

- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
Tax Avoidance: Trusts
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
24-09-1997
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
38
- Electorate
WA
- Interjector
- Page
6863
- Party
AD
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Senator MURRAY
- Responder
Senator HILL
- Speaker
- Stage
- Type
- Context
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1997-09-24/0098
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- TELECOMMUNICATIONS (INTERCEPTION) AND LISTENING DEVICE AMENDMENT BILL 1997
- LEGISLATIVE INSTRUMENTS BILL 1996
- TELECOMMUNICATIONS (INTERCEPTION) AND LISTENING DEVICE AMENDMENT BILL 1997
-
LEGISLATIVE INSTRUMENTS BILL 1996
- In Committee
- MATTERS OF PUBLIC INTEREST
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
- DEPUTY OPPOSITION WHIP
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Minister for Social Security
(Senator SHERRY, Senator NEWMAN) -
Superannuation: Public Servants
(Senator GIBSON, Senator KEMP) -
Superannuation
(Senator MURPHY, Senator NEWMAN) -
Cassini Space Probe
(Senator STOTT DESPOJA, Senator ELLISON) -
Superannuation: Public Servants
(Senator SHERRY, Senator KEMP) -
Roxby Downs
(Senator MARGETTS, Senator HILL) -
Taxation: Savings Rebate
(Senator GEORGE CAMPBELL, Senator KEMP) -
Natural Heritage Trust
(Senator CALVERT, Senator HILL) -
Tax Avoidance: Trusts
(Senator JACINTA COLLINS, Senator KEMP) -
Tax Avoidance: Trusts
(Senator MURRAY, Senator HILL) -
Currency Trading
(Senator DENMAN, Senator KEMP)
-
Minister for Social Security
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- PETITIONS
- DOCUMENTS
- NOTICES OF MOTION
-
ORDER OF BUSINESS
- Community Affairs References Committee
- ACIL Economics
- Australian Pensioners and Superannuants Federation
- Environment, Recreation, Communications and the Arts References Committee
- National Children's Commission
- Environment, Recreation, Communications and the Arts References Committee
- Child Care
- Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee
-
North-West Cape
Anti-personnel Mines
Nuclear Fuel - Finance and Public Administration References Committee
- COMMITTEES
- BUDGET 1997-98
- COMMITTEES
- WORKPLACE RELATIONS AND OTHER LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1997
-
LEGISLATIVE INSTRUMENTS BILL 1996
-
In Committee
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator O'CHEE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator O'CHEE
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator O'CHEE
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS, Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator BOLKUS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
-
In Committee
- COMMITTEES
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- DOCUMENTS
- ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Industry Development Centre Hunter
(Senator Tierney, Senator Ellison) -
Privacy
(Senator Stott Despoja, Senator Ellison) -
Department of Health and Family Services: Programs
(Senator Woodley, Senator Ellison) -
Test Case Litigation Program
(Senator Sherry, Senator Kemp) -
Australia Post
(Senator Allison, Senator Alston) -
Northern Territory: 1800 Phone Numbers
(Senator Brown, Senator Alston) -
HMAS
(Senator Margetts)
-
Industry Development Centre Hunter
Page: 6863
Senator MURRAY
—My question is to the Minister representing the Prime Minister, and I wish to follow the line of questioning from Senator Collins. My question is about trusts, and I preface it by declaring a personal interest as a member of a trust, and this is declared in the pecuniary interests register. Minister, I refer to media reports of yesterday's joint party meeting and ask: why has the Prime Minister interfered in the tax office's review of trusts—a review actively promoted by his own Treasurer—by assuring coalition MPs that small business trusts will be protected for tax planning purposes? Isn't the tax commissioner now under extreme pressure to narrow the ATO review to conform with the PM's remarks, if he expects government support for legislative changes? Is the government still concerned that income being funnelled through tax minimising trusts is rising at more than twice the rate of the PAYE system and is now over $116 billion a year? (Time expired)
Senator HILL
—If the Prime Minister said, as was reported yesterday, that the government would not be doing anything that would bankrupt small business, then I can quite understand that, because we are actually on the side of small business. Not surprisingly,
a review of taxation would take that into account.
We actually believe that small business is the key to job creation in this country. That is why we have put so much emphasis on policies that have enabled interest rates to come down five times since we got into government, on policies that keep inflation low and on the reform of the industrial relations system, to give greater flexibility to benefit small employers in their employment. And that is why we are looking in part at taxation reform as well—in order to support small business.
I regret that you seem to have misunderstood the outcomes of yesterday's discussions—or what was reported—because I can assure you that any adoption of taxation reform will be consistent with our wanting small business to grow and prosper.
Senator MURRAY
—Madam President, I ask a supplementary question. Minister, given your statement, if I can rephrase it, that your party is totally committed to pursuing trusts, will the Prime Minister ensure that the tax commissioner and the Treasurer are able to pursue trusts which are being used for tax avoidance or undue tax minimisation? Will you give that assurance to the Senate?
Senator HILL
—Nothing has changed from the announcement in the budget that a discussion paper on the taxation of trusts will be released. Obviously, there are issues relating to taxation of trusts. I agree with what Senator Murray said: the expansion of trusts has been considerable. And there are, particularly in relation to large business, questions of equity relating to that. That will be taken into account. So it has not been affected at all. But I reiterate that this government is firmly on the side of small business, and taxation reform, to which we are committed, will actually be designed to support small business growth, particularly in order that we might expand employment.