

- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICEQUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
10-02-2004
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
40
- Electorate
Australian Capital Territory
- Interjector
Faulkner, Sen John
PRESIDENT, The
- Page
19526
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Senator LUNDY
- Responder
Senator KEMP
- Speaker
- Stage
- Type
- Context
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2004-02-10/0029
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- REPRESENTATION OF VICTORIA
- COMMISSION TO ADMINISTER THE OATH OR AFFIRMATION OF ALLEGIANCE
- BUSINESS
- MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IDENTIFICATION AND AUTHENTICATION) BILL 2003
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICEQUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICEQUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator LUNDY, Senator KEMP) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator BARTLETT, Senator HILL) -
Iraq
(Senator FAULKNER, Senator HILL) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator MURPHY, Senator HILL) -
National Security: Terrorism
(Senator LUDWIG, Senator ELLISON) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator HEFFERNAN, Senator IAN MACDONALD) -
Foreign Affairs: Hong Kong
(Senator FAULKNER, Senator ELLISON) -
Social Welfare: Protection of Children
(Senator BARTLETT, Senator ELLISON)
-
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: ADDITIONAL ANSWERS
- AUSTRALIAN LABOR PARTY
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERSQUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE: TAKE NOTE OF ANSWERS
- SCIENCE: ASSISTED REPRODUCTIVE TECHNOLOGY
- CONDOLENCES
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- LEAVE OF ABSENCE
- COMMITTEES
- RECHERCHE BAY: LOGGING
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- ASSENT
- BUDGET
- COMMITTEES
-
AVIATION TRANSPORT SECURITY BILL 2003
AVIATION TRANSPORT SECURITY (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS AND TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS) BILL 2003
NATIONAL RESIDUE SURVEY CUSTOMS LEVY RATE CORRECTION (LAMB EXPORTS) BILL 2003
NATIONAL RESIDUE SURVEY EXCISE LEVY RATE CORRECTION (LAMB TRANSACTIONS) BILL 2003
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY IMPROVEMENT BILL 2003
BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY IMPROVEMENT (CONSEQUENTIAL AND TRANSITIONAL) BILL 2003
HEALTH LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (MEDICARE) BILL 2003 -
PRIMARY INDUSTRIES (EXCISE) LEVIES AMENDMENT (WINE GRAPES) BILL 2003
AGRICULTURE, FISHERIES AND FORESTRY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 2) 2003
SUPERANNUATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (CHOICE OF SUPERANNUATION FUNDS) BILL 2003 - BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (IDENTIFICATION AND AUTHENTICATION) BILL 2003
- FISHERIES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (COMPLIANCE AND DETERRENCE MEASURES AND OTHER MATTERS) BILL 2003 [2004]
- DOCUMENTS
- ADJOURNMENT
- DOCUMENTS
- PROCLAMATIONS
-
Questions on Notice
-
Australian Institute of Petroleum: Meeting with Minister
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Veterans
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Coonan) -
Gene Technology
(Senator Harris, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Tasmanian Regional Forest Agreement
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Immigration: Asylum Seekers
(Senator Brown, Senator Vanstone) -
Veterans' Affairs: Commemorative Medal
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Coonan) -
National Security Hotline
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
Aviation: Security Identity Cards
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
National Security Hotline
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
National Security Hotline
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
National Security Hotline
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
Western Australia: Regional Solutions Program
(Senator Nettle, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Immigration: Port Hedland Detention Centre
(Senator Brown, Senator Vanstone) -
Immigration: Migrant Intake
(Senator Brown, Senator Vanstone) -
Sustainable Regions Program
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Sustainable Regions Program
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Transport and Regional Services: Regional Solutions Program
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Trade: Snow Peas and Sugar Snap Peas Imports
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Veterans: Home Care Program
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Coonan) -
Regional Services: Rural Transaction Centre Program
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Regional Services: Rural Transaction Centre Program
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation: Staffing
(Senator Allison, Senator Vanstone) -
Education, Science and Training: Evaluation and Investigation Program
(Senator Carr, Senator Vanstone) -
Australian Federal Police and Customs: Explosive Material
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Ellison) -
Fisheries: Illegal Operators
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Fisheries: Illegal Operators
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Fisheries: Illegal Operators
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Fisheries: Heard and McDonald Islands
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Fisheries:
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Fisheries: Illegal Operators
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Trade: Live Animal Exports
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Health: Blood and Blood Products
(Senator Hutchins, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Attorney-General's: Legal Aid
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation: National Measurement Laboratory
(Senator Allison, Senator Vanstone) -
Immigration: Visas
(Senator Bartlett, Senator Vanstone) -
Communications, Information Technology and the Arts: Institute of Public Affairs
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Kemp) -
Dairy Regional Assistance Program: Eurobodalla Coast Gourmet Trail
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Dairy Regional Assistance Program: Alternative Industry Starter Kits
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Dairy Regional Assistance Program: Bega Cheese
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Dairy Regional Assistance Program: Bega Cheese
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Foreign Affairs: Indonesia
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Human Rights: China
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Indonesia: Mining
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Quarantine: Seed Cleaning Facilities
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Communications, Information Technology and the Arts: Paper and Paper Products
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Kemp) -
Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs: Paper and Paper Products
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Vanstone) -
Customs:
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Environment and Heritage: Air Transport System
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Environment and Heritage: Air Transport System
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Environment and Heritage: Air Transport System
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Environment: Water Management
(Senator Bartlett, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Environment: Forest Management
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Prime Minister and Cabinet: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Hill) -
Health and Ageing: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Environment and Heritage: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Finance and Administration: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Minchin) -
Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Industry, Tourism and Resources: Alternative Dispute Resolution
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Minchin) -
Nuclear Weapons: Cancer Incidence
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Trade: Free Trade Agreement
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Iraq
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Defence: Point Nepean
(Senator Allison, Senator Hill) -
Defence: Internet Site
(Senator Chris Evans, Senator Hill) -
Australian Defence Force: Service Medals
(Senator Marshall, Senator Hill) -
Firearms Safety Training
(Senator Marshall, Senator Ellison) -
Health: Complementary Healthcare Consultative Forum
(Senator Allison, Senator Ian Campbell) -
United States: Nuclear Treaties
(Senator Allison, Senator Hill) -
Australian Defence Force: Colour Perception Classification 3
(Senator Chris Evans, Senator Hill) -
Environment: Government Fleet Vehicles
(Senator Nettle, Senator Abetz) -
Customs: X-Ray Machines
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Ellison) -
Environment: Renewable Energy
(Senator Allison, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Health: Food Imports
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Agriculture: Dairy Assistance
(Senator Webber, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Health: Autism
(Senator Allison, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Environment: Ozone Protection
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Environment: Ozone Protection
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Environment: Ozone Protection
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Environment: Greenhouse Gas Abatement Grant
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Prime Minister: Overseas Accommodation
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Hill) -
Health: Donation
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Abetz) -
Medicare: Bulk-Billing
(Senator Marshall, Senator Ian Campbell) -
National Radioactive Waste Repository
(Senator Allison, Senator Minchin) -
Defence: Abrams Tanks
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Australia and New Zealand Food Regulation Ministerial Council
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Campbell) -
Visit of HRH Prince Harry
(Senator Ludwig, Senator Ellison) -
Indonesia: Pemaron Power Plant
(Senator Brown, Senator Hill) -
Royal Australian Navy:
(Senator Mark Bishop, Senator Hill) -
Defence: Air 9000 Project
(Senator Chris Evans, Senator Hill) -
Environment: Supervising Scientist
(Senator Allison, Senator Ian Macdonald) -
Health: Smoking Related Death and Disease
(Senator Allison, Senator Ian Campbell) -
New South Wales: South East Fibre Exports
(Senator Nettle, Senator Hill) -
Environment: Airconditioners
(Senator Brown, Senator Ian Macdonald)
-
Australian Institute of Petroleum: Meeting with Minister
Page: 19526
Senator LUNDY (2.23 p.m.)
—My question is to Senator Kemp, representing the Minister for Communications, Information Technology and the Arts. Is the minister aware that US trade ambassador Zoellick has stated:
... the FTA contains important and unprecedented provisions to improve market access for US films and television programs over a variety of media including cable, satellite, and the internet.
Can the minister also confirm that the Prime Minister stated yesterday:
In relation to new media there is a reservation which effectively allows the Australian government, after a proper objective process involving consultation with parties, to reserve a level of local content.
Can the minister give an absolute assurance that the Australian government has retained the power to regulate all future broadcasting and audiovisual services without the consent of the US government?
Senator KEMP
—Senator Lundy, we can all have a variety of quotes; people like to make them to promote a case. I must say that I have been intrigued with question time today and the obvious split which is now appearing in Labor Party ranks. I was intrigued to hear that Mr Beattie is a very strong supporter of the free trade agreement, and I was equally intrigued to hear from my colleague Senator Minchin that Mr Rann is also a very strong supporter of the free trade agreement. So I think the Labor Party already has problems in this area.
Senator Lundy, to respond to your question, let me quote Mr Kim Dalton. Mr Kim Dalton, as you know, is the CEO of the Australian Film Commission. This is what he said—it is not me; this is what he said:
The government has retained the capacity to regulate in all areas of the industry and should be congratulated.
That of course is the main game, as far as I am concerned. Senator Lundy was expecting that this government would not stand up for the interests of Australia. This government has a very proud record of standing up for the interests of Australia. Senator Lundy, as the government promised, we have fully preserved our cultural and public policy interests under the free trade agreement.
Senator Faulkner interjecting—
The PRESIDENT
—Order! Senator Faulkner, shouting across the chamber is disorderly.
Senator KEMP
—The point I think we should make is that Australian stories and Australian voices are still going to be heard on Australian screens and in the future. Senator Lundy, I have checked a press release that you put out in the last hour or so, and I regret to say that it is so full of errors that it will certainly have to be corrected. Your research is very poorly based.
I can confirm that the result under the free trade agreement for the audiovisual sector is a good one for the sector. It is a good result for Australia. It makes it very clear that the free trade agreement is in Australia's interests. As I have mentioned, the Labor Party are already splitting on this issue; there are Labor Party leaders who are very supportive of the free trade agreement.
Importantly, the agreement ensures that the government retains the power to regulate for Australian content in both existing and new forms of media, whether analog or digital. The outcome of the audiovisual negotiations also provides Australia with a capacity to apply current Australian content transmission quotas to more than one channel per provider in a multichannelling environment and to extend the 10 per cent—and this is an important development—expenditure requirement for pay TV to a broader range of channel formats and to potentially increase the expenditure requirements for pay TV drama services up to 20 per cent. This is a very good outcome for the free trade agreement. It is a good outcome for the audiovisual sector in Australia.
The scare tactics of Senator Lundy and her colleagues will not work. Senator Lundy, when you look closely at this agreement, you will see that what you predicted has not turned out. This government has been able to defend very strongly Australian interests. It is a very good outcome for Australia. It is a very good outcome for the audiovisual sector.
Senator LUNDY
—Mr President, I ask a supplementary question. I refer back to the original question. The minister did not answer whether they can provide an absolute assurance that the Australian government has retained power to regulate all future broadcasting and audiovisual services without the consent of the US government. Please answer that question. If it is all okay, as you describe, what are the unprecedented provisions to which Ambassador Zoellick refers? And what is different, if you say it is all okay?
Senator KEMP
—It is clear that Senator Lundy has not listened to the answer but let me make it clear that, if the Australian government determines that audiovisual content is not readily available to Australian consumers, the government can put in place measures to ensure that access to that programming is not unreasonably denied. That is a decision that the Australian government makes, as I have quoted to her. Senator Lundy's scare tactics are going to fail. They are not well based. To be quite frank, it is very important that Senator Lundy adopts a more positive approach to an excellent trade agreement for Australia.