

- Title
URGENT LEGISLATION
Allotment of Time
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
12-08-2004
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
40
- Electorate
Queensland
- Interjector
ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT, The
Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Page
26497
- Party
NATS
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Boswell, Sen Ron
- Stage
Allotment of Time
- Type
- Context
Bills
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2004-08-12/0367
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- WOMEN: DOMESTIC VIOLENCE
- EDUCATION: HIGHER EDUCATION CONTRIBUTION SCHEME
- FOREIGN AFFAIRS: SUDAN
- COMMITTEES
- ELGIN MARBLES
- EDUCATION: HIGHER EDUCATION CONTRIBUTION SCHEME
- BUSINESS
- PARLIAMENTARY ZONE
- IMMIGRATION: DETAINEES
- JAMES HARDIE INDUSTRIES: COMPENSATION
- COMMITTEES
- BROADCASTING SERVICES AMENDMENT (ANTI-SIPHONING) BILL 2004
-
WATER EFFICIENCY LABELLING AND STANDARDS BILL 2004
VOCATIONAL EDUCATION AND TRAINING FUNDING AMENDMENT BILL 2004
TAX LAWS AMENDMENT (2004 MEASURES NO. 4) BILL 2004
NEW INTERNATIONAL TAX ARRANGEMENTS (MANAGED FUNDS AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2004 - CUSTOMS TARIFF AMENDMENT (OIL, GAS AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2004
- CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT (SUICIDE RELATED MATERIAL OFFENCES) BILL 2004
- COMMITTEES
- BUSINESS
-
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION BILL 2004
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION (CUSTOMS TARIFF) BILL 2004 - OCCUPATIONAL HEALTH AND SAFETY (COMMONWEALTH EMPLOYMENT) AMENDMENT (EMPLOYEE INVOLVEMENT AND COMPLIANCE) BILL 2002
- BUSINESS
- ELECTORAL AND REFERENDUM AMENDMENT (PRISONER VOTING AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2004
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Veterans' Affairs: Home Care Program
(Bishop, Sen Mark, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Defence: Policy
(Macdonald, Sen Sandy, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Defence: Standard Defence Supply System
(Evans, Sen Chris, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Social Welfare: Reform
(Colbeck, Sen Richard, Patterson, Sen Kay) -
Telstra: Mass Services Disruption Notices
(Marshall, Sen Gavin, Coonan, Sen Helen) -
Greece: Bilateral Social Security Agreement
(Ridgeway, Sen Aden) -
Environment: Plastic Shopping Bags
(Webber, Sen Ruth, Campbell, Sen Ian)
-
Veterans' Affairs: Home Care Program
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Environment: Mandatory Renewable Energy Target
(Harradine, Sen Brian, Campbell, Sen Ian) -
Sport: Drug Testing
(Ludwig, Sen Joe, Coonan, Sen Helen) -
International Criminal Court
(Greig, Sen Brian, Ellison, Sen Chris) -
Communications: Television Sports Broadcasts
(Conroy, Sen Stephen, Coonan, Sen Helen) -
Forestry: Management
(Lees, Sen Meg, Campbell, Sen Ian)
-
Environment: Mandatory Renewable Energy Target
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- NUCLEAR ENERGY: WASTE STORAGE
- COMMITTEES
-
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION BILL 2004
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION (CUSTOMS TARIFF) BILL 2004-
In Committee
- Harris, Sen Len
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Allison, Sen Lyn
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Lundy, Sen Kate
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Lundy, Sen Kate
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Lundy, Sen Kate
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Lundy, Sen Kate
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Lundy, Sen Kate
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Division
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Cherry, Sen John
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Cherry, Sen John
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Ridgeway, Sen Aden
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Conroy, Sen Stephen
- Harris, Sen Len
- Harris, Sen Len
- Hill, Sen Robert
- Harris, Sen Len
- Harris, Sen Len
-
In Committee
- COMMITTEES
-
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION BILL 2004
US FREE TRADE AGREEMENT IMPLEMENTATION (CUSTOMS TARIFF) BILL 2004 - BUSINESS
- ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 3) 2004
- ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 2) 2004
- URGENT LEGISLATION
-
ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 3) 2004
ANTI-TERRORISM BILL (NO. 2) 2004 - BUSINESS
-
MARRIAGE AMENDMENT BILL 2004
- First Reading
-
Second Reading
- Macdonald, Sen Ian
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Boswell, Sen Ron
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Barnett, Sen Guy
- Harradine, Sen Brian
- Collins, Sen Jacinta
- Cherry, Sen John
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Marshall, Sen Gavin
- Forshaw, Sen Michael
- Moore, Sen Claire
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Buckland, Sen Geoffrey
- Ferris, Sen Jeannie
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Division
- Procedural Text
-
In Committee
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Ludwig, Sen Joe
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Faulkner, Sen John
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Nettle, Sen Kerry
- Coonan, Sen Helen
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Division
- Procedural Text
- Third Reading
- ELECTORAL AND REFERENDUM AMENDMENT (PRISONER VOTING AND OTHER MEASURES) BILL 2004
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- ADJOURNMENT
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Health: Australian Longitudinal Study on Women's Health
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Campbell, Sen Ian) -
Health: Private Hospitals
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Campbell, Sen Ian) -
Science: Stem Cell Research
(Brown, Sen Bob, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Health: Chickenpox
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Patterson, Sen Kay) -
Medibank Private
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Ludwig, Sen Joe, Hill, Sen Robert)
-
Health: Australian Longitudinal Study on Women's Health
Page: 26497
Senator BOSWELL (Leader of The Nationals in the Senate) (1:32 PM)
—I was not going to get into this debate; I was going to save my comments for the substantive debate on the Marriage Amendment Bill 2004. But I am forced to come into this debate because I believe the 1,200 people who came from all parts of Australia, representing many other Australians who believe that marriage is the cornerstone of Australia, have been vilified. Senator Greig, you are quite open about your relationship, and I do not condemn you for it. That is your choice. As we pass in the corridors, I always say g'day to you. I do not condemn you for your choice of lifestyle, and you do not condemn me for being on the other side of the issue. We exchange pleasantries and say g'day to each other as we pass.
The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT
—Direct your remarks through the chair please, Senator Boswell.
Senator BOSWELL
—What I find difficult is when Senator Greig gets up here and vilifies these people in the same terms that he believes the gay and lesbian community have been vilified. He is turning the whole debate around. He vilified the 1,200 people who came from as far as Western Australia and Queensland, with three or four days notice, to express their concerns. Do they not have rights also? They have the right to come here and represent views, which I know are the views of the majority of Australians. They have every right to come here and express those views. If Senator Greig were going to address a gay and lesbian rights rally in Sydney tomorrow and if I suggested to him that all those people were anti-Christian, did not like churches and were against families, that would be wrong. But he is doing exactly what he accuses those 1,200 people of doing.
I know the passion that the Democrats have. I know how strongly they feel. I know they do not like being rolled. I was in exactly the same position during the native title debate. I thought it was absolutely wrong that native title be brought in and for there to be two titles over a property. I fought it hard. I did not believe in it. I was passionate about it but I did not have the numbers, and native title became a fact of life. I had to accept it. I made a speech on the third reading, if senators recall. I knew that we were done and I knew we had the numbers against us, but I did congratulate the Aboriginal people and the people who supported them in this place on a well-run campaign.
Senator Ridgeway
—You still didn't give us much.
Senator BOSWELL
—I say to Senator Ridgeway, the Aboriginal representative in this chamber, that I fought against it and I was rolled, but I congratulated the Aboriginal people on their campaign and the way they ran it. Democracy is numbers. The Democrats do not represent the majority of people. They have that narrow vote of around six or seven per cent. That is fair enough. They come in here and they represent them. But we represent the majority of people, and the overwhelming majority of people want marriage preserved between a man and a woman. Are we wrong to get up and defend the position of the majority? Of course we are not wrong.
We have been elected by people with different points of view. The people who elected me feel very strongly about this issue. Many of them are the people whom Senator Greig, I believe, has criticised and vilified. Look, in the excitement of giving speeches perhaps some of those things should not have been said. I do not know. As Senator Greig said, I sat near the front, although it was not to get my photo in the paper; it was to support those people because they turned up and made a huge contribution in coming here. It cost them a heap of money to get here, and they deserved support.
I sat in the second front row—not to get my photo in the paper, because I did not believe that would happen and, even if it did, that was not the reason I went there—to support those who back the majority of people. They came in here to express not an anti-gay or anti-lesbian position, or to vilify the gays and the lesbians, but to support marriage which they believe is the cornerstone of society.
Let us get on with the debate. I know how strongly you feel, Senator Greig. I can gauge that by the passion with which you are delivering your message. I shared that anxiety and passion in the native title debate. You might remember—I do not think you were here, Senator Greig—that I stood up and everyone in the gallery booed me. I was putting forward a position which I believed was the position of the people who elected me and which they asked me to support, and I agreed with their position. That is what representation is all about.
Unless you can get the majority of people to believe in gay and lesbian marriages, you are never going to override the parliament because the parliament is expressing the majority views. That is what it is all about. Everyone on this side of the parliament, and probably those on the other side, knows that. If Senator Greig were to go out there and express his view, he would be annihilated because it would not be the majority view of the people of Australia. You need only six or seven per cent of the vote to get elected, and then you pick up a bit of a spill here and cross-preference with the Greens and the Democrats and pick up a bit of the spill from Labor. You are not going for the majority vote; you are going for the minority vote. You always have and you always will. You do not represent the majority views of the two major parties.
The two major parties have to reflect what is required in the mainstream electorate. The mainstream electorate do not support marriage between same-sex couples. But that is not to say that they are vilified or that they are second-class citizens. That is their choice of life and, if that is their lifestyle, I do not condemn or condone it. It does not represent what I believe is a family. Let us not debate this any longer. Let us get on with the substantive debate and put our positions forward on what we believe and the people of Australia want us to vote for.