

- Title
HINDMARSH ISLAND BRIDGE BILL 1996
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
26-03-1997
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
38
- Electorate
VIC
- Interjector
COLLINS
PATTERSON
- Page
2580
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Senator COONEY
- Stage
- Type
- Context
Bill
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1997-03-26/0297
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- THERAPEUTIC GOODS AMENDMENT BILL 1997
- DAYS AND HOURS OF MEETING
-
COMMONWEALTH SERVICES DELIVERY AGENCY BILL 1996
COMMONWEALTH SERVICES DELIVERY AGENCY (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 1997-
In Committee
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator O'BRIEN, Senator NEWMAN
- Senator BROWN
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator BROWN
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator HARRADINE, The CHAIRMAN
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator BROWN
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator FAULKNER
- Senator NEWMAN
- Senator WOODLEY
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator BROWN
- Senator HARRADINE
- Third Reading
-
In Committee
-
AVIATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL (No. 1) 1997
- Second Reading
-
In Committee
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator CAMPBELL
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Senator MARGETTS
- Third Reading
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
-
EXPORT MARKET DEVELOPMENT GRANTS BILL 1997
EXPORT MARKET DEVELOPMENT GRANTS (REPEAL AND CONSEQUENTIAL PROVISIONS) BILL 1997-
Second Reading
- Senator COOK
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator COOK
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator COOK
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator COOK
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator COOK
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator COOK
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator COOK, Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator COOK
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator COOK
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator COOK
- Senator COOK
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Senator COOK
- Senator BROWNHILL
- Senator MURRAY
- Third Reading
-
Second Reading
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- HINDMARSH ISLAND BRIDGE BILL 1996
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Austudy
(Senator DENMAN, Senator VANSTONE) -
Small Business
(Senator TIERNEY, Senator HILL) -
Unemployment
(Senator FOREMAN, Senator VANSTONE) -
Higher Education
(Senator KNOWLES, Senator VANSTONE) -
Senator Colston
(Senator FAULKNER, The PRESIDENT) -
Student Assistance
(Senator STOTT DESPOJA, Senator VANSTONE) -
Mining: North Stradbroke Island
(Senator CHILDS, Senator PARER) -
Small Business
(Senator MARGETTS, Senator HILL)
-
Austudy
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
- QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- REMOVAL OF SENATOR FROM PARLIAMENTARY RETIRING ALLOWANCES TRUST
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES OF MOTION
- COMMITTEES
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- PRIME MINISTER'S VISIT TO CHINA
- COMMITTEES
- SENATE: PHOTOGRAPHS
- SENATOR COLSTON
- EAST GIPPSLAND FORESTS
- COMMITTEES
- TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE: SENATORS
- TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE: SENATORS
- TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE: SENATORS
- TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE: SENATORS
- TRAVELLING ALLOWANCE: SENATORS
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- COMMITTEES
- DOCUMENTS
- COMMITTEES
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
-
EDUCATION LEGISLATION AMENDMENT BILL 1997
SOCIAL SECURITY AND VETERANS' AFFAIRS LEGISLATION AMENDMENT (MALE TOTAL AVERAGE WEEKLY EARNINGS BENCHMARK) BILL 1997 - AGED CARE INCOME TESTING BILL 1997
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
-
TELECOMMUNICATIONS (CARRIER LICENCE CHARGES) BILL 1996
TELECOMMUNICATIONS (NUMBERING CHARGES) BILL 1996
TELECOMMUNICATIONS (NUMBERING FEES) AMENDMENT BILL 1996 - COMMITTEES
- WORKPLACE RELATIONS REGULATIONS
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- HINDMARSH ISLAND BRIDGE BILL 1996
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
-
PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE INCENTIVES BILL 1996
MEDICARE LEVY AMENDMENT BILL (No. 2) 1996
TAXATION LAWS AMENDMENT (PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE INCENTIVES) BILL 1996-
Consideration of House of Representatives Message
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator LEES
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator NEAL
- Senator NEAL
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Adoption of Report
- Third Reading
-
Consideration of House of Representatives Message
- DAYS AND HOURS OF MEETING
- COMMITTEES
- TAX LAW IMPROVEMENT BILL 1996
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
-
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS SURCHARGE (ASSESSMENT AND COLLECTION) BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS SURCHARGE IMPOSITION BILL 1997
TERMINATION PAYMENTS SURCHARGE (ASSESSMENT AND COLLECTION) BILL 1997
TERMINATION PAYMENTS SURCHARGE IMPOSITION BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS SURCHARGE (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS SURCHARGE (APPLICATION TO THE COMMONWEALTH) BILL 1997
SUPERANNUATION CONTRIBUTIONS SURCHARGE (APPLICATION TO THE COMMONWEALTH—REDUCTION OF BENEFITS) BILL 1997 - ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
- QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
Page: 2580
Senator COONEY(8.01 p.m.)
—There is just one matter that was raised by the minister which I would like to comment on. He spoke about the cost of the legal proceedings that had occurred over the Hindmarsh Island Bridge. I know that he did not intend it in this context, but I would hate the impression to be created that there was a cost on fairness and a cost on justice. Some people talk about affordable safety. Some people talk about affordable justice, and I think that is a wrong concept. It is one of the core functions of government—talking about government in terms of the three arms of government, and in that sense it is one of the core functions of government—to see justice done and to see it done to everybody no matter what their race, creed, colour, size or age. I think it sends out the wrong message when it is put that `we have got to pass this act because to go through the judicial processes would be too much'.
Beliefs, as Senator Collins says, are matters of great importance. He spoke about his belief, and it just occurred to me that he spoke about Jesus turning water into wine at Cana. He said that, although he did not believe that occurred, nevertheless it was a symbol of his general beliefs in this area. I must confess that I have a greater belief in the miracle of Cana than he has. I remember hearing a master of ceremonies in modern days testing some wine prior to a wedding feast. When he sipped an offered brand of wine, he screwed up his face and said, `If the Lord came down from Heaven, he would change this back into water.'
Senator Bob Collins
—All 360 gallons of it!
Senator COONEY
—I think it is the 360 gallons, rather than the transformation, that has you in doubt, Senator Collins, but perhaps they drank well in those days. But that is the point I would like to make.
Senator Bob Collins
—Sounds like a wedding in the Northern Territory to me.
Senator COONEY
—May I say, Senator Collins, that I do not think that anyone has represented the territory as well as you have this week—or over the years for that matter.
Senator Patterson
—What about Grant Tambling?
Senator COONEY
—And Grant Tambling, of course. In any event, the point I want to make, and then I will sit down, is the fact that the legal process has been truncated. I know that it has caused a great deal of distress to the Chapmans, but the process of law is important. I am sure that it is not being brought in on this basis, but if this bill was brought in on the basis that this is the only way in which we can cut costs and that this is really a cost cutting exercise, I think that would certainly send out a wrong message about how we should conduct the affairs of this society. The way the affairs of this society should be conducted is through the proper legal processes. Sure they go wrong, just as the parliament goes wrong and just as government goes wrong from time to time, but that underlying principle is important. I think it is a matter that was well described and touched on by Senator Margetts.