- Title
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
INVALID PENSIONS: INSTITUTIONALISED HANDICAPPED PEOPLE
- Database
Senate Hansard
- Date
24-02-1981
- Source
Senate
- Parl No.
32
- Electorate
VIC
- Interjector
- Page
7
- Party
LP
- Presenter
- Status
Final
- Question No.
- Questioner
Senator MISSEN
- Responder
Senator CHANEY
- Speaker
- Stage
- Type
- Context
- System Id
chamber/hansards/1981-02-24/0032
Previous Fragment Next Fragment
-
Hansard
- Start of Business
- RESIGNATION OF SENATORS
- DEATH OF THE HONOURABLE ERIC LAIDLAW ROBINSON, M.P.
- MINISTERIAL ARRANGEMENTS
- PETITIONS
- STANDING ORDERS COMMITTEE
- AUSTRALIAN CONCILIATION AND ARBITRATION COMMISSION
-
QUESTIONS WITHOUT NOTICE
-
MINING PROJECTS: EMPLOYMENT
(Senator CARRICK) -
JAPAN: PURCHASE OF COAL
(Senator BONNER, Senator CARRICK) -
INVALID PENSIONS: PROCEDURES AND GUIDELINES
(Senator GRIMES, Senator CHANEY) -
INVALID PENSIONS: INSTITUTIONALISED HANDICAPPED PEOPLE
(Senator MISSEN, Senator CHANEY) -
AZARIA CHAMBERLAIN CASE
(Senator MULVIHILL, Senator PETER BAUME) -
AUSTRALIAN FILM INDUSTRY: TAX CONCESSION
(Senator PUPLICK, Senator Dame MARGARET GUILFOYLE) -
URANIUM
(Senator CHIPP, Senator CARRICK) -
RIVER MURRAY
(Senator TEAGUE, Senator CARRICK) -
AUSTRALIAN CAR MANUFACTURING INDUSTRY
(Senator BISHOP, Senator MESSNER) -
ABORIGINAL SCHOOL IN BRISBANE
(Senator MacGIBBON, Senator PETER BAUME) -
ABORIGINAL COMMUNITIES: ESSENTIAL SERVICES
(Senator ROBERTSON, Senator PETER BAUME) -
ADELAIDE AIRPORT
(Senator YOUNG, Senator MESSNER) -
APPROPRIATION FOR ABORIGINES IN THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
(Senator CAVANAGH, Senator PETER BAUME) -
RIVER MURRAY
(Senator JESSOP, Senator CARRICK) -
APPROPRIATION FOR ABORIGINES IN THE NORTHERN TERRITORY
(Senator RYAN, Senator PETER BAUME) -
RECORD ROYALTIES
(Senator PUPLICK, Senator DURACK) -
CHARACTER ASSESSMENTS
(Senator EVANS, Senator DURACK) -
AERIAL FIRE-FIGHTING
(Senator ARCHER, Senator CARRICK) -
TOXIC SHOCK SYNDROME
(Senator MELZER, Senator PETER BAUME) -
LIQUID HYDROCARBONS
(Senator MacGIBBON, Senator CARRICK) -
ABORIGINAL RIGHTS
(Senator COLEMAN, Senator PETER BAUME) -
FEDERAL BY-ELECTION RESULTS
(Senator TEAGUE, Senator CARRICK) -
CHILD CARE PROGRAM
(Senator McLAREN, Senator CHANEY) -
AUSTRALIAN BROADCASTING TRIBUNAL
(Senator BUTTON, Senator PETER BAUME) -
URANIUM MINING
(Senator JESSOP, Senator CARRICK)
-
MINING PROJECTS: EMPLOYMENT
- PRESENTATION OF PAPERS
- ADELAIDE AIRPORT
- PRESENTATION OF PAPERS
- ASSENT TO BILLS
- PARLIAMENTARY RETIRING ALLOWANCES TRUST
- AUSTRALIAN INSTITUTE OF ABORIGINAL STUDIES
- RETIREMENT OF PRINCIPAL PARLIAMENTARY REPORTER
- PRESENTATION OF PAPERS
- COMMONWEALTH OMBUDSMAN
- AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL RAILWAYS COMMISSION
- THE PRINCE OF WALES
- AUSTRALIAN NATIONAL RAILWAYS COMMISSION
- STATES GRANTS COMMISSIONS
- ADJOURNMENT
- ELECTION PETITION
- PAPERS
-
ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS
-
Barrow Island: Fauna Conservation Program
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Peter Baume) -
Whaling: Catch Quota of Minke Whales
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Peter Baume) -
Export of Koalas
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Messner) -
Yorke Peninsula: Fauna Refuge
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Messner) -
Electoral Advertisements
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Peter Baume) -
Convention on Endangered Fauna Species
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Messner) -
Western Australian Urban Lands Council
(Senator Rocher, Senator Carrick) -
Tertiary Education Assistance Scheme
(Senator Rocher, Senator Carrick) -
Department of Housing and Construction
(Senator Rocher, Senator Messner) -
Qantas Airways Stage I Project, Sydney
(Senator Rocher, Senator Messner) -
Aviation: Pilot Licences
(Senator Rocher, Senator Messner) -
Aviation: Pilot Licences
(Senator Rocher, Senator Messner) -
Ronald Anderson and Associates Pty Ltd
(Senator Walsh, Senator Chaney) -
Public Relations Consultants: Dual Employment by Statutory Authorities and Political Parties
(Senator Walsh, Senator Chaney) -
Sir Lenox Hewitt: Visits to Middle East Countries
(Senator Walsh, Senator Messner) -
Social Welfare: Beds for Disabled People
(Senator Grimes, Senator Chaney) -
Social Welfare Invalid Pensions: Medical Examinations
(Senator Grimes, Senator Peter Baume) -
Social Welfare: Cost of Raising Unemployment Benefit to Standard Rate
(Senator Grimes, Senator Chaney) -
Aviation: Upgrading of Albury Airport
(Senator Evans, Senator Messner) -
National Park in South-west Tasmania
(Senator Chipp, Senator Peter Baume) -
Freedom of Information Bill
(Senator Mason, Senator Durack) -
Orders Pursuant to s. 117A (7) of the Broadcasting and Television Act
(Senator Mason, Senator Peter Baume) -
Petrochemical Plant at Redcliff, South Australia
(Senator Mason, Senator Peter Baume) -
CB Radio: 27MHz Band
(Senator Chipp, Senator Peter Baume) -
Norfolk Island
(Senator Chipp, Senator Messner) -
Aircraft Passengers Suffering From Upper Respiratory Tract Infection
(Senator Chipp, Senator Messner) -
Social Welfare: Aged Married Couples
(Senator Grimes, Senator Chaney) -
Wheat: Striped Rust
(Senator Neal, Senator Chaney) -
Energy Gain in Alternative Energy Sources
(Senator Archer, Senator Carrick) -
Ethnic Television: Advertising Funds
(Senator Colston, Senator Peter Baume) -
Qantas Cabin Crews
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Messner) -
Recorded Books for the Blind
(Senator Ryan, Senator Messner) -
Cancer in Miners at Radium Hill
(Senator Mason, Senator Peter Baume) -
Education: Enrolments in Secondary Schools
(Senator Neal, Senator Carrick) -
Mail Contracts: Central Australia
(Senator Keeffe, Senator Peter Baume) -
Social Welfare: Supporting Parents Benefit
(Senator Colston, Senator Chaney) -
After-school Care Program: Gilles Street Primary School
(Senator Grimes, Senator Chaney) -
Trade Practices Act: Courses in Meditation
(Senator Teague, Senator Messner) -
Medical Benefits: Transcendental Meditation
(Senator Teague, Senator Peter Baume) -
Entry into Australia by Religious Cults
(Senator Teague, Senator Durack) -
Kangaroo Island: War Service Land Settlement Scheme
(Senator Cavanagh, Senator Chaney) -
Sydney Home Nursing Service
(Senator Sibraa, Senator Peter Baume) -
Department of Veterans' Affairs
(Senator Grimes, Senator Messner) -
Hospital Patients: Pension Benefits
(Senator MacGibbon, Senator Chaney) -
Antarctic Bases: Taxation Concessions
(Senator Primmer, Senator Dame Margaret Guilfoyle) -
Manned Light-stations
(Senator Button, Senator Durack) -
Delivered Meals Subsidy Act
(Senator Grimes, Senator Chaney) -
Food Production: Alternative Fuels
(Senator Kilgariff, Senator Carrick) -
National Employment and Training System
(Senator Ryan, Senator Dame Margaret Guilfoyle) -
Commonwealth Rebate for Apprentice Full-time Training Scheme
(Senator Ryan, Senator Dame Margaret Guilfoyle) -
Aboriginal Work Force
(Senator Ryan, Senator Dame Margaret Guilfoyle) -
Non-Aboriginal Australians: Access to Telephones
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) - Procedural Text
-
Conciliation and Arbitration Commission
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Chaney) -
International Labour Organisation
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Chaney) - Procedural Text
-
Television Translator: Airlie Beach
(Senator Colston, Senator Peter Baume) -
Brisbane Telephone Directory
(Senator Colston, Senator Peter Baume) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport Curfew
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport: Curfew
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Brisbane Airport
(Senator Colston, Senator Messner) -
Ex-service Benefits
(Senator Walsh, Senator Messner) -
Alleged Social Security Conspiracy Case: Legal Aid Payments
(Senator Grimes, Senator Durack) -
Nuclear Shelters in Perth and Fremantle
(Senator Chipp, Senator Durack) -
Trade Union Members Employed by Armed Services
(Senator Mason, Senator Durack) -
Broadcasting or Televising of Objectionable Items
(Senator Mason, Senator Peter Baume) -
Television: Teletext Service
(Senator Mason, Senator Peter Baume) -
Community Access Television
(Senator Chipp, Senator Peter Baume) -
Gladstone: Infrastructure and Funding Needs
(Senator Chipp, Senator Carrick) -
Commonwealth Centre, Chifley Square, Sydney: Security
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Peter Baume) -
Chemicals 2,4,5-T and 2,4-D
(Senator Colston, Senator Durack) -
Vietnam Veterans: Disability Pensions
(Senator Grimes, Senator Messner) -
Mail to Yugoslavia
(Senator Mulvihill, Senator Peter Baume) -
Defence of Government Schools Organisation: Court Costs
(Senator Evans, Senator Durack) -
Radio Licence: Mildura
(Senator Button, Senator Peter Baume) -
Electoral: Broadcasting and Television
(Senator Button, Senator Peter Baume) -
Live Sheep Exports
(Senator Primmer, Senator Chaney) -
Aid for Indonesia: Land Rovers
(Senator Primmer, Senator Durack) -
Medical Qualifications of Airlines Cabin Crews
(Senator Coleman, Senator Messner) -
Telephones: Cost of Services
(Senator Button, Senator Peter Baume) -
Solar Energy Research
(Senator Keeffe, Senator Carrick) -
Aborigines: Northern Territory Reserves
(Senator Kilgariff, Senator Peter Baume) -
Aboriginals: Unemployment Benefit
(Senator Ryan, Senator Chaney) -
Aboriginal Communities: Access to Telephones
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Aboriginal Reserves: Queensland
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Tranby Co-operative College
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Aboriginal Housing
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Aboriginal Communities: Sewerage and Electricity
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Water Supplies to Aboriginal Communities
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Aboriginal Health Workers
(Senator Ryan, Senator Peter Baume) -
Water Hyacinth
(Senator Robertson, Senator Durack)
-
Barrow Island: Fauna Conservation Program
Page: 7
Senator MISSEN
—My question is addressed to the Minister for Social Security. I draw the Minister's attention to a letter, a copy of which I have supplied to the Minister, which appeared in the Australian of 9 February 1981 and related to the invalid pension paid to handicapped people living in State institutions. I ask the Minister to comment on the letter and in particular the following claim:
Since the 1 January, 1981, any handicapped person of pensionable age admitted to an institution run by the State will receive the princely sum of $17.80 a fortnight to buy clothes, personal effects, toiletries, to spend on any outings and to save for long range events such as holidays.
Will the Minister inform the Senate why the pension received by such handicapped residents has been reduced from $44.80 to $17.80 a fortnight when at the same time the amount for maintenance going to the State has been increased from $93.40 to $120.40 a fortnight? Will he also inform the Senate what improvements in board might be effected as a result of the increased maintenance being paid to the State institutions? Does the Minister agree that the main goal of these institutions should be the rehabilitation of its handicapped residents into community living? Does the Minister also agree that in this the International Year of Disabled Persons the Government must take the lead if it is to achieve an enlightened attitude by the public towards handicapped people? If so, will he assure the Senate that consideration will be given to removing this Commonwealth-State arrangement which makes the rehabilitation of handicapped people living in State institutions even more difficult?
Senator CHANEY
—The honourable senator did provide me with a copy of the letter which appeared in the Australian but I had in fact seen it when it was published on 9 February. The matters raised in the letter in fact relate to charges which are made in State institutions in Queensland and relate to the net income which is available to invalid pensioners after they meet those charges. I think many honourable senators would be aware that the level of those charges is determined by the State and does not come within the Social Security portfolio. On the other hand, the social security legislation which applies to benevolent institutions does provide that where a pensioner is living in an approved benevolent home an amount equal to 87 1/2 per cent of the pension should be paid directly to the home in respect of his care and accommodation. In fact there are no benevolent homes in Queensland which are caught by that legislation but the State Government has tied the charges made in State nursing homes to the level specified for benevolent homes under the Commonwealth legislation. In fact, it is Commonwealth policy to achieve as great a uniformity as possible in the charges levied in respect of long term nursing home patients.
Whilst the matter of these charges referred to in the letter and referred to by Senator Missen in his question is a matter for the State, it is a fact that there is no uniformity of charging among benevolent homes, non-government nursing homes, public hospitals and most State nursing homes. The point which I think is the central point of Senator Missen's question is whether the charges and the amount which is left for the people concerned are in line with their need for rehabilitation. That is a particular point to which I have not given consideration. It may be that different considerations ought to apply in the circumstances of those institutions. In the case where full board and lodgings are in effect being provided in other forms of institutions, perhaps for the very old people who are in them, it may well be quite appropriate. Perhaps for others it is not. I will examine that aspect of the honourable senator's question and see whether I should add to that reply.

