

- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Climate Change
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
16-06-2009
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
42
- Electorate
South Australia
- Interjector
PRESIDENT, The
- Page
3313
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Wortley, Sen Dana
- Responder
Wong, Sen Penny
- Speaker
- Stage
Climate Change
- Type
- Context
Questions Without Notice
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2009-06-16/0043
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- BUSINESS
- NATION BUILDING PROGRAM (NATIONAL LAND TRANSPORT) AMENDMENT BILL 2009
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Employment
(Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta, Arbib, Sen Mark) -
Nation Building and Jobs Plan
(McEwen, Sen Anne, Evans, Sen Chris) -
Employment
(Fifield, Sen Mitchell, Arbib, Sen Mark) -
Climate Change
(Wortley, Sen Dana, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Broadband
(Minchin, Sen Nick, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Environment: Dieback
(Siewert, Sen Rachel, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Budget
(Bushby, Sen David, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Building the Education Revolution Program
(Marshall, Sen Gavin, Arbib, Sen Mark) -
Defence
(Johnston, Sen David, Faulkner, Sen John)
-
Employment
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- LEAVE OF ABSENCE
- COMMITTEES
- CAR DEALERSHIP FINANCING GUARANTEE APPROPRIATION BILL 2009
- COMMITTEES
- POLAND
- POLAND
- CHINA
- PERUVIAN AMAZON
- ANTARCTICA
- PARLIAMENTARIANS' ENTITLEMENTS
- AUSTRALIAN TERRESTRIAL BIODIVERSITY ASSESSMENT 2008
- MATTERS OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- COMMITTEES
-
INTERNATIONAL MONETARY AGREEMENTS AMENDMENT (FINANCIAL ASSISTANCE) BILL 2009
SOCIAL SECURITY AMENDMENT (TRAINING INCENTIVES) BILL 2009 - HEALTH INSURANCE AMENDMENT (EXTENDED MEDICARE SAFETY NET) BILL 2009
- SOCIAL SECURITY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IMPROVED SUPPORT FOR CARERS) (CONSEQUENTIAL AND TRANSITIONAL) BILL 2009
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- BUSINESS
-
AUSTRALIAN BUSINESS INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIP BILL 2009
AUSTRALIAN BUSINESS INVESTMENT PARTNERSHIP (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENT) BILL 2009 - BUSINESS
-
SOCIAL SECURITY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IMPROVED SUPPORT FOR CARERS) BILL 2009
SOCIAL SECURITY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IMPROVED SUPPORT FOR CARERS) (CONSEQUENTIAL AND TRANSITIONAL) BILL 2009 - DOCUMENTS
-
SOCIAL SECURITY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IMPROVED SUPPORT FOR CARERS) BILL 2009
SOCIAL SECURITY AMENDMENT (TRAINING INCENTIVES) BILL 2009- Second Reading
-
In Committee
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Fifield, Sen Mitchell
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Fifield, Sen Mitchell
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Fifield, Sen Mitchell
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Fifield, Sen Mitchell
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Third Reading
-
FAIR WORK (STATE REFERRAL AND CONSEQUENTIAL AND OTHER AMENDMENTS) BILL 2009
FAIR WORK (TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS AND CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2009-
In Committee
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Division
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Xenophon, Sen Nick
- Arbib, Sen Mark
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Fisher, Sen Mary Jo
-
In Committee
- ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Aged Care
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Australian Crime Commission: Stafffing
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Climate Change and Water: Media Contracts
(Ronaldson, Sen Michael, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Pacific Brands
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Snowy River
(Brown, Sen Bob, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Antarctica
(Brown, Sen Bob, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Special Minister of State: Electorate Office
(Ronaldson, Sen Michael, Faulkner, Sen John) -
Indigenous Tutorial Assistance Scheme
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Aged Care
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory Committee
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Pharmaceutical Benefits Advisory Committee
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Aged Care
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Taxation
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Taxation
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Budget Process
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Minister for the Environment, Heritage and the Arts
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Minister for the Environment, Heritage and the Arts
(Cormann, Sen Mathias, Evans, Sen Chris) -
Prime Minister and Cabinet: Website
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Evans, Sen Chris) -
Treasury: Website
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Conroy, Sen Stephen) -
Education: Music
(Milne, Sen Christine, Carr, Sen Kim) -
United Nations Framework Conventionon Climate Change
(Milne, Sen Christine, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Climate Change
(Milne, Sen Christine, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Climate Change
(Milne, Sen Christine, Carr, Sen Kim) -
National Water Initiative
(Milne, Sen Christine, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Regional Forest Agreement
(Milne, Sen Christine, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Education, Employment and Workplace Relations: Australian Workplace Agreements
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Ludwig, Sen Joe) -
Talisman Sabre Military Exercises
(Ludlam, Sen Scott, Faulkner, Sen John) -
Waratah Coal Inc. Rail Line
(Ludlam, Sen Scott, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Australian Nuclear Science and Technology Organisation
(Ludlam, Sen Scott, Carr, Sen Kim) -
Proposed Pulp Mill
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Foreign Affairs: Legal Expenses
(Ludlam, Sen Scott, Faulkner, Sen John) -
Dryland Salinity
(Bishop, Sen Mark, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Climate Change
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Wong, Sen Penny) -
Prime Minister: Advertising
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Evans, Sen Chris)
-
Aged Care
Page: 3313
Senator WORTLEY (2:27 PM)
—My question is to the Minister for Climate Change and Water, Senator Wong. Can the minister outline why it is necessary to act on climate change, can the minister provide authoritative sources that demonstrate that climate change is real and can the minister advise the Senate on whether there are any alternative views?
Senator WONG (Minister for Climate Change and Water)
—I thank Senator Wortley for the question and for her interest in climate change matters. There are, of course, a great number of authoritative sources that can be cited on the issue of climate change. But those opposite might be interested to hear from one authority in particular. That would, of course, be the Leader of the Opposition, Mr Turnbull. It is Mr Turnbull who has said:
… climate change is a fact, not a theory.
He also said that the work of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change ‘confirms that human activity is causing global warming’. The fact is that 13 of the 14 warmest years on record occurred between 1995 and 2008. But, sadly, on this issue Mr Turnbull’s party room still remains a safe haven for the climate change sceptics. He appears to be incapable of showing the strong leadership that is needed and standing up against the sceptics in the party room for what he knows is right. Last night we saw the extraordinary spectacle of a Liberal senator—
Honourable senators interjecting—
The PRESIDENT
—Order! When there is quiet we will proceed.
Senator WONG
—I was saying that last night we saw the extraordinary spectacle of a Liberal senator in this place actually being to the right of Senator Boswell on the issue of climate change, and I congratulate Senator Cash for that remarkable achievement. But, most importantly, Senator Cash broke ranks with her leader, Mr Turnbull, by demanding—
The PRESIDENT
—Order! There needs to be silence on my right when Senator Wong is answering the question. When we have order we will proceed.
Senator WONG
—As I said, Senator Cash is the latest in a line of senators and MPs who have broken ranks with their own leader, Malcolm Turnbull, but more importantly they do not even agree with John Howard. (Time expired)
Senator WORTLEY
—Mr President, I ask a supplementary question. Given the minister’s answer, can the minister now outline whether there is any hope on the horizon for action on climate change? Have any recent developments increased the likelihood of Australia making progress on climate change? Will it be possible for Australia to move forward on climate change?
Senator WONG (Minister for Climate Change and Water)
—It is quite clear from Mr Turnbull’s public statements that he does want to act on climate change. He was once one of the parliament’s strongest advocates for emissions trading, but since he has taken over the leadership, which I note he did so in part by campaigning against Dr Nelson on the issue of climate change, he has unfortunately been looking over his shoulder, watching his back against Mr Costello, worried about losing the support of the climate change sceptics such as Senator Cash. With Mr Costello now apparently out of the picture, we might see Malcolm Turnbull finally able to show the leadership to put Australia’s national interest ahead of his own political interests. Mr Turnbull should do what he knows is right. He should support action on climate change. Instead of looking over his shoulder, he now has the chance to look forward and look to the national interest.
Senator WORTLEY
—Mr President, I ask a further supplementary question. Can the minister further expand on the prospects for action on climate change? Is there any new evidence that the minister can provide to the Senate that climate change action may be possible?
Senator WONG (Minister for Climate Change and Water)
—There is some evidence—and it comes from a surprising quarter—of there being some light at the end of the tunnel and that is from Mr Abbott. This morning Mr Abbott was asked the question, ‘Do you think Turnbull now has more authority in the party room on difficult issues such as the CPRS now that Costello has gone?’ and Mr Abbott said:
All of those issues can now be discussed purely on their merits without any injection of personalities that might otherwise have occurred.
Tony Abbott has said it how it is. The internals of the Liberal Party have been driving the opposition’s position on climate change. So with Mr Costello out of the picture the question now is: does Mr Turnbull have the nerve to do what he knows is right, to stand up to those like Senator Cash, sceptics on that side, and support action on climate change? Those over there who know climate change is a real issue should turn up and say, ‘Hey, Malcolm, Peter’s gone; it’s your chance now to do the right thing.’