

- Title
HVP No 45 - 02 June 2011
22 QUESTIONS
- Database
House Votes and Proceedings
- Date
02-06-2011
- Source
House of Reps
- Number
45
- Page
612
- Status
Final
- Main Committee
no
- System Id
chamber/votes/2011-06-02/0023
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
House Votes and Proceedings
-
House
- 1 MEETING OF THE HOUSE
- 2 SPEAKER’S STATEMENT AND RULING—DISSENT FROM RULING MOVED
- 3 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS—PRIVATE MEMBERS’ BUSINESS
- 4 INDEXATION OF MILITARY PENSIONS—REPORT FROM MAIN COMMITTEE
- 5 ISRAEL
- 6 CENTENARY OF THE CHOICE OF THE GRIFFIN DESIGN FOR THE NATIONAL CAPITAL—REPORT FROM MAIN COMMITTEE
- 7 SELECT COMMITTEE ON AUSTRALIA’S IMMIGRATION DETENTION NETWORK
- 8 HOME INSULATION PROGRAM (COMMISSION OF INQUIRY) BILL 2011
- 9 SCIENCE CURRICULUM—REPORT FROM MAIN COMMITTEE
- 10 REGIONAL AUSTRALIA—STANDING COMMITTEE—REPORT—STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS—MOTION TO TAKE NOTE OF DOCUMENT—REFERENCE TO MAIN COMMITTEE
- 11 FAMILY ASSISTANCE AND OTHER LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 2011
- 12 TAX LAWS AMENDMENT (2011 MEASURES NO. 5) BILL 2011
- 13 FINANCIAL FRAMEWORK LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 1) 2011
- 14 PUBLIC WORKS—PARLIAMENTARY STANDING COMMITTEE—REFERENCE OF WORK—INTEGRATED FIT-OUT OF NEW LEASED PREMISES FOR THE AUSTRALIAN TAXATION OFFICE AT 55 ELIZABETH STREET, BRISBANE, QLD
- 15 PUBLICATIONS COMMITTEE—REPORT
- 16 ELECTORAL MATTERS—JOINT STANDING COMMITTEE—MEMBERSHIP
- 17 AGED CARE AMENDMENT BILL 2011
- 18 TAXATION OF ALTERNATIVE FUELS BILLS 2011—COGNATE DEBATE
- 19 TAXATION OF ALTERNATIVE FUELS LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 2011
- 20 MEMBERS’ STATEMENTS
- 21 DEATH OF SERGEANT BRETT WOOD—CONDOLENCE MOTION—REPORT FROM MAIN COMMITTEE
- 22 QUESTIONS
- 23 STATING THE QUESTION ON AMENDMENTS—STATEMENT BY SPEAKER
- 24 SELECTION COMMITTEE—REPORT
- 25 DISCUSSION OF MATTER OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE—NATIONAL BROADBAND NETWORK
- 26 ADJOURNMENT
- ATTENDANCE
- Main Committee
-
House
22 QUESTIONS
Questions without notice being asked—
|
|
|
|
|
|
Suspension of standing and sessional orders moved
Mr Abbott (Leader of the Opposition) moved—That so much of the standing and sessional orders be suspended as would prevent the Member for Warringah moving immediately—That this House calls on the Prime Minister to explain to the Australian people why her Government has abandoned the manufacturing industry in this country by preparing to introduce a carbon tax. In particular, why the:
(1) Members for Corio and Corangamite aren’t standing up for the 1,300 workers at Ford in Geelong;
(2) Member for Gellibrand isn’t standing up for the 3,300 workers at Toyota in Altona;
(3) Member for Capricornia isn’t standing up for the 2,000 workers a the Newlands, German Creek and Moranbah coal mines;
(4) Members for Throsby and Cunningham aren’t standing up for the 7,000 workers at Bluescope Steel and Illawarra Coal;
(5) Member for Brand isn’t standing up for the 1,300 workers at Alcoa in Kwinana;
(6) Member for Calwell isn’t standing up for the 1,900 workers at Ford in Broadmeadows;
(7) Member for Hunter isn’t standing up for the 2,700 jobs at the Wambo, Mount Thorley, Mount Owen and Hunter Valley mines;
(8) Member for Lingiari isn’t standing up for the 850 workers at Rio Tinto/Alcoa Gove;
(9) Member for Wakefield isn’t standing up for the 2,700 workers at Holden in Elizabeth;
(10) Member for Bass isn’t standing up for the 560 workers at Alcan in Bell Bay; and
(11) Prime Minister won’t even stand up for the 466 workers in her own seat of Lalor who work at One Steel in Laverton.
Debate ensued.
The time allowed by standing order 1 for debate on the motion having expired—
Question—put.
*99
The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—
AYES, 72
|
Mr Abbott |
Mr Entsch |
Mr McCormack |
Mr Ruddock |
|
Mr Alexander |
Mr Fletcher |
Mr Macfarlane |
Mr Schultz |
|
Mr K. J. Andrews |
Mr Forrest |
Ms Marino |
Mr Scott |
|
Mrs K. L. Andrews |
Mr Frydenberg |
Mrs Markus |
Mr Secker* |
|
Mr Baldwin |
Ms Gambaro |
Mr Matheson |
Mr Simpkins |
|
Mr Billson |
Mrs Gash |
Mrs Mirabella |
Mr Slipper |
|
Mrs B. K. Bishop |
Mr Haase |
Mr Morrison |
Mr A. D. H. Smith |
|
Ms J. I. Bishop |
Mr Hartsuyker |
Mrs Moylan |
Mr Somlyay |
|
Mr Briggs |
Mr A. G. Hawke |
Mr Neville |
Dr Southcott |
|
Mr Broadbent |
Mr Hockey |
Mr O’Dowd |
Dr Stone |
|
Mr Buchholz |
Mr Hunt |
Ms O’Dwyer |
Mr Tehan |
|
Mr Chester |
Mr Irons |
Mrs Prentice |
Mr Truss |
|
Mr Christensen |
Dr Jensen |
Mr Pyne |
Mr Tudge |
|
Mr Ciobo |
Mr E. T. Jones |
Mr Ramsey |
Mr Turnbull |
|
Mr Cobb |
Mr Keenan |
Mr Randall |
Mr van Manen |
|
Mr Coulton* |
Mr C. Kelly |
Mr Robb |
Mr Vasta |
|
Mr Crook |
Mr Laming |
Mr Robert |
Dr Washer |
|
Mr Dutton |
Ms Ley |
Wyatt Roy |
Mr Wyatt |
NOES, 74
|
Mr Adams |
Mr Dreyfus |
Dr Leigh |
Ms Rowland |
|
Mr Albanese |
Mrs Elliot |
Ms Livermore |
Ms Roxon |
|
Mr Bandt |
Ms Ellis |
Mr Lyons |
Mr Rudd |
|
Ms Bird |
Mr L. D. T. Ferguson |
Mr McClelland |
Ms Saffin |
|
Mr Bowen |
Mr M. J. Ferguson |
Ms Macklin |
Mr Shorten |
|
Mr Bradbury |
Mr Fitzgibbon |
Mr Marles |
Mr Sidebottom |
|
Ms Brodtmann |
Mr Garrett |
Mr Melham |
Mr S. F. Smith |
|
Ms A. E. Burke |
Mr Georganas |
Mr Mitchell |
Ms Smyth |
|
Mr A. S. Burke |
Mr Gibbons |
Mr Murphy |
Mr Snowdon |
|
Mr Butler |
Ms Gillard |
Mr Neumann |
Mr Swan |
|
Mr Byrne |
Mr Gray |
Mr Oakeshott |
Mr Symon |
|
Mr Champion |
Ms Grierson |
Mr O’Connor |
Mr C. R. Thomson |
|
Mr Cheeseman |
Mr Griffin |
Ms O’Neill |
Mr K. J. Thomson |
|
Mr Clare |
Ms Hall* |
Ms Owens |
Ms Vamvakinou |
|
Ms Collins |
Mr Hayes* |
Ms Parke |
Mr Wilkie |
|
Mr Combet |
Mr Husic |
Mr Perrett |
Mr Windsor |
|
Mr Crean |
Mr S. P. Jones |
Ms Plibersek |
Mr Zappia |
|
Mr Danby |
Dr M. J. Kelly |
Mr Ripoll |
|
|
Mrs D’Ath |
Ms King |
Ms Rishworth |
|
* Tellers
Pairs
Dr Emerson Mrs Griggs
And so it was negatived.
|
|
|
|
|
|
Questions without notice concluded.