

- Title
ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER COMMISSION AMENDMENT BILL 1996
In Committee
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
26-06-1996
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
38
- Electorate
NT
- Interjector
The TEMPORARY CHAIRMAN (Senator Calvert)
COONEY
- Page
2288
- Party
ALP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
- Responder
- Speaker
Senator BOB COLLINS
- Stage
- Type
- Context
Bill
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1996-06-26/0229
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- PETITIONS
-
NOTICES OF MOTION
- Consideration of Legislation
- Regulations and Ordinances Committee
- Introduction of Legislation
- Australian Drug Evaluation Committee
- Administration of Drugs to Women in Prison
- Introduction of Legislation
- Introduction of Legislation
- Introduction of Legislation
- Mr P.J. Keating: Piggery
- Employment, Education and Training References Committee
- Economy: Privatisation
- Women
- Days and Hours of Meeting
- Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee
- Rural and Regional Affairs and Transport References Committee
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- NATIONAL COMMISSION OF AUDIT
- ABORIGINAL LEGAL SERVICES
- COMMITTEES
- DAYS AND HOURS OF MEETING
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
-
HEALTH AND OTHER SERVICES (COMPENSATION) AMENDMENT BILL 1996
ABORIGINAL LAND RIGHTS (NORTHERN TERRITORY) AMENDMENT BILL 1996 - COMMITTEES
- STRIP SEARCHES IN PRISONS
- COMMONWEALTH ELECTORAL AMENDMENT (16 AND 17 YEAR OLD VOLUNTARY ENROLMENT) BILL 1996
- VIETNAMESE ASYLUM SEEKERS
- EMPLOYMENT, EDUCATION AND TRAINING AMENDMENT BILL 1996
- COMMITTEES
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- COMMITTEES
- ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER COMMISSION AMENDMENT BILL 1996
- MATTERS OF PUBLIC INTEREST
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Social Security: Pensions
(Senator FAULKNER, Senator NEWMAN) -
Macquarie, Heard and McDonald Islands
(Senator McGAURAN, Senator HILL) -
Social Security
(Senator CHRIS EVANS, Senator NEWMAN) -
Aboriginal Legal Services
(Senator ELLISON, Senator HERRON) -
Project Investment
(Senator COOK, Senator SHORT) -
Labour Downsizing
(Senator KERNOT, Senator VANSTONE) -
Commonwealth Bank of Australia: Share Offer
(Senator JONES, Senator SHORT) -
Uranium Mining
(Senator MARGETTS, Senator HILL) -
National Commission of Audit
(Senator WHEELWRIGHT, Senator SHORT) -
Poverty
(Senator CHAPMAN, Senator NEWMAN) -
Telstra
(Senator KNOWLES, Senator ALSTON) -
Aboriginal Affairs: Special Auditor
(Senator COLSTON, Senator HERRON) -
Burma
(Senator BOURNE, Senator HILL) -
Aboriginal Affairs: Special Auditor
(Senator BOB COLLINS, Senator HERRON)
-
Social Security: Pensions
-
MEDICARE LEVY AMENDMENT BILL 1996
INCOME TAX ASSESSMENT AMENDMENT BILL 1996 - QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- REPORT OF PRESIDENT'S VISIT TO ZAMBIA AND SOUTH AFRICA
- NOTIFICATION OF SENATORS' INTERESTS
- COMMITTEES
-
ABORIGINAL AND TORRES STRAIT ISLANDER COMMISSION AMENDMENT BILL 1996
-
In Committee
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator HERRON
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator HERRON
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator KERNOT
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator PANIZZA
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator HERRON
- Senator COONEY
- Senator CHAMARETTE
- Senator HERRON
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator BOB COLLINS
- Senator COONEY
- Senator HERRON
- Third Reading
-
In Committee
-
CUSTOMS AMENDMENT BILL 1996
CUSTOMS TARIFF AMENDMENT BILL (No. 1) 1996 - NOTICES OF MOTION
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- ASSENT TO LAWS
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- DOCUMENTS
-
CUSTOMS AMENDMENT BILL 1996
CUSTOMS TARIFF AMENDMENT BILL (No. 1) 1996 - ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- DOCUMENTS
- QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
Page: 2288
Senator BOB COLLINS(5.53 p.m.)
—I want to explain to the minister why I am interested in pursuing this matter. I make no bones about it; it is fundamentally for my continuing education and that of all other legislators. We are now confronted with this interesting new term `units' rather than `dollars'. I have been advised, by those who know, that one unit is $100.
Senator Panizza quite correctly made a reference to the sentencing guidelines that judges take into account. What Senator Kernot said astonished me. I am puzzled why we need to have units instead of dollars. This is a serious matter and it will be interesting to see what advice we get. If the reason for having units instead of dollars is so that courts will have some discretion to convert the units into prison sentences as well as money, then I am going to run a campaign that is as good as yours, Senator Chamarette, to get this pernicious business of units taken out of legislation and to have dollars put back in.
That is for a reason, in terms of what I think is a very important relationship between parliaments and courts. I always understood that an important sentencing guideline, as well as the one Senator Panizza mentioned, was that judges are supposed to have some regard to what the legislators—in their wisdom or stupidity from time to time and who are elected by the people—think is a reasonable punishment or a reasonable provision in a piece of legislation. If the parliament in its wisdom or stupidity believes that a non-custodial sentence is appropriate and, indeed, by inference, that a custodial sentence is not appropriate—and I am prepared to be educated; that is why I find this a very interesting point; I have puzzled over this new term `unit', but not enough to lose sleep over it—if that means that judges can at their discretion send people to gaol—
Senator Cooney
—It doesn't mean that.
Senator BOB COLLINS
—It doesn't? You worried me, Senator Chamarette; that is what I am saying. I am about to be reassured, apparently. With the explanation that the minister will now give, you will probably support us, Senator Chamarette.