Note: Where available, the PDF/Word icon below is provided to view the complete and fully formatted document
Previous Fragment    Next Fragment
Ch12 Senate amendments and requests / PROCEDURE FOLLOWING SENATE CONSIDERATION / Reasons



Download WordDownload Word

House of Representatives                                Ch 12                                                 p 434

 

Senate amendments and requests / PROCEDURE FOLLOWING SENATE CONSIDERATION

 

Reasons

When the House disagrees to a Senate amendment to a bill, a Member (usually the relevant Minister) must move the motion ‘That the amendment(s) be disagreed to’ and present to the House written reasons for the House not agreeing to the amendments. 1

The requirement for reasons also applies in the case of Senate bills if the House disagrees to any amendments made by the Senate to amendments of the House. 2 In practice reasons are not given when a Senate amendment is disagreed to in cases where the House then makes a substitute amendment. There is no requirement for reasons when Senate requests for amendment are not agreed to.

After presenting the reasons, copies of which are circulated, the Minister moves that they be adopted by the House. An amendment cannot be moved to the reasons, as the question before the Chair is that the reasons be adopted, 3 but an amendment has been moved to that question. 4 The reasons are included with the message returning the bill to the Senate.

The former practice of appointing a committee to draw up reasons was discontinued in 1998. 5



S.O. 161(c).



S.O. 170(b).



H.R. Deb. (8.12.83) 3557-8.



VP 1913/204.



VP 1996-98/3170.