- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
War Crimes Trials
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
14-12-1993
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
37
- Electorate
SA
- Interjector
Senator Crichton-Browne
The PRESIDENT
- Page
4496
- Party
LP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Senator MINCHIN
- Responder
Senator BOLKUS
- Speaker
- Stage
- Type
- Context
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1993-12-14/0026
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
- DISTINGUISHED VISITORS
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
Health System
(Senator HILL, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Exportation of Fragmentation Grenades
(Senator CHILDS, Senator ROBERT RAY) -
Health System
(Senator HERRON, Senator RICHARDSON) -
CSL Ltd
(Senator WEST, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Daishowa Paper Manufacturing Co.
(Senator COULTER, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Rice
(Senator JONES, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Health System
(Senator ALSTON, Senator RICHARDSON) -
Department of the Arts and Administrative Services
(Senator DEVEREUX, Senator McMULLAN) -
High Court of Australia
(Senator KEMP, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Forests
(Senator CHAMARETTE, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Extradition of Dr Wayne Bradshaw
(Senator CHRIS EVANS, Senator BOLKUS) -
Charities
(Senator PATTERSON, Senator CROWLEY) -
Disabled Persons
(Senator LEES, Senator BOLKUS) -
Defence Force: Resignation of Pilots
(Senator MacGIBBON, Senator FAULKNER) -
Vandalism of War Cemeteries and Memorials
(Senator McKIERNAN, Senator FAULKNER) -
Extradition of Dr Wayne Bradshaw
(Senator CRICHTON-BROWNE, Senator BOLKUS) -
Malaysia
(Senator SANDY MACDONALD, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Sunscreens
(Senator REYNOLDS, Senator CROWLEY) -
High Court of Australia
(Senator ELLISON, Senator GARETH EVANS) -
Trade with China
(Senator MURPHY, Senator SCHACHT) -
War Crimes Trials
(Senator MINCHIN, Senator BOLKUS) -
Superannuation
(Senator BEAHAN, Senator McMULLAN) -
Norfolk Island
(Senator CALVERT, Senator RICHARDSON)
-
Health System
- QUESTION TIME
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS ON NOTICE
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- PETITIONS
- NOTICES OF MOTION
- LEAVE OF ABSENCE
-
DOCUMENTS
- Australian Defence Industries Ltd
- Australian Security Intelligence Organisation
- Textiles, Clothing and Footwear Development Authority
- National Board of Employment, Education and Training
- Australian Land Transport Development Program
- National Capital Planning Authority
- Auditor General's Reports
- Auditor-General's Reports
- COMMITTEES
- AUSTRALIAN PARLIAMENTARY DELEGATION TO VIETNAM, LAOS AND CAMBODIA
- COMMITTEES
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
- ETHNIC COMMUNITIES
- COMMITTEES
- BILLS RETURNED FROM THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
- DEVELOPMENT ALLOWANCE AUTHORITY AMENDMENT BILL 1993
- COMMITTEES
-
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS REFORM BILL 1993
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT (JUDGES' REMUNERATION) BILL 1993-
In Committee
- Senator CRANE
- Senator CHAPMAN
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator BELL
- Senator PARER
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator PARER
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator PARER
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CHAPMAN
- Senator KEMP
- Senator SHERRY
- Senator CRANE
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator BELL
- Senator CRANE
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator PARER
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator CRANE
- Senator CHAPMAN
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator McMULLAN
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator HARRADINE
- Senator ELLISON
- Senator KEMP
- Senator BELL
- Senator IAN MACDONALD
- Senator HARRADINE
-
In Committee
- ORDER OF BUSINESS
-
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS REFORM BILL 1993
INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COURT (JUDGES' REMUNERATION) BILL 1993 - NATIVE TITLE BILL 1993
- ADDITIONAL RESPONSES TO QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
- ADJOURNMENT
- PERSONAL EXPLANATIONS
- DOCUMENTS
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
-
Veterans' Affairs: Training Courses
(Senator Knowles, Senator Faulkner) -
Defence Force: Health Staff
(Senator Newman, Senator Robert Ray) -
Defence: Camera Sets
(Senator Calvert, Senator Robert Ray) -
Defence: Hat and Coat Stands
(Senator Calvert, Senator Robert Ray) -
ATSIC: Travel
(Senator Panizza, Senator Collins)
-
Veterans' Affairs: Training Courses
Page: 4496
Senator MINCHIN
—My question is directed to the Minister representing the Attorney-General. I refer the minister to the withdrawal of charges in the most recent war crimes trial in Adelaide, which is now the third trial in South Australia to have been abandoned or dismissed. Can the minister confirm that the total cost to the taxpayers of these three war crimes trials was $27.5 million? Is that amount consistent with the amount budgeted for these trials? What further expenditure is expected to be incurred? Can the minister indicate whether there will be any further prosecutions of South Australians for European war crimes?
Senator BOLKUS
—I do have some information in respect of the costs of the investigations and prosecutions. I am informed that a special investigations unit was established in May 1987 to investigate alleged war criminals. It ceased to operate on 30 June 1992. The funding of its operations over that almost five-year period totalled some $11,497,575. After its closure, some of its key personnel formed the war crimes prosecution support unit. That unit's costs from its establishment on 1 July 1992 to 30 June 1993 were $2,223,275.60. The costs of this financial year's operations are not yet known.
A team of investigators, including the director of the unit, was in the Ukraine collecting evidence when the Director of Public Prosecutions entered a nolle prosequi in the Wagner prosecution. The involvement of the office of the Director of Public Prosecutions commenced in the 1989-90 financial year and the costs of that office to the present time are $6,749,860. The best available figure for legal aid costs for the same period is some $4 1/2 million. The total costs at present, I am informed, are approximately $29 million.
I should add that, because of the mode of operation of the special investigations unit and the defence, where the same legal team represented all three defendants, it has not been possible to provide separate costings for each defendant in the prosecution under the War Crimes Act. But it can be said that the total expenditure on each defendant by the office of the DPP has been: Polyukhovich, $3.6 million; Berezowski, $1.16 million; and Wagner, close to $2 million. If there is any further information that Senator Minchin has asked for that I have not given, I will undertake to present it to him.
Senator Crichton-Browne
—Mr President, I raise a point of order. I ask that Senator Bolkus table the document from which he just read—or is he hiding behind the cowardice of not having the courage?
The PRESIDENT
—Whether or not the minister tables the document is a matter for him.

