Mr McMULLAN (3:27 PM) —My question is to the Minister for Employment Services. Minister on what basis did you assert on Sky TV news yesterday that donations to the Liberal Party from Mr Marc Ratcliffe of Workplace Education and Development, from the proceeds of previous training courses promoted by you, were `disclosed through the normal Electoral Commission processes'? If they were disclosed, why is there no record of any such donations to the Liberal Party, either from Mr Ratcliffe or his company, Workplace Education and Development, in either the donor returns to the Australian Electoral Commission or the Liberal Party returns?

Mr BROUGH (Minister for Employment Services) —Clearly the donation that was provided was below that required to have an individual's name named.