

Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Goods and Services Tax: Petrol Prices
(Crean, Simon, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Small Business Confidence
(Thompson, Cameron, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Small Business Confidence
(Crean, Simon, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Small Business
(Gallus, Christine, MP, Costello, Peter, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Petrol Prices
(Ferguson, Martin, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Immigration: Woomera Centre
(Wakelin, Barry, MP, Ruddock, Philip, MP) -
Olympic Games: Hospitality Boxes and Tickets
(Andren, Peter, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
East Timor: Australian Assistance
(Nehl, Garry, MP, Downer, Alexander, MP) -
Research and Development: Business Expenditure
(Beazley, Kim, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Industrial Relations: Disputes
(Billson, Bruce, MP, Reith, Peter, MP) -
Education: Funding for Non-government Schools
(Lee, Michael, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Private Health Insurance: Lifetime Health Cover
(St Clair, Stuart, MP, Wooldridge, Dr Michael, MP) -
Education: Fundraising
(Lee, Michael, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Aviation: Virgin Airlines
(Baird, Bruce, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Education: Funding for Catholic Schools
(Lee, Michael, MP, Kemp, Dr David, MP) -
Native Title: Alternative Policies
(Haase, Barry, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Education: Funding for Non-government Schools
(Lee, Michael, MP, Kemp, Dr David, MP)
-
Goods and Services Tax: Petrol Prices
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
-
QUESTIONS TO MR SPEAKER
-
Questions on Notice
(McFarlane, Jann, MP, SPEAKER, Mr) -
Questions on Notice
(Theophanous, Dr Andrew, MP, SPEAKER, Mr) -
Questions on Notice
(Murphy, John, MP, SPEAKER, Mr) -
Parliamentary Library
(Albanese, Anthony, MP, SPEAKER, Mr) -
Questions on Notice
(Danby, Michael, MP, SPEAKER, Mr) -
Press Gallery: Eviction
(Edwards, Graham, MP, SPEAKER, Mr)
-
Questions on Notice
- AUDITOR-GENERAL'S REPORTS
- PAPERS
- MATTERS OF PUBLIC IMPORTANCE
- MAIN COMMITTEE
- MATTERS REFERRED TO MAIN COMMITTEE
- COMMITTEES
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE SENATE
-
GENE TECHNOLOGY BILL 2000
GENE TECHNOLOGY (LICENCE CHARGES) BILL 2000
GENE TECHNOLOGY (CONSEQUENTIAL AMENDMENTS) BILL 2000
GENE TECHNOLOGY (LICENCE CHARGES) BILL 2000 - ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
- NOTICES
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Privacy Amendment (Private Sector) Legislation
(McClelland, Robert, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Department of Industry, Science and Resources: Commonwealth Funded Programs, Tasmania
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
Attorney-General's Department: Commonwealth Funded Programs, Tasmania
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Family Court: Judge Relocation
(McClelland, Robert, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Privy Council: Judicial Committee
(Melham, Daryl, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Second Sydney Airport: Economic Benefits
(Crosio, Janice, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Second Sydney Airport: Sydney's Gateways In The 21st Century Report
(Price, Roger, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Migration: Social Security Agreements
(Sciacca, Con, MP, Ruddock, Philip, MP) -
Stronger Families and Communities Strategy: Funding
(Ellis, Annette, MP, Anthony, Larry, MP) -
Explosive Ordnance Storage, Wallangarra: Review
(Ferguson, Laurie, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
HMAS Sydney Inquiry: Implementation of Recommendations
(Smith, Stephen, MP, Truss, Warren, MP) -
Patrick Stevedores: Meetings
(Bevis, Arch, MP, Reith, Peter, MP)
-
Privacy Amendment (Private Sector) Legislation
Page: 19515
Mr LEE (3:10 PM)
—My question is again to the Prime Minister. Does the Prime Minister recall saying in his speech last Friday while opening a new facility at Melbourne Grammar that `Every last dollar of this wonderful facility was contributed by the parent body and the supporters of the school, the whole $4 or $5 million of it'? Prime Minister, how many government schools or low fee Catholic or independent schools have the ability to raise $5 million from their parents or old boys?
Government members interjecting—
Mr SPEAKER
—Order! The member for Dobell is entitled to ask his question provided it is within the standing orders, and to ask it in silence.
Mr LEE
—Prime Minister, do you really think it is fair that under your new funding system you do not even consider the private fundraising of the very wealthy schools? How does giving an average $800,000 a year to the 62 wealthiest schools in Australia help working-class parents send their kids to school?
Mr HOWARD (Prime Minister)
—I do remember saying that and it is the case that the facility that I opened at that particular school, which has produced some students on both sides of Australian politics—
Mr Costello
—John Brumby.
Mr Downer
—Malcolm Fraser.
Mr HOWARD
—I won't get into personalities—
Mr Tanner
—You'll have to, because you have got no argument.
Mr HOWARD
—The member for Melbourne interjects about no argument. The member for Dobell asks if I take account of the fundraising capacities of different schools. The answer is yes, and that is why schools in category 1 get on average about 17 per cent per capita funding and schools in the Catholic systems get about 70 per cent. This shows the absolute ignorance of the Labor Party's education spokesman about the fundamentals of education funding in this country. The whole fundamental in education funding in this country is that the main per capita recurrent support from the Commonwealth operates on the basis that the poorest schools get the most funding and the not so poor schools get less funding. That is why the school in category 1 or 2 gets about 17 per cent, the sorts of schools that the member for Dobell was yelling his head off about get about 17 per cent, schools like Melbourne Grammar, and the Catholic systemic schools get 70 per cent. That is how it has been for a long time, and I think that is very fair.
That is the system that I thought the Australian Labor Party supported. But what you cannot grasp is that there is another category of schools. The other category of schools is those low fee independent schools, and you voted to stop them expanding. When the bill came before the parliament to abolish the new schools policy that you maintained, you all voted to maintain the old system. The old system would have prevented the establishment of Anglican systemic schools in the western suburbs of Sydney charging fees of $2,000, $3,000 or $4,000 a year. These are the schools that John Aquilina is now wanting to run the ruler over in New South Wales because he has been sooled onto them by the teacher unions in that particular state. That is what you are trying to stop, and no attempt to drag Melbourne Grammar into it is going to alter that reality.