

Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- COMMITTEES
- TRADE PRACTICES AMENDMENT (UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT—SAVING OF STATE AND TERRITORY LAWS) BILL 2000
-
STATEMENTS BY MEMBERS
- Ferrall, Sir Raymond
- Macquarie Electorate: Mountains Community Transport
- Blacktown City Council: 21st Anniversary
-
Ballarat Electorate: World Environment Day Awards
Ballarat Electorate: Australian Catholic University - Charlton Electorate: Cowan Mine Survival Unit
- Petrie Electorate: Italian National Day
- Fowler Electorate: Bankstown Airport
- Local Government: Armidale-Dumaresq Council Election
- Immigration: Three-Year Visas
- East Timor: Australian Troops
- McEwen Electorate: Mount Buller
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Solomon Islands: Police Funding Assistance
(Brereton, Laurie, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
World Environment Day
(Hull, Kay, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Solomon Islands: Political Crisis
(Kerr, Duncan, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
Economy: Employment Growth
(Charles, Bob, MP, Costello, Peter, MP) -
Prime Minister: South Pacific Forum
(Beazley, Kim, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
New Tax System: Alternative Policies
(Washer, Dr Mal, MP, Costello, Peter, MP) -
Age Pension: Decrease
(Beazley, Kim, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Industrial Relations: Pattern Bargaining
(Secker, Patrick, MP, Reith, Peter, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Pensions
(Swan, Wayne, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Education: Funding
(Bailey, Fran, MP, Kemp, Dr David, MP) -
Consumer Price Index: Pensions
(Quick, Harry, MP, Howard, John, MP) -
Work for the Dole: Outcomes
(Vale, Danna, MP, Abbott, Tony, MP) -
Minister for Finance and Administration: Official Duties
(McLeay, Leo, MP, Fahey, John, MP) -
Health: Life Expectancy of Australians
(Moylan, Judi, MP, Wooldridge, Dr Michael, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Education
(Lee, Michael, MP, Kemp, Dr David, MP) -
Industrial Relations: Employee Entitlements
(Somlyay, Alex, MP, Reith, Peter, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Education
(Lee, Michael, MP, Kemp, Dr David, MP) -
Sugar Industry: North Queensland
(Katter, Bob, MP, Truss, Warren, MP) -
Goods and Services Tax: Australian Business Number
(McClelland, Robert, MP, Reith, Peter, MP) -
Frequent Flyer Schemes: Complaints
(Macfarlane, Ian, MP, Hockey, Joe, MP)
-
Solomon Islands: Police Funding Assistance
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
PETITIONS
- Goods and Services Tax: Education
- CSIRO: Clayton Site
- Kirkpatrick, Private Jack Simpson
- Banking Services
- Sexual Discrimination
- Kalejs, Konrad
- Vietnam Veterans': Mobidity Study
- Goods and Services Tax: Receipts and Dockets
- Environment: Forest Conservation
- Heavily Indebted Poor Countries Initiative
- Mantatory Sentencing Legislation
- Goods and Services Tax: Therapeutic goods
- Genetically Modified Food: Labelling
- Procedural Text
- PRIVATE MEMBERS BUSINESS
- TRADE PRACTICES AMENDMENT (UNCONSCIONABLE CONDUCT—SAVING OF STATE AND TERRITORY LAWS) BILL 2000
- PRIVATE MEMBERS BUSINESS
- GRIEVANCE DEBATE
-
BROADCASTING SERVICES AMENDMENT (DIGITAL TELEVISION AND DATACASTING) BILL 2000
DATACASTING CHARGE (IMPOSITION) AMENDMENT BILL 2000 - PRIVATE MEMBERS BUSINESS
-
BROADCASTING SERVICES AMENDMENT (DIGITAL TELEVISION AND DATACASTING) BILL 2000
DATACASTING CHARGE (IMPOSITION) AMENDMENT BILL 2000 - ADJOURNMENT
- Adjournment
-
QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
-
Family Court of Australia: Unrepresented Litigants
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, Williams, Daryl, MP) -
Minister for Defence: Meetings with United States Defence Force Personnel
(Danby, Michael, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
Voting: Electronic Democracy Article
(Latham, Mark, MP, Fahey, John, MP) -
Veterans: Gold Card Eligibility
(McFarlane, Jann, MP, Scott, Bruce, MP) -
Federation Funds: Murray River Bridges
(Ferguson, Martin, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Jenkins, Mr Mervyn: Suicide Investigation
(Price, Roger, MP, Moore, John, MP) -
Voyage Permits
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Australian Defence Force: Puckapunyal Medical Centre
(Ferguson, Laurie, MP, Scott, Bruce, MP) -
Islamic Republic of Iran
(Danby, Michael, MP, Downer, Alexander, MP) -
Australian Defence Force: Smoking Policy
(Macklin, Jenny, MP, Scott, Bruce, MP) -
Marine Council: Meeting
(Bevis, Arch, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Rail: Very High Speed Train
(Ferguson, Martin, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Rail: Very High Speed Train
(Ferguson, Martin, MP, Anderson, John, MP) -
Minister for the Environment and Heritage: Domestic Violence Legislation Administration
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, Truss, Warren, MP) -
Minister for Communications, Information Technology and the Arts: Domestic Violence Legislation Administration
(O'Byrne, Michelle, MP, McGauran, Peter, MP) -
Australia House, London: Public Access
(McFarlane, Jann, MP, Downer, Alexander, MP) -
Illegal Immigration: Detention Costs
(McFarlane, Jann, MP, Ruddock, Philip, MP) -
Employment National: Job Network Contracts
(Tanner, Lindsay, MP, Abbott, Tony, MP)
-
Family Court of Australia: Unrepresented Litigants
Page: 17006
Mr EDWARDS (4:54 PM)
—I recently had a very disturbing letter from a veteran advocate in Perth. It reads thus:
Dear Mr Edwards,
I write this letter to register my disgust and also to inform you of the bureaucratic nonsense that currently prevails when a Veteran suffers a psychotic breakdown. I will document the chain of events below, which I was involved in.
On Sunday the 9th of April 2000 I received a phone call at approximately 1600hrs from a neighbour of Ken Freeman, a Veteran, who I had been dealing with and assisting in submitting a claim for Post Traumatic Stress Disorder to Veterans Affairs. The neighbour told me that Ken had informed him that he was about to commit suicide and was in a very poor state of mind and appeared to have completely broken down.
I inquired of the neighbour if he was prepared to keep Ken safe whilst I arranged his admittance to the Hollywood Clinic which at that point I thought was put in place to deal with such emergencies. I then rang the Hollywood Clinic and spoke with the duty staff and informed them of what had transpired and also informed them that Ken had been attending Dr Oleh Kaye, Psychiatrist, and was in possession of a report that had been sent to the Veterans Affairs Department in support of his claim for Post Traumatic Stress. I then requested that I deliver Ken to the Clinic for immediate treatment given his state of mind. I was advised by the duty staff that they could not admit Ken even though there was adequate bedspace, because they needed a referral from a Psychiatrist before the admittance could take place. I then informed the staff that Dr Oleh Kaye could not be contacted and could they suggest an alternative with a view to having Ken admitted to the Clinic for treatment as soon as possible. I was then informed to take him to either Royal Perth Hospital or Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital to see the resident Psychiatrist for a referral.
I arrived at the emergency department of Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital at 1722hrs the same day. Ken was seen in the emergency department by the Medical Doctor on duty who I advised what was required of him, to have Ken transferred to the Hollywood Clinic for immediate treatment. He then advised us that the resident Psychiatrist would see Ken in due course. At approximately 0130hrs on 10th April 2000, some eight hours later, Ken was finally seen to by the resident Psychiatrist.
I must inform you, those eight hours I spent with Ken without any help from any medical professional in the waiting room of the Sir Charles Gairdner Emergency Department were somewhat upsetting to say the least. Ken was admitted to hospital at approximately 0200hrs on the 10th April 2000 and I was informed by the resident Psychiatrist that Ken would be transferred to the Hollywood Clinic later that morning. I then left the hospital at approximately 0215hrs, 10th April 2000.
At approximately 0830hrs on the 10th April 2000, I received a phone call from the Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital resident Psychiatrist informing me that despite his referral, the Clinic would still not accept Ken, as approval to admit him had not been received from the Department of Veterans Affairs, and could I sort it out. I then rang the Veterans Affairs Department to ascertain why Ken was not being transferred to the Clinic. I was advised that until he could furnish proof that he was in fact a Veteran, transfer could not take place. I point out, for your information, that his Veterans Affairs file number was WSM 8465. I then arranged for proof of this to be faxed to the Veterans Affairs Department at approximately 1000hrs 10th April 2000. Ken was finally admitted to the Hollywood Clinic some eighteen hours after the start of what I considered a life threatening emergency.
The reason I write this letter Mr Edwards, is that Ken Freeman, an ex member of the Special Air Service Regiment died on the 12th April 2000, two days after being admitted to the clinic. I feel that an argument could be mounted that the bureaucratic lunacy that surrounded Ken, and given his fragile condition even I, a non-medical professional, could see he was in, could have contributed to his eventual death two days later.
What I ask Mr Edwards, is that Ken's death not go unnoticed and that other Veterans do not have to continue to endure these continual bureaucratic bunglings that ruin lives; you help to address this would be appreciated.
Having received this letter, I had discussions with the writer, Mr Eric Giblett, a JP, and also with Mr Freeman's widow. They feel very strongly that they do not want Ken Freeman's life to pass without something being done. I have put a series of questions to the Minister for Veterans' Affairs, and I hope that he will call an urgent review of the admittance procedures. I do not want to apportion blame or point the finger at any person in particular, but there was obviously something very wrong with the system. If that something is still very wrong with the system, then it must be addressed as a matter of urgency. Like Mrs Freeman and her two children, I do not want Ken's death to pass without the matter being addressed. To do so, in their own words, `would be a waste of his life'.
I also want to take the opportunity to compliment Eric Giblett. Eric is a dedicated advocate and voluntary worker. It is on those like him—for it is often on their shoulders—that falls the heavy burden of support for fellow veterans. These two men were close friends. I can imagine that those eight hours that Eric Giblett spent with Ken Freeman would have been difficult hours. I do not know what the answer is, because our system relies so much on volunteer help. I think the volunteer help in this particular circumstance went a long way. I think we need to recognise, too, the volunteer help that veterans give other veterans in every state, in every ex-service organisation and in every group that is set up to assist fellow veterans. I am sure that the Minister for Veterans' Affairs, who is sitting at the table, would be most concerned about this circumstance. I earnestly ask him if he could, with the resources of his department, to ascertain what the procedural problem was and, if there is a problem, to have it fixed up.
I did not want to delay bringing this letter to the attention of the House much longer, but I would have liked to have known the cause of death. There has been a coronial inquiry, but at this stage there has been no public announcement of the results. Once again, I ask the minister to address the questions and this issue. I am sure that he will be prepared to do that.