

- Title
MIGRATION AMENDMENT (EXCISION FROM MIGRATION ZONE) BILL 2001
MIGRATION AMENDMENT (EXCISION FROM MIGRATION ZONE) (CONSEQUENTIAL PROVISIONS) BILL 2001
BORDER PROTECTION (VALIDATION AND ENFORCEMENT POWERS) BILL 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 6) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 5) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 1) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (JUDICIAL REVIEW) BILL 1998 [2001]
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
25-09-2001
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
39
- Electorate
Tasmania
- Interjector
CHAIRMAN, The
Schacht, Sen Chris
Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Page
27848
- Party
AG
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Brown, Sen Bob
- Stage
In Committee
- Type
- Context
Bills
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2001-09-25/0134
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Education: Government Policy
(Ferguson, Sen Alan, Ellison, Sen Chris) -
Coles Myer and Daimaru: Job Losses
(Cook, Sen Peter, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Australian Labor Party: Centenary House
(Ferris, Sen Jeannie, Abetz, Sen Eric) -
Australian Taxation Office: Refunds
(Murphy, Sen Shayne, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Community Organisations: Public Liability Insurance
(Cherry, Sen John, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Australian Taxation Office: Job Cuts
(Lundy, Sen Kate, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Afghanistan: Australian Commitment
(Brown, Sen Bob, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Goods and Services Tax: Ansett Tickets
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Economy: Innovation and Knowledge
(Coonan, Sen Helen, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Australian Defence Force: Surveillance Operation
(Faulkner, Sen John, Minchin, Sen Nick)
-
Education: Government Policy
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- COMMITTEES
- NOTICES
- BUSINESS
- AUSTRALIAN MUSLIM COMMUNITY
- PARLIAMENTARY ZONE
- EDUCATION
- COMMITTEES
- FORESTS: VICTORIA
- COMMITTEES
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- ASSENT TO LAWS
- COMMITTEES
- BUSINESS
- PARLIAMENTARY ZONE
-
MIGRATION AMENDMENT (EXCISION FROM MIGRATION ZONE) BILL 2001
MIGRATION AMENDMENT (EXCISION FROM MIGRATION ZONE) (CONSEQUENTIAL PROVISIONS) BILL 2001
BORDER PROTECTION (VALIDATION AND ENFORCEMENT POWERS) BILL 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 6) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 5) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 1) 2001
MIGRATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (JUDICIAL REVIEW) BILL 1998 [2001]- Second Reading
-
In Committee
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Harradine, Sen Brian
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Cooney, Sen Barney
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Stott Despoja, Sen Natasha
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Brown, Sen Bob
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Harradine, Sen Brian
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Greig, Sen Brian
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Harris, Sen Len
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Harris, Sen Len
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Harris, Sen Len
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Schacht, Sen Chris
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Harris, Sen Len
- Brown, Sen Bob
- McKiernan, Sen Jim
- Harris, Sen Len
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Brown, Sen Bob
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Ellison, Sen Chris
- Division
- Procedural Text
- ADJOURNMENT
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Civil Aviation Safety Authority: Audit
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Transport and Regional Services Portfolio: Missing Computer Equipment
(Faulkner, Sen John, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Exceptional Circumstances Program: Western Australian Farmers
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Exceptional Circumstances Program: Queensland Farmers
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Overseas Aid Gift Deduction Scheme: Tax Deductibility
(Bourne, Sen Vicki, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Arms Traffic Regulations: Australian Exemption
(Bourne, Sen Vicki, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Radioactive Oily Waste
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Minchin, Sen Nick)
-
Civil Aviation Safety Authority: Audit
Page: 27848
Senator BROWN (8:57 PM)
—It would. That is the problem, you see. If you are sitting on Bruny Island or King Island and looking at this piece of legislation, you recognise that mainland Tasmania is part of the state—so is King Island, so is Flinders Island, so is Bruny Island, Maria Island and so on. Mainland Tasmania is an island which makes up part of the state of Tasmania, which has quite a list of other islands which give you the completion of the whole state. This legislation says that `any island that forms part of a State or Territory' can be cut out. That includes mainland Tasmania.
I have not got to Senator Stott Despoja's observation that mainland Australia is an island. If you are looking at it from Hobart, mainland Australia is an island, and I am not sure that it is the most important island in the confederation. We Tasmanians tend to look at it as the `North Island'. In fact, if you come to Tasmania you will hear mainland Australia referred to quite frequently as the `North Island', because it is only part of the country. I am not going to take up that argument; I am here busy defending Tasmania. That is why there is an amendment coming up removing this anti-Tasmanian clause from the legislation. If that does not succeed, I will be moving another amendment. You have really got me going here.
Senator BROWN
—Exactly. What happens if they next come in with some sort of electoral bill that does the same as the migration legislation we have got here and starts excising bits of Australia according to that?
Senator Stott Despoja
—Or a racial discrimination bill.
Senator BROWN
—Anything at all. It is absurd. This is a very silly clause, a very silly piece of legislation done on the run. It needs to be changed. The Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs, Mr Ruddock, lamely said on radio the other day that if we came up with Tasmania for regulation in the future the regulation could be knocked out by either house of parliament. But—as I think I heard Senator Schacht, in quite unruly fashion, interject earlier with comment, very helpfully—the fact is that a regulation can be brought in. For example, under current circumstances we are not going to be sitting after Friday. You can bring in a regulation on Saturday and it will be sitting there until whenever parliament next meets. And then, if a house of parliament wants to change that regulation, it takes some time. The government will get its way for months on end if we allow this to stand. I hope that the Labor Party will defend the Labor state of Tasmania and the other islands that Senator Schacht has mentioned by supporting the amendment that I will be putting shortly, after we have dealt with the very good amendment that Senator Bartlett has moved.