Save Search
    Prev   Next   Return to results listPrint ListEmail Document Link

Title

DISSENT FROM RULING

Division

Database

House Hansard

Date

19-09-2007

Source

House of Reps

Parl No.

41

Electorate

 

Interjector

 

Main Committee/Federation Chamber

 

Page

78

Party

 

Presenter

 

Status

Final

Question No.

 

Questioner

 

Responder

 

Speaker

 

Stage

 

Type

 

Context

Dissent from Ruling

System Id

chamber/hansardr/2007-09-19/0067


Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
 Download Current HansardDownload Current Hansard    View Or Save XMLView/Save XML

Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Wednesday, 19 September 2007
Page: 78
[3:22 PM]

The House divided.    

(The Speaker—Hon. David Hawker)

DIVISION:NOES 84 (31 majority) AYES 53 PAIRS 0
AYESNOESPAIRS
Adams, D.G.H.Albanese, A.N.
Bevis, A.R.Bird, S.
Bowen, C.Burke, A.E.
Burke, A.S.Byrne, A.M.
Corcoran, A.K.Crean, S.F.
Danby, M. *Edwards, G.J.
Elliot, J.Ellis, A.L.
Ellis, K.Emerson, C.A.
Ferguson, L.D.T.Ferguson, M.J.
Fitzgibbon, J.A.Garrett, P.
Georganas, S.George, J.
Gibbons, S.W.Gillard, J.E.
Grierson, S.J.Griffin, A.P.
Hall, J.G. *Hatton, M.J.
Hayes, C.P.Irwin, J.
Jenkins, H.A.Kerr, D.J.C.
King, C.F.Lawrence, C.M.
Livermore, K.F.Macklin, J.L.
McClelland, R.B.McMullan, R.F.
Melham, D.Murphy, J.P.
O’Connor, G.M.Plibersek, T.
Price, L.R.S.Roxon, N.L.
Rudd, K.M.Sawford, R.W.
Sercombe, R.C.G.Smith, S.F.
Snowdon, W.E.Swan, W.M.
Thomson, K.J.Vamvakinou, M.
Wilkie, K.
Abbott, A.J.Anderson, J.D.
Andrews, K.J.Bailey, F.E.
Baird, B.G.Baker, M.
Baldwin, R.C.Barresi, P.A.
Bartlett, K.J.Billson, B.F.
Bishop, B.K.Bishop, J.I.
Broadbent, R.Brough, M.T.
Cadman, A.G.Causley, I.R.
Ciobo, S.M.Cobb, J.K.
Costello, P.H.Downer, A.J.G.
Draper, P.Dutton, P.C.
Elson, K.S.Entsch, W.G.
Farmer, P.F.Fawcett, D.
Ferguson, M.D.Forrest, J.A.
Gambaro, T.Georgiou, P.
Haase, B.W.Hardgrave, G.D.
Hartsuyker, L.Henry, S.
Hockey, J.B.Howard, J.W.
Hull, K.E. *Hunt, G.A.
Jensen, D.Jull, D.F.
Keenan, M.Kelly, D.M.
Kelly, J.M.Laming, A.
Ley, S.P.Lindsay, P.J.
Lloyd, J.E.Macfarlane, I.E.
Markus, L.May, M.A.
McArthur, S. *McGauran, P.J.
Mirabella, S.Moylan, J.E.
Nairn, G.R.Nelson, B.J.
Neville, P.C.Pearce, C.J.
Prosser, G.D.Pyne, C.
Randall, D.J.Richardson, K.
Robb, A.Ruddock, P.M.
Schultz, A.Scott, B.C.
Secker, P.D.Slipper, P.N.
Smith, A.D.H.Somlyay, A.M.
Southcott, A.J.Stone, S.N.
Thompson, C.P.Ticehurst, K.V.
Tollner, D.W.Truss, W.E.
Tuckey, C.W.Turnbull, M.
Vaile, M.A.J.Vale, D.S.
Vasta, R.Wakelin, B.H.
Washer, M.J.Wood, J.

  * Denotes tellers

Question negatived.