. Thomson |
Mr Combet |
Ms Hall* |
Ms Owens |
Ms Vamvakinou |
Mr Crean |
Mr Hayes* |
Ms Parke |
Mr Wilkie |
Mr Danby |
Mr Husic |
Mr Perrett |
Mr Zappia |
* Tellers
Pairs
Ms Rowland Mr Neville
Dr M. J. Kelly Mr Hockey
The numbers for the “Ayes” and the “Noes” being equal, the Speaker gave his casting vote with the “Noes” noting that the proposition had not been supported by a majority and that by voting “No” he would not prevent further discussion of the proposition.
And so it was negatived.
Dr Southcott (seconder) addressing the House—
Closure of Member
Mr Albanese moved—That the Member be no longer heard.
Question—put.
*107
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 70
Mr Adams |
Mr Dreyfus |
Ms King |
Ms Rishworth |
Mr Albanese |
Mrs Elliot |
Dr Leigh |
Ms Roxon |
Ms Bird |
Ms Ellis |
Ms Livermore |
Mr Rudd |
Mr Bowen |
Dr Emerson |
Mr Lyons |
Ms Saffin |
Mr Bradbury |
Mr L. D. T. Ferguson |
Mr McClelland |
Mr Shorten |
Ms Brodtmann |
Mr M. J. Ferguson |
Ms Macklin |
Mr Sidebottom |
Ms A. E. Burke |
Mr Fitzgibbon |
Mr Marles |
Mr S. F. Smith |
Mr A. S. Burke |
Mr Garrett |
Mr Melham |
Ms Smyth |
Mr Butler |
Mr Georganas |
Mr Mitchell |
Mr Snowdon |
Mr Byrne |
Mr Gibbons |
Mr Murphy |
Mr Swan |
Mr Champion |
Ms Gillard |
Mr Neumann |
Mr Symon |
Mr Cheeseman |
Mr Gray |
Mr O’Connor |
Mr C. R. Thomson |
Mr Clare |
Ms Grierson |
Ms O’Neill |
Mr K. J. Thomson |
Ms Collins |
Mr Griffin |
Ms Owens |
Ms Vamvakinou |
Mr Combet |
Ms Hall* |
Ms Parke |
Mr Wilkie |
Mr Crean |
Mr Hayes* |
Mr Perrett |
Mr Zappia |
Mr Danby |
Mr Husic |
Ms Plibersek |
|
Mrs D’Ath |
Mr S. P. Jones |
Mr Ripoll |
|
NOES, 74
Mr Abbott |
Mr Entsch |
Mr Macfarlane |
Mr Scott |
Mr Alexander |
Mr Fletcher |
Ms Marino |
Mr Secker* |
Mr K. J. Andrews |
Mr Forrest |
Mrs Markus |
Mr Simpkins |
Mrs K. L. Andrews |
Mr Frydenberg |
Mr Matheson |
Mr Slipper |
Mr Baldwin |
Ms Gambaro |
Mrs Mirabella |
Mr A. D. H. Smith |
Mr Bandt |
Mrs Gash |
Mr Morrison |
Mr Somlyay |
Mr Billson |
Mrs Griggs |
Mrs Moylan |
Dr Southcott |
Mrs B. K. Bishop |
Mr Haase |
Mr Oakeshott |
Dr Stone |
Ms J. I. Bishop |
Mr Hartsuyker |
Mr O’Dowd |
Mr Tehan |
Mr Briggs |
Mr A. G. Hawke |
Ms O’Dwyer |
Mr Truss |
Mr Broadbent |
Mr Hunt |
Mrs Prentice |
Mr Tudge |
Mr Buchholz |
Mr Irons |
Mr Pyne |
Mr Turnbull |
Mr Chester |
Dr Jensen |
Mr Ramsey |
Mr van Manen |
Mr Christensen |
Mr E. T. Jones |
Mr Randall |
Mr Vasta |
Mr Ciobo |
Mr Keenan |
Mr Robb |
Dr Washer |
Mr Cobb |
Mr C. Kelly |
Mr Robert |
Mr Windsor |
Mr Coulton* |
Mr Laming |
Wyatt Roy |
Mr Wyatt |
Mr Crook |
Ms Ley |
Mr Ruddock |
|
Mr Dutton |
Mr McCormack |
Mr Schultz |
|
* Tellers
Pairs
Ms Rowland Mr Neville
Dr M. J. Kelly Mr Hockey
And so it was negatived.
The time allowed by standing order 1 for debate on the motion for the suspension of standing orders having expired and a question not having been proposed to the House, the motion lapsed.