

- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Nursing Homes
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
10-11-1997
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
38
- Electorate
NSW
- Interjector
- Page
8575
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Senator FORSHAW
- Responder
Senator HERRON
- Speaker
- Stage
- Type
- Context
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1997-11-10/0053
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- REPRESENTATION OF QUEENSLAND
- COMMITTEES
- BUDGET 1997-98
- EXCISE TARIFF AMENDMENT BILL (No. 1) 1997
- CHARTER OF BUDGET HONESTY BILL 1996
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Nursing Homes
(Senator FAULKNER, Senator HILL) -
Economy
(Senator COONAN, Senator HILL) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator LUNDY, Senator HERRON) -
Aboriginal Reconciliation
(Senator FERRIS, Senator HERRON) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator CHRIS EVANS, Senator HERRON) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator LEES, Senator HERRON) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator COOK, Senator HERRON) -
Drugs
(Senator FERGUSON, Senator VANSTONE) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator CROWLEY, Senator HERRON) -
Romania: Adoption Agreement
(Senator HARRADINE, Senator HILL) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator ROBERT RAY, Senator HERRON) -
Trade: Europe
(Senator MURRAY, Senator HILL) -
Aboriginal Reconciliation
(Senator BOLKUS, Senator HERRON) -
Drugs
(Senator EGGLESTON, Senator ELLISON) -
Nursing Homes
(Senator FORSHAW, Senator HERRON) -
Recreational Fishing
(Senator O'CHEE, Senator PARER)
-
Nursing Homes
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- PETITIONS
-
NOTICES OF MOTION
- Special Broadcasting Service
- Mr Yitzhak Rabin
- Tasmania: Regional Forest Agreement
- Community Affairs References Committee
- Consideration of Legislation
- Logging and Woodchipping
- Drugs
- Human Rights: East Timor
- University of New South Wales
- Nigeria: Ogoni People
- Education: Funding
- Education: Funding
- Human Rights: East Timor
- Victoria: Soil Contamination
- Victoria: Intellectually Disabled Students
- LEAVE OF ABSENCE
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
-
ORDER OF BUSINESS
- National Competition Policy Committee
- Child Care
- Travel Allowances
- Ministers and Ministerial Staff
- Landmines
- Classification (Publications, Films and Computer Games) Regulations (Amendment)
- Oakajee Port and Industrial Estate
- Tasmanian Wilderness World Heritage Area
- Australian Capital Territory: Government
- CONSIDERATION OF LEGISLATION
- COMMITTEES
- MATTERS OF URGENCY
- DOCUMENTS
- BUDGET 1997-98
- IMPORTATION OF COOKED CHICKEN MEAT
-
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS TAX (MEMBERS OF CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED SUPERANNUATION FUNDS) ASSESSMENT AND COLLECTION BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS TAX (MEMBERS OF CONSTITUTIONALLY PROTECTED SUPERANNUATION FUNDS) IMPOSITION BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS AND TERMINATION PAYMENTS TAXES LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS TAX IMPOSITION AMENDMENT BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS TAX) BILL 1997
TERMINATION PAYMENTS TAX IMPOSITION AMENDMENT BILL 1997 - BUDGET 1997-98
- NATIVE TITLE AMENDMENT BILL 1997
- SOCIAL SECURITY LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (YOUTH ALLOWANCE) BILL 1997
- ASSENT TO LAWS
-
DEFENCE SERVICE HOMES AMENDMENT BILL 1997
TAXATION LAWS AMENDMENT BILL (No. 5) 1997 -
PARLIAMENTARY SERVICE BILL 1997
PARLIAMENTARY SERVICE (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 1997 - BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- COMMITTEES
- CONSIDERATION OF LEGISLATION
- CHARTER OF BUDGET HONESTY BILL 1996
- COMMITTEES
-
PUBLIC SERVICE BILL 1997
PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT (CONSEQUENTIAL AND TRANSITIONAL) AMENDMENT BILL 1997 - CONSIDERATION OF LEGISLATION
- WHEAT MARKETING AMENDMENT BILL 1997
-
CHILD CARE PAYMENTS BILL 1997
CHILD CARE PAYMENTS (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS AND TRANSITIONAL PROVISIONS) BILL 1997 - ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
- PROCLAMATIONS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Multilateral Agreement on Investment
(Senator Margetts, Senator Kemp) -
Taxation
(Senator Allison, Senator Kemp) -
Department of Immigration and Multicultural Affairs: Media Monitoring Services
(Senator Robert Ray, Senator Vanstone) -
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Commission: Media Monitoring Services
(Senator Robert Ray, Senator Herron) -
Earl Hill Project
(Senator Woodley, Senator Kemp) -
Sales Tax
(Senator Brown, Senator Kemp) -
Government Contracts
(Senator Robert Ray, Senator Kemp) -
International Passenger Statistics
(Senator O'Brien, Senator Kemp) -
Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet: Public Relations Contracts
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Hill) -
Contracts for Public Relations Services
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Hill) -
Government Contracts
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Newman) -
Contracts for Public Relations Services
(Senator Faulkner, Senator Hill) -
Disappearance of Aircraft VH-AQL
(Senator Brown, Senator Alston) -
Kakadu National Park World Heritage Area
(Senator Lees, Senator Parer) -
National Plantations Strategy Co-ordinator
(Senator Brown, Senator Parer) -
Parliamentary Travel: Jetset
(Senator Brown, Senator Minchin) -
Mental Health
(Senator Allison, Senator Herron) -
Papua New Guinea: Defence Partnership
(Senator Margetts, Senator Newman) -
Mental Health
(Senator Lees, Senator Herron) -
Department of Defence: Research
(Senator Robert Ray, Senator Newman) -
Department of Health and Family Services: Research
(Senator Robert Ray, Senator Herron) - Procedural Text
-
Multilateral Agreement on Investment
Page: 8575
Senator FORSHAW
—My question is addressed to the Minister representing the Minister for Family Services. If $4,000 is the average annual nursing home capital fee that must be paid, can the minister explain what options will be available for elderly Australians whose only asset is their home and who are unable to find tenants and are also unable to obtain a reverse mortgage?
Senator HERRON
—I thank Senator Forshaw for the question. Based on preliminary information, the average payment would
be of the order of $4,000, with providers in low cost regions charging somewhat less and providers in high cost regions charging somewhat more. Senator Forshaw will be aware that the government will be retaining the arrangement for exempting an estimated 27 per cent of people entering residential care from making capital payments because of hardship or financial disadvantage. As before, the government will continue to pay up to an extra $12 a day to the provider on their behalf.
Having answered Senator Forshaw's question in that context, I should add that the detail will be worked out and that they are arrangements that have been voluntarily entered into between the people going into nursing homes, their relatives and the providers of nursing home care. The detail will be available after it has been determined in consultation with the respective groups.
Senator FORSHAW
—It is obvious, Minister, that you really do not have much of an idea. The question that I asked related to people who are obliged to pay the $4,000 fee. It did not relate to people who are not obliged to. It concerned those who are obliged to pay it but are not in the position to either obtain tenants or a reverse mortgage. If you are going to get back to me on that, at least that will be somewhat helpful. But I also ask you this, Minister: can you—will you—give a categorical guarantee that no nursing home resident will be evicted for failure to pay the annual fee? If you can give that commitment, Minister, can you also explain how that will work in situations where people cannot, as I said earlier, pay the $4,000?
Senator HERRON
—Madam President, There are hardship provisions. Nobody will be forced, if they have hardship, to pay anything. The reality is that the principle stays. The principle is that those people who can afford to pay should pay. Currently, the taxpayer pays 70 per cent of the cost of nursing home care for 130,000 residents. It is also a fact that the government is approaching it constructively because, over the next 20 years, the number of people over age 65 will grow 2½ times as fast as the general population. The number of people over age 80 will grow
nearly three times as fast. So we are taking a constructive approach to it. We are not doing what the previous Labor government did, which was to ignore it. We have to approach it. It is a problem faced by all of us. The alternative is to increase taxation. (Time expired)