

- Title
EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (WELFARE TO WORK AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2005
FAMILY AND COMMUNITY SERVICES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (WELFARE TO WORK) BILL 2005
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
06-12-2005
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
41
- Electorate
South Australia
- Interjector
- Page
117
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Wong, Sen Penny
- Stage
In Committee
- Type
- Context
Bills
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2005-12-06/0162
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 2) 2005
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Welfare to Work
(Trood, Sen Russell, Abetz, Sen Eric) -
Mr Oday Adnan al-Tekriti
(Ludwig, Sen Joe, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Welfare to Work
(Payne, Sen Marise, Patterson, Sen Kay) -
Mr Robert Gerard
(Sherry, Sen Nick, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Economy
(Fierravanti-Wells, Sen Concetta, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Welfare to Work
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Working Holiday Program
(Nash, Sen Fiona, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Welfare to Work
(Brown, Sen Carol, Abetz, Sen Eric)
-
Welfare to Work
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: ADDITIONAL ANSWERS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- LEAVE OF ABSENCE
- PARLIAMENTARY ZONE
- HOCKEYROOS
- WORLD AIDS DAY
- TIME ZONES
- WHALING
- RESERVE BANK OF AUSTRALIA
- MR JOHN PATRICK DUCKER AO
- COMMITTEES
- WOMEN WITH DISABILITIES AUSTRALIA
- MR NGUYEN TUONG VAN
- EXPORT TRADE
- FALUN GONG
- AUDITOR-GENERAL’S REPORTS
- COMMITTEES
-
ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 2) 2005
-
In Committee
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Division
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Division
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Third Reading
-
In Committee
-
EMPLOYMENT AND WORKPLACE RELATIONS LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (WELFARE TO WORK AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2005
FAMILY AND COMMUNITY SERVICES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (WELFARE TO WORK) BILL 2005-
In Committee
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- McLucas, Sen Jan
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Moore, Sen Claire
- McLucas, Sen Jan
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Division
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Evans, Sen Chris
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- McLucas, Sen Jan
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- McLucas, Sen Jan
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- McLucas, Sen Jan
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Fielding, Sen Steve
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Siewert, Sen Rachel
- Abetz, Sen Eric
- Wong, Sen Penny
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Division
- Procedural Text
-
In Committee
- FAMILY AND COMMUNITY SERVICES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (WELFARE TO WORK) BILL 2005
- ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Minister for Finance and Administration: Overseas Travel
(Evans, Sen Chris, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Special Minister of State: Overseas Travel
(Evans, Sen Chris, Abetz, Sen Eric) -
Minister for Finance and Administration: Overseas Travel
(Evans, Sen Chris, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Finance and Administration: Grants
(O’Brien, Sen Kerry, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Finance and Administration: Grants
(O’Brien, Sen Kerry, Abetz, Sen Eric) -
Environment: Port Phillip Bay
(Brown, Sen Bob, Campbell, Sen Ian) -
Army: Incapacity Pay
(Bishop, Sen Mark, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Fuel Excise
(Milne, Sen Christine, Minchin, Sen Nick)
-
Minister for Finance and Administration: Overseas Travel
Page: 117
Senator WONG (7:31 PM)
—Firstly, I will start with a number of questions for the minister, although I note that he does not appear to have any advisers here. I am not sure if he wants me to talk more generally for a period of time. I suppose the first issue would be the evidence that was presented to the Senate Community Affairs Legislation Committee inquiring into this legislation. A great many submitters discussed their concerns about the bill and, in particular, made the point that the government had not presented any evidence that shifting people onto a lower payment would in fact help them get a job or have any effect on increasing the participation rate.
The committee asked this question of the department on, I think, the Monday and the department took it on notice. On the Wednesday the department provided references to a few international studies—some of which looked at the effect of increasing income support payments and the effect that would have on labour force participation, which obviously in this situation is entirely irrelevant. The committee was also presented with evidence by the department of a study—which I understand the government does not rely on—on the possibility of theoretically abolishing the social security system and whether that would help people get work. Can the minister confirm that the government has undertaken no modelling, economic research or any research whatsoever that it is putting forward with this legislation to the Senate that demonstrates that a reduction in income support payments will actually lead to a rise in labour force participation?