

- Title
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Eastern Europe: Cyanide Spill
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
17-02-2000
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
39
- Electorate
Queensland
- Interjector
DEPUTY PRESIDENT,The
- Page
12015
- Party
AD
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Bartlett, Sen Andrew
- Stage
Eastern Europe: Cyanide Spill
- Type
- Context
Questions Without Notice
- System Id
chamber/hansards/2000-02-17/0124
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- NOTICES
- BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- NOTICES
- COMMITTEES
- INTERNATIONAL CLIMATE CHANGE NEGOTIATIONS
- COMMITTEES
-
GLADSTONE POWER STATION AGREEMENT (REPEAL) BILL 1999
TELECOMMUNICATIONS (CONSUMER PROTECTION AND SERVICE STANDARDS) AMENDMENT BILL 1999 - CORPORATIONS LAW: ACCOUNTING STANDARD AASB1015
- COMMITTEES
- MINISTERS OF STATE AND OTHER LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1999
- EXPORT FINANCE AND INSURANCE CORPORATION AMENDMENT BILL 1999
- CRIMINAL CODE AMENDMENT (APPLICATION) BILL 1999
-
CUSTOMS AMENDMENT BILL (NO. 2) 1999
IMPORT PROCESSING CHARGES AMENDMENT BILL 1999 - CRIMES AT SEA BILL 1999
- ADELAIDE AIRPORT CURFEW BILL 1999
- CRIMES AT SEA BILL 1999
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Tax Reform: Public Opinion Research
(Campbell, Sen George, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Rural and Regional Australia: Government Policy
(Watson, Sen John, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Rural and Regional Australia: Veterans' Services
(Schacht, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Environment: Queensland Land Clearing
(McGauran, Sen Julian, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Goods and Services Tax: Wheat Producers Loans
(West, Sen Sue, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Private Health Insurance: Rebate
(Lees, Sen Meg, Herron, Sen John) -
Defence: Funding
(Hogg, Sen John, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Ministerial Responsibility
(Harris, Sen Len, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Goods and Services Tax: Reform
(Forshaw, Sen Michael, Kemp, Sen Rod) -
Tax Reform: Public Education
(Mason, Sen Brett, Ellison, Sen Chris) -
Shoalwater Bay: Sandmining
(Bolkus, Sen Nick, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Eastern Europe: Cyanide Spill
(Bartlett, Sen Andrew, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Health: MRI Scans
(Evans, Sen Chris, Herron, Sen John) -
Tax Reform: Car Industry
(Chapman, Sen Grant, Minchin, Sen Nick)
-
Tax Reform: Public Opinion Research
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- ADJOURNMENT
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Minister for Regional Services, Territories and Local Government: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Minister for Education, Training and Youth Affairs: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Ellison, Sen Chris) -
Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Industry, Science and Resources: Departmental Liaison Officers
(Ray, Sen Robert, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Attorney-General's Department: Internal Staff Development Courses
(Faulkner, Sen John, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Attorney-General's Department: External Staff Development Courses
(Faulkner, Sen John, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Freedom of Information Requests: Members of Parliament
(Faulkner, Sen John, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Medicare: Theatre Fees
(Abetz, Sen Eric, Herron, Sen John) -
Department of Transport and Regional Services: Cost of Legal Advice from Attorney-General's Department
(Faulkner, Sen John, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Department of Industry, Science and Resources: Cost of Legal Advice from Attorney-General's Department
(Faulkner, Sen John, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Department of Veterans' Affairs: Salaries
(Faulkner, Sen John, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Child Care in Australia: Report
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Department of Family and Community Services: Child-Care Database
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Department of Family and Community Services: Children's Services Statistical Report
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Department of Family and Community Services: Child Care in Australia Report
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Child Care in Australia Report: School Age Care
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Child Care in Australia Report: Outside School and Vacation Care
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Department of Family and Community Services: Exclusion of Statistical Data
(Evans, Sen Chris, Newman, Sen Jocelyn) -
Australian Maritime Safety Authority: Search
(O'Brien, Sen Kerry, Macdonald, Sen Ian) -
Proposed Silicon Smelter, Lithgow, New South Wales
(Brown, Sen Bob, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Tibet: Immigrants and Refugees
(Brown, Sen Bob, Vanstone, Sen Amanda) -
Tasmania: Native Vegetation
(Brown, Sen Bob, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Export Incentive Development Grants: Private Education and Training Providers
(Carr, Sen Kim, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Offshore Petroleum Exploration
(Brown, Sen Bob, Minchin, Sen Nick) -
Eritrean-Ethiopian War
(Brown, Sen Bob, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Ranger Wetlands Filtration System
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Hill, Sen Robert) -
Radioactive Smoke Alarms
(Allison, Sen Lyn, Minchin, Sen Nick)
-
Minister for Regional Services, Territories and Local Government: Departmental Liaison Officers
Page: 12015
Senator BARTLETT (3:32 PM)
—I move:
That the Senate take note of the answer given by the Minister for the Environment and Heritage (Senator Hill) to a question without notice asked by me today, relating to the cyanide spill in Romania.
The spill of cyanide into rivers in Hungary and Europe more widely is something that has attracted quite a deal of media attention in Australia and, obviously, in Europe as well in recent times. Anybody who doubts that we are now in a shrinking globe need only notice the worldwide attention being focused on Australia because of this incident. I am sure that most senators have been getting emails from people in Hungary complaining about the environmental damage that has been caused and asking us, as representatives of the Australian parliament, what we are going to do about it. So clearly this is something that is in the minds of some citizens in Hungary for them to be going to the trouble of emailing members of parliament in Australia asking them to act, assist and ensure that this sort of thing does not happen again. In question time today, as also occurred on Tuesday, we have been asking the government what sort of concrete action it will take to regulate the activities of Australian mining companies overseas. The company involved in this particular incident has, of course, denied that the cyanide spill is responsible for the environmental damage and is querying the extent of the damage.
I welcome the minister's commitment on Tuesday to table a report—or to publish or publicise a report—detailing the full situation once all the facts have come to light. I think that would be in the company's interest, obviously, if things are as they say. It would certainly be in Australia's interest, regardless of whether or not the company is correct in saying that they are not really to blame. It is clearly in Australia's interest to get the full facts about this situation. That does not change the fact that there have been other instances of Australian mining companies operating in a way that has been environmentally damaging. The minister's answer today, which was basically talking about encouraging voluntary compliance with codes of practice and encouraging companies to operate in an effective way and in a way that is not environmentally damaging, is all very nice and cooperative. There is nothing wrong with trying to work cooperatively, but the fact remains that there will always be companies that will not comply with voluntary codes and that will go outside those codes. Those companies can not only cause environmental damage, damage to people's livelihoods and great financial costs to communities overseas but also damage Australia's reputation. So to fall back and rely on nice cooperative voluntary codes is clearly just a `hope for the best approach' which, in the view of the Democrats, is not satisfactory in adequately protecting Australia's reputation. The Democrats believe that clearly there is a situation where our national interest is at stake. Clearly Australia is identified throughout Europe as having some connection to this particular problem. We need to learn the lessons from this otherwise we may well be faced with a similar situation in the future.
It is also worth noting, I think, the minister's response to my question in relation to funding by the Export Finance Insurance Corporation, which provides assistance to companies that may be looking at operating overseas, including mining companies. As far as I am aware—and I should clarify this for the record—that was not the case with this particular mine in Romania. But the minister again said that it is a bit unreasonable to put in place specific requirements that companies be required to meet environmental standards before they get funding from EFIC. I think it is quite a sensible approach to ensure that we do not go providing taxpayers' money to companies unless we can be sure that they are going to operate in a way that is environmentally responsible and that also meets human rights standards. I would urge the government to take account of that approach and of the widespread concerns not just of the people of Hungary who have been emailing us but also of the people of Australia, including investors and business people, who recognise the damage that such incidents can do to Australia's reputation and to those that seek to invest overseas. This generates not just valuable projects in those countries but also valuable revenue for Australia. (Time expired)
The DEPUTY PRESIDENT
—Order! The time for the debate has expired.
Question resolved in the affirmative.