

- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
04-04-2000
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
39
- Electorate
Queensland
- Interjector
- Page
13267
- Party
AD
- Presenter
- Status
Proof
- Question No.
- Questioner
Woodley, Sen John
- Responder
Herron, Sen John
- Speaker
- Stage
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
- Type
- Context
Questions Without Notice
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2000-04-04/0014
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Health: MRI Scans
(Evans, Sen Chris, Herron, Sen John) -
Trade: Exports
(Gibson, Sen Brian, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Bolkus, Sen Nick, Herron, Sen John) -
Telstra: Privatisation
(Brownhill, Sen David, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(McLucas, Sen Jan, Herron, Sen John) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Ridgeway, Sen Aden, Herron, Sen John) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Faulkner, Sen John, Herron, Sen John) -
Mandatory Sentencing Legislation
(Brown, Sen Bob, Herron, Sen John) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Herron, Sen John) -
Rural and Regional Australia: Services
(Ferguson, Sen Alan, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Evans, Sen Chris, Herron, Sen John) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Woodley, Sen John, Herron, Sen John) -
Aboriginals: Stolen Generation
(Faulkner, Sen John, Herron, Sen John) -
Welfare Reform: Interim Report
(Payne, Sen Marise, Newman, Sen Jocelyn)
-
Health: MRI Scans
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- NURSING HOMES: RIVERSIDE
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- NOTICES
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- CONSTITUTION ALTERATION (ELECTORS' INITIATIVE, FIXED TERM PARLIAMENTS AND QUALIFICATION OF MEMBERS) 2000
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- GENETIC PRIVACY
- ZIMBABWE
- EDUCATION: EXPORTS
- COMMITTEES
- MANDATORY SENTENCING LEGISLATION
- MATTERS OF URGENCY
- DOCUMENTS
- BUDGET 1999-2000
- ASSENT TO LAWS
- TRANSPORT AND TERRITORIES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1999
- BROADCASTING SERVICES AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 4) 1999
- COMMITTEES
- A NEW TAX SYSTEM (TAX ADMINISTRATION) BILL (NO. 1) 2000
- DOCUMENTS
- ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Treasurer: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Assistant Treasurer: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Minister for Financial Services and Regulation: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs: External Staff Development Courses
(Faulkner, Sen John, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Members of Parliament: Queen of Australia Photograph Requests
(Faulkner, Sen John, Ellison, Sen Chris) -
Garner MacLennan Group: Compact Disc
(Brown, Sen Bob, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Department of Transport and Regional Development: SES Officers
(Faulkner, Sen John, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Department of Veterans' Affairs: SES Officers
(Faulkner, Sen John, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Pay Telephones
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Alston, Sen Richard) -
Tasmania: World Heritage Area
(Brown, Sen Bob, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Department of the Environment and Heritage: Year 2000 Compliance
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Human Rights: China
(Bourne, Sen Vicki, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Reserve Bank of Australia: Interest Rates
(Cook, Sen Peter, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Department of the Treasury: Gavin Anderson and Kortlang
(Ray, Sen Robert, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Australian Federal Police: Staff
(Murray, Sen Andrew, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Australian Electoral Commission: Enrolments
(Faulkner, Sen John, Ellison, Sen Chris)
-
Treasurer: Departmental Liaison Officers
Page: 13267
Senator WOODLEY (2:52 PM)
—My question is addressed to the Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs, Senator Herron. I draw the minister's attention to media reports today, including the Courier-Mail editorial and Donald Horne on Radio National. Is the minister aware of historian Donald Horne's comment on Radio National this morning that the Prime Minister is the instigator of the statement that there is no stolen generation? Can you tell the Senate the exact nature of the involvement of the Prime Minister or his personal staff in the preparation of your submission?
Senator HERRON (Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs)
—The statement was prepared by the Office of Indigenous Policy, which referred it to me. I altered it in a few respects, perhaps a little in phraseology. It was sent to Minister Ruddock's office—I think he was overseas at the time. They ticked it off, it went back to the Prime Minister's office, and he ticked it off. I think he was busy at the time. I am not sure whether he actually physically saw it, because he was otherwise engaged with the Queen's visit and a lot of other things. That is the process that it went through, and then I signed off on the final submission, having read it again, and put it into the Senate legal and constitutional affairs committee. I understand—the chairman may correct me—that it was released last Thursday, but I am not absolutely certain about that. I was told by my counterpart in the other chamber, who had a copy when we were on a radio program. He is nodding his head. That was released by the Senate legal and constitutional affairs committee on Thursday last week.
Senator WOODLEY
—Further to the answer of the minister: Minister, was this policy part of a poll-driven strategy to shore up votes for the coalition in marginal regional seats in the lead-up to the next election, as many people in the media have claimed?
Senator HERRON (Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Affairs)
—I have seen that statement too. I absolutely refute that categorically. The government's position has not changed in three years. What I put in that submission is exactly the position that we have maintained. But I have never criticised the HREOC report, as you would be aware, because I do not believe it was my place to. That was a submission put forward by Sir Ronald Wilson on behalf of his committee. He interviewed 535 people with oral and written submissions and then the legal services did other collections—I think thousands of submissions. I have never been critical of that. But there has never been an opportunity to put the facts on the table; there just hasn't. I did not wish to debate that. The legal and constitutional affairs committee, with its instruction, gave us the opportunity to put the facts on the table, and I think people should judge them for themselves. That is why I say that I think everybody should get hold of that submission. All the historical matters, as best as we could get them, are in that document. (Time expired)