Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Wednesday, 3 September 2008
Page: 4369
[10:56 AM]

The committee divided.          

(The Chairman—Senator the Hon. AB Ferguson)

DIVISION:NOES 36 (2 majority) AYES 34 PAIRS 3
AYESNOESPAIRS
Arbib, M.V.Bilyk, C.L.
Bishop, T.M.Brown, B.J.
Brown, C.L.Cameron, D.N.
Collins, J.Conroy, S.M.
Crossin, P.M.Farrell, D.E.
Faulkner, J.P.Feeney, D.
Forshaw, M.G.Furner, M.L.
Hanson-Young, S.C.Hogg, J.J.
Hurley, A.Hutchins, S.P.
Ludlam, S.Ludwig, J.W.
Lundy, K.A.Marshall, G.
McEwen, A. *McLucas, J.E.
Milne, C.Moore, C.
O’Brien, K.W.K.Polley, H.
Pratt, L.C.Sherry, N.J.
Siewert, R.Stephens, U.
Sterle, G.Wortley, D.
Abetz, E.Adams, J.
Barnett, G.Bernardi, C.
Boswell, R.L.D.Boyce, S.
Brandis, G.H.Bushby, D.C.
Cash, M.C.Colbeck, R.
Coonan, H.L.Ellison, C.M.
Ferguson, A.B.Fielding, S.
Fierravanti-Wells, C.Fifield, M.P.
Fisher, M.J.Heffernan, W.
Humphries, G.Johnston, D.
Joyce, B.Kroger, H.
Macdonald, I.Mason, B.J.
McGauran, J.Minchin, N.H.
Nash, F. *Parry, S.
Payne, M.A.Ronaldson, M.
Ryan, S.M.Scullion, N.G.
Troeth, J.M.Trood, R.B.
Williams, J.R.Xenophon, N.
Carr, K.J.Eggleston, A.
Evans, C.V.Cormann, M.H.P.
Wong, P.Birmingham, S.

* denotes teller

Question negatived.