ParlInfo - HVP No 24 - 22 February 2011 : 7 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED

Permalink Prev Next Return to results list

Title: HVP No 24 - 22 February 2011

7 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED
Database: House Votes and Proceedings

Date: 22-02-2011
Source: House of Reps
Number: 24
Page: 328
Status: Final
Main Committee: no
System Id: chamber/votes/2011-02-22/0008

Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document

Table Of Contents

Download PDF

Previous Fragment Next Fragment

House Votes and Proceedings
- House
- Main Committee

Content Window

7 SUSPENSION OF STANDING AND SESSIONAL ORDERS MOVED

Mr Hockey moved—That so much of the standing and sessional orders be suspended as would prevent the Member for North Sydney from moving the following motion forthwith: That this House notes with deep concern the release of 25 secret Treasury documents contradicting the Treasurer about the impact of its proposed banking package including:

(1) claiming on 12 December 2010 that the package would “build up competition in our banking system” when the secret Treasury advice demonstrates that the absolute opposite is true;

(2) claiming on 12 December 2010 that the banking package would “ensure that interest rates are lower over time” when in the secret Treasury advice again the absolute opposite is true;

(3) failing to heed the warnings of the Treasury that “there are lots of risks and sensitivities associated with banning exit fees” including higher interest rates, higher bank fees and less transparency in banking;

(4) failing to heed the warnings of the Treasury that the Treasurer’s banking package “could disproportionately impact first home buyers”; and

(5) failing to heed the warnings of smaller financial services providers such as Aussie Home Loans, Bank of Queensland and Suncorp Metway that the banking package may reduce banking competition and lead to higher overall costs for consumers.

Debate ensuing—

Mr Albanese (Leader of the House) addressing the House—

Closure of Member

Mr Pyne moved—That the Member be no longer heard.

Question—put.

*45

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 69

Mr Abbott	Mr Forrest	Mr Macfarlane	Mr Scott
Mr Alexander	Mr Frydenberg	Ms Marino	Mr Secker*
Mr K. J. Andrews	Ms Gambaro	Mrs Markus	Mr Simpkins
Mrs K. L. Andrews	Mrs Gash	Mr Matheson	Mr Slipper
Mr Baldwin	Mrs Griggs	Mrs Mirabella	Mr A. D. H. Smith
Mr Billson	Mr Haase	Mr Morrison	Mr Somlyay
Mrs B. K. Bishop	Mr Hartsuyker	Mrs Moylan	Dr Stone
Ms J. I. Bishop	Mr A. G. Hawke	Mr Neville	Mr Tehan
Mr Broadbent	Mr Hockey	Mr O’Dowd	Mr Truss
Mr Buchholz	Mr Hunt	Ms O’Dwyer	Mr Tudge
Mr Chester	Mr Irons	Mrs Prentice	Mr Turnbull
Mr Christensen	Dr Jensen	Mr Pyne	Mr van Manen
Mr Ciobo	Mr E. T. Jones	Mr Ramsey	Mr Vasta
Mr Cobb	Mr Katter	Mr Randall	Dr Washer
Mr Coulton*	Mr C. Kelly	Mr Robb	Mr Wyatt
Mr Dutton	Mr Laming	Mr Robert
Mr Entsch	Ms Ley	Wyatt Roy
Mr Fletcher	Mr McCormack	Mr Ruddock

NOES, 73

Mr Adams	Mrs D’Ath	Ms King	Ms Rishworth
Mr Albanese	Mr Dreyfus	Dr Leigh	Ms Rowland
Mr Bandt	Mrs Elliot	Ms Livermore	Ms Roxon
Ms Bird	Dr Emerson	Mr Lyons	Ms Saffin
Mr Bowen	Mr L. D. T. Ferguson	Mr McClelland	Mr Shorten
Mr Bradbury	Mr M. J. Ferguson	Ms Macklin	Mr S. F. Smith
Ms Brodtmann	Mr Fitzgibbon	Mr Marles	Ms Smyth
Ms A. E. Burke	Mr Garrett	Mr Melham	Mr Snowdon
Mr A. S. Burke	Mr Georganas	Mr Mitchell	Mr Swan
Mr Butler	Mr Gibbons	Mr Murphy	Mr Symon
Mr Byrne	Ms Gillard	Mr Neumann	Mr C. R. Thomson
Mr Champion	Mr Gray	Mr Oakeshott	Mr K. J. Thomson
Mr Cheeseman	Ms Grierson	Mr O’Connor	Ms Vamvakinou
Mr Clare	Mr Griffin	Ms O’Neill	Mr Wilkie
Ms Collins	Ms Hall*	Ms Owens	Mr Windsor
Mr Combet	Mr Hayes*	Ms Parke	Mr Zappia
Mr Crean	Mr Husic	Mr Perrett
Mr Crook	Mr S. P. Jones	Ms Plibersek
Mr Danby	Dr M. J. Kelly	Mr Ripoll

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Ellis Mr Keenan

Mr Rudd Mr Schultz

Mr Sidebottom Mr Briggs

And so it was negatived.

The time allowed by standing order 1 for debate on the motion having expired—

Question—put.

*46

The House divided (the Speaker, Mr Jenkins, in the Chair)—

AYES, 71

Mr Abbott	Mr Fletcher	Mr McCormack	Mr Ruddock
Mr Alexander	Mr Forrest	Mr Macfarlane	Mr Scott
Mr K. J. Andrews	Mr Frydenberg	Ms Marino	Mr Secker*
Mrs K. L. Andrews	Ms Gambaro	Mrs Markus	Mr Simpkins
Mr Baldwin	Mrs Gash	Mr Matheson	Mr Slipper
Mr Billson	Mrs Griggs	Mrs Mirabella	Mr A. D. H. Smith
Mrs B. K. Bishop	Mr Haase	Mr Morrison	Mr Somlyay
Ms J. I. Bishop	Mr Hartsuyker	Mrs Moylan	Dr Stone
Mr Broadbent	Mr A. G. Hawke	Mr Neville	Mr Tehan
Mr Buchholz	Mr Hockey	Mr O’Dowd	Mr Truss
Mr Chester	Mr Hunt	Ms O’Dwyer	Mr Tudge
Mr Christensen	Mr Irons	Mrs Prentice	Mr Turnbull
Mr Ciobo	Dr Jensen	Mr Pyne	Mr van Manen
Mr Cobb	Mr E. T. Jones	Mr Ramsey	Mr Vasta
Mr Coulton*	Mr Katter	Mr Randall	Dr Washer
Mr Crook	Mr C. Kelly	Mr Robb	Mr Windsor
Mr Dutton	Mr Laming	Mr Robert	Mr Wyatt
Mr Entsch	Ms Ley	Wyatt Roy

NOES, 71

Mr Adams	Mrs D’Ath	Dr M. J. Kelly	Ms Plibersek
Mr Albanese	Mr Dreyfus	Ms King	Mr Ripoll
Mr Bandt	Mrs Elliot	Dr Leigh	Ms Rishworth
Ms Bird	Dr Emerson	Ms Livermore	Ms Rowland
Mr Bowen	Mr L. D. T. Ferguson	Mr Lyons	Ms Roxon
Mr Bradbury	Mr M. J. Ferguson	Mr McClelland	Ms Saffin
Ms Brodtmann	Mr Fitzgibbon	Ms Macklin	Mr Shorten
Ms A. E. Burke	Mr Garrett	Mr Marles	Mr S. F. Smith
Mr A. S. Burke	Mr Georganas	Mr Melham	Ms Smyth
Mr Butler	Mr Gibbons	Mr Mitchell	Mr Snowdon
Mr Byrne	Ms Gillard	Mr Murphy	Mr Swan
Mr Champion	Mr Gray	Mr Neumann	Mr Symon
Mr Cheeseman	Ms Grierson	Mr Oakeshott	Mr C. R. Thomson
Mr Clare	Mr Griffin	Mr O’Connor	Mr K. J. Thomson
Ms Collins	Ms Hall*	Ms O’Neill	Ms Vamvakinou
Mr Combet	Mr Hayes*	Ms Owens	Mr Wilkie
Mr Crean	Mr Husic	Ms Parke	Mr Zappia
Mr Danby	Mr S. P. Jones	Mr Perrett

* Tellers

Pairs

Ms Ellis Mr Keenan

Mr Rudd Mr Schultz

Mr Sidebottom Mr Briggs

The requirements of standing order 47(c)(ii) for an absolute majority having not been satisfied, the motion was not carried.

Previous Fragment Next Fragment

Menu Options

Senate

House of Representatives

Get informed

Bills

Committees

Get involved

Visit Parliament

APH Website features